thrillist

Nothing but Grande, WI cheeses and Stanislaus tomatoes are used by this FND institution, which also makes its dough daily, then lets it sit a full 48hrs to ensure crusty perfection before adorning it with ultra-fresh toppings and either popping it in the oven or packing it as a take 'n bake. They've also got some of the meatiest wings around, best consumed with their "lip numbing" hot sauce, which is why Pizza Guy doubles as a plastic-surgery prep room for Hollywood collagen recipients. Suck on that, Hollywood...with your fat collagen lips!

Add to My Thrillist

Choose take 'n bake for $2 off the price. If you don't like it, bring back 1/2 of it: they'll analyze it, offer suggestions, and replace it. Check the menu right here.

See the rest of our Favorite 5 Pizza Pies here, because every day should be a pizza day