The ultimate guide to NYC pizza places open 'til 4am or later
After a long night spent blowing your rent on delicious cinnamon shots and swiping right too many times on Tinder, your less-than-great decisions should be rewarded. Enter: pizza, everyone’s best late-ass-night friend.
But where to find that super-past-bedtime slice? We’ve got the answer with this master list of NYC pizza joints open 'til 4am or later, conveniently organized by neighborhood because we know those delicious cinnamon shots are preventing you from figuring it out otherwise.
Archie’s Bar & Pizza
128 Central Avenue
Details: Open 'til 4am Monday – Saturday
OMG Pizza Brooklyn
1307 Myrtle Avenue
Details: Open 'til 4:30am daily
Extra Cheese: This diner-style joint means you can* get your pizza with a side of cheeseburger and eggs. (*will)
Josho’s Pizza Palace
171 Starr Street
Details: Open 24 hours daily. Boosh.
South Brooklyn Pizza
451 Court Street
Details: Open 'til 4am daily
Extra Cheese: This parlor shares a back garden with a bar, meaning you can keep drinking and get your pizza on 'til all hours of the night.
Artichoke Basille’s Pizza
114 10th Avenue
Details: Open 'til 5am Tuesday-Saturday
Rocky’s Brick Oven Pizza
304 W 14th Street
Details: Open 'til 5am daily
Extra Cheese: With slices like Bacon Ranch Tomato & Penne alla Vodka, you can’t go wrong with this Chelsea staple.
Famous Amadeus Pizza
408 8th Avenue
Details: Open 'til 4:45am Tuesday-Saturday
Extra Cheese: Stumbling out of Madison Square Garden? Enjoy a slice at this long-running joint, situated right outside Penn Station.
2 Bros. Pizza
601 6th Avenue
Details: Open 'til 4am Thursday-Saturday
Pizza Gaga
171 W 23rd Street
Details: Open 'til 5am Thursday-Saturday
Great Burrito
100 W 23rd Street
Details: Open 24 hours daily
Extra Cheese: Mexican & pizza all under one roof? Best news ever.
Ganni’s Pizza
652 Myrtle Avenue
Details: Open 'til 4am daily
South Brooklyn Pizza
320 Court Street
Details: Open 'til 4am daily
Artichoke Basille’s Pizza
328 E 14th Street
Details: Open 'til 5am daily
Extra Cheese: Stick with the slice that made them famous, the classic Artichoke.
Lil Frankie’s Pizza
19 1st Avenue
Details: Open 'til 4am Friday & Saturday
East Village Pizza & Kebabs
145 1st Avenue
Details: Open 'til 5am daily
Extra Cheese: Pizza & falafel. It’s practically health food.
Fat Sal’s Pizza
201 Avenue A
Details: Open 'til 4am Tuesday-Saturday
Stromboli Pizza
83 St. Mark’s Place
Details: Open 'til 5am daily
A Slice of Naples Pizza
334b Bowery
Details: Open 'til 4am Thursday-Saturday
99 Cents Fresh Pizza
71 2nd Avenue
Details: Open 24 hours daily
Extra Cheese: Dollar slices. ‘Round the clock. Hell yes.
Nino’s Pizza
131 St. Marks Place
Details: Open 'til 5am daily
Krust Pizzeria
226 E 14th Street
Details: Open 'til 5am Friday & Saturday
Extra Cheese: $1 hot dogs, pretzels, and pizza. Together at last.
Vinny Vincenz
231 1st Avenue
Details: Open 'til 4:30am Friday & Saturday
FDR 99 Cents Slice Pizza
150 E 2nd Street
Details: Open 'til 4am daily, 5am Friday & Saturday
Muzzarella Pizza
221 Avenue A
Details: Open 'til 4am Friday & Saturday
Solo Pizza
27 Avenue B
Details: Open 'til 4am Friday & Saturday
Extra Cheese: Way more than just a pizza place, it's actually a sandwiches-pastas-calzones-pizza place.
Harry’s Italian Pizza Bar
2 Gold Street
Details: Open 'til 4am Thursday-Saturday
Steve’s Pizza
110 Trinity Place
Details: Open 'til 5:30am daily
Extra Cheese: No frills about this joint, but the pizza is fast, reliable, and tasty.
Joe’s Pizza
150 E 14th Street
Details: Open 'til 4:30am daily
Extra Cheese: From the folks at the original Joe’s on Carmine St, this new outpost delivers solid slices you can rely on. Since, remember, they're solid.
Bravo Pizza
115 E 14th Street
Details: Open 'til 4am Friday
Artichoke Basille’s Pizza
111 Macdougal Street
Details: Open 'til 5am Friday & Saturday
Bleecker Street Pizza
69 7th Avenue South
Details: Open 'til 5am Friday & Saturday
Extra Cheese: This famous parlor is still churning out drool-worthy slices, even as the sun comes up.
Olio e Piú
3 Greenwich Avenue
Details: Open 24 hours daily
Extra Cheese: Because maybe you still have one more drink in you at 5am, this place serves alcohol (legally?) 24 hours a day, too.
99 Cents Fresh Pizza
388 6th Avenue
Details: Open 'til 4am Thursday-Saturday
Joe’s Pizza
7 Carmine Street
Details: Open 'til 4:30am daily
Extra Cheese: One of the city's longest standing pizzerias. So: legit.
Karavas Pizza ‘N’ Pita
108 7th Avenue South
Details: Open 'til 4am daily
Percy’s Pizza
190 Bleecker Street
Details: Open 'til 5am Friday & Saturday
Little Italy Pizza
122 University Place
Details: Open 24 hours daily
Famous Original Ray’s Pizza
195 E Houston Street
Details: Open 'til 5am daily
Rosario's Pizza
173 Orchard Street
Details: Open 'til 5am Friday & Saturday
Extra Cheese: One of the best slices in the city, especially the Sicilian.
Nonna’s LES Pizza
105 Clinton Street
Details: Open 'til 4am Friday & Saturday
Uncle Paul’s Pizza
70 Vanderbilt Avenue
Details: Open 24 hours daily
Extra Cheese: Catching a train at Grand Central? Pit stop here. Or don't, it's your life.
99 Cents Fresh Pizza
151 E 43rd Street
Details: Open 'til 4am daily
Little Italy Pizza
2 East 33rd Street
Details: Open 24 hours daily
Famous Original Ray’s Pizza
736 7th Avenue
Details: Open 'til 5am daily
Extra Cheese: Which Ray’s is really the original? No one knows (except maybe Ray?), but this chain delivers high-quality slices you can count on.
Famous Original Ray’s Pizza
831 7th Avenue
Details: Open 'til 5am daily
99 Cents Fresh Pizza
569 9th Avenue
Details: Open 24 hours daily
Fat Sal’s Pizza
730 10th Avenue
Details: Open 'til 4am Tuesday-Saturday
Famous Amadeus Pizza
840 8th Avenue
Details: Open 'til 4:45am Tuesday-Saturday
2 Bros. Pizza
557 8th Avenue
Details: Open 24 hours daily
Extra Cheese: Founded in the East Village before expanding throughout the city, this chain brings a more polished feel to the dollar-slice game. Also: Bros.
Carve Unique Sandwiches & Pizza
760 8th Avenue
Details: Open 24 hours daily
Extra Cheese: The pizza might draw you in, but the awesome assortment of freshly carved sandwiches are the real star of this unassuming spot (sorry, pizza).
Empire Pizza
314 5th Avenue
Details: Open 'til 5am Friday & Saturday
Little Italy Pizza
401 7th Avenue
Details: Open 24 hours daily
Rocky’s Number II
607 2nd Avenue
Details: Open 'til 4:30am daily
Pizza 33
489 3rd Avenue
Details: Open 'til 4am Friday & Saturday
Extra Cheese: Order one of their epic lasagna or baked ziti slices, because obviously.
Dough Boys Pizza
451 3rd Avenue
Details: Open 'til 5am Friday & Saturday
Extra Cheese: A stacked array of slices, rolls, and heros one block from Brother Jimmy’s? Yeah, buddy.
Pizza & Pita
344 E 34th Street
Details: Open 'til 4:30am Friday & Saturday
Joe’s Pizza of the Village
483 5th Avenue
Details: Open 'til 4am daily, 5am Friday & Saturday
American Cheez
444 7th Avenue
Details: Open 'til 4am daily
Famous Original Ray’s Pizza
1827 2nd Avenue
Details: Open 'til 4am Friday & Saturday
Two Boots Pizza
1617 2nd Avenue
Details: Open 'til 4am Friday & Saturday
Fat Sal’s Pizza
1603 2nd Avenue
Details: Open 'til 4am Tuesday-Saturday
Extra Cheese: Keep the popped-collar party going at this joint just down the block from Dorrian’s.
Papa John’s
1732 2nd Avenue
Details: Open 'til 5am Friday & Saturday
Extra Cheese: Reliable pies with a chocolate chip cookie “pizza” on the side.
Roma Pizza
1568 3rd Avenue
Details: Open 'til 4am Friday & Saturday
Famous Original Ray’s Pizza
462 Columbus Avenue
Details: Open 'til 5am Friday & Saturday
Pizza By La Grolla
403 Amsterdam Avenue
Details: Open 'til 4am Friday & Saturday
Francesco's Pizzeria
186 Columbus Avenue
Details: Open 'til 4am Friday & Saturday
Extra Cheese: You need to order the "I Love Lucy" by the pie, but with a combo of goat cheese, mozzarella, and pesto sauce, it’s worth the late-night splurge/having tomorrow-morning leftovers (maybe).
Little Italy Pizza
214 W 92nd Street
Details: Open 'til 4:30am Friday & Saturday
Little Italy Pizza
2047 Broadway
Details: Open 24 hours daily
Extra Cheese: Get a specialty slice -- either the chipotle chicken or sweet & spicy calamari. Rinse. Repeat. (But don't actually rinse.)
Grandma Rose’s Pizza
457 Graham Avenue
Details: Open 'til 5am Friday & Saturday
Two Boots Pizza
558 Driggs Avenue
Details: Open 'til 4am Friday & Saturday
Extra Cheese: Duuuude you can/should order "The Dude", which's predictably a Cajun/bacon cheeseburger slice.
Christine Fischer is a freelance writer dedicated to a strict diet of Champagne, cookies, and the occasional pizza. Follow her on Facebook and Instagram.