Stop thumbing through crappy city-guides and join Thrillist: the best of what's new in your city, delivered once-daily, always free.

Get on the list

Thrillist New York
Emailed on: Thursday June 29, 2006

Steakhouse Rubric

With the recent openings of Craftsteak and the slightly more under-the-radar Staghorn, plus Wolfgang's Tribeca slated for July, you've got a glut of new steakhouses to rate. Because judging a steakhouse's worthiness is more science than art, we compiled this handy scoring system. Please use it in poor health.

STEAK

+3 For each person over 2 the biggest porterhouse can feed

+3 If options are broken down by the cow's breed, origin, and feed (+1 for each)

+1 For every week over 4 they dry-age their most senior steak

-3 If menu includes petit filet (<10oz), even if it's free

-4 If you leave without getting the meat-sweats

OTHER ENTRÉES

+2 If prime rib requires little trimming, and can be cut with fork

-2 If there's no surf & turf

+1 If delicious mutton chops are available

-3 If there's a menu section listed as "On the Lighter Side", "Healthy", etc

STARTERS AND SIDES

+2 If thick-cut bacon's available

-2 For no lettuce wedge on menu

+1 For every shrimp above four in the shrimp cocktail

+1 If creamed spinach is so thick, even furious shaking won't free it from spoon

LIQUOR AND WINE

+1 For each wine bottle under $40

+1 For each bottle over $1000

+1 For each multiple of 20 scotches available

-2 For the presence of a "specialty" cocktail menu

OLD SCHOOLNESS

+1 If the dominant motif is "Wood"

+1 If you can barely keep yourself from smoking

+1 If at least one staffer has vivid memories of WWII

SERVICE

+1 If you can walk-in w/o a reservation

-1 If you can walk-in w/o a reservation

+2 If waiter assumes everyone is ordering steak

+3 If waiter has a mustache

People Who Dug This Article Were Also Into...

Further Cheat Sheet + Rundown-ness

  • 16928.2223.jpg

    Idiot-Proof Super...

    This Super Sunday, be the bigdicked...

  • 1129

    Sunday Booze...

    Some people/gods consider Sunday a...

  • 1111

    BYOB Update

    Ideally, there should be a BYO for...

You Know You Love Steakhouses