Sugar & Plumm The best place in NY for fishbowl sundaes and fried chicken

Keep My Thrillist organized with checklists

Add to Checklist

My Note

Add Note

Making you want to be rolled around by Oompa Loompas like no place else in NYC, part sweets temple, part pulled-pork-slinger Sugar and Plumm Gene Wilds out with a candy stripe-lit, purple 'n white interior featuring a mosaic ode to all things dessert.


Up front sit bins upon bins of by-the-pound candy and an ice cream counter, at which you can grab milkshakes including a waffle & candied bacon job to-go, even if you're just to-going to the leather-banquette'd sit-down cafe to snag sweet waffles savoried up with crispy free range chicken, bacon, or 72hr-smoked pulled pork.


Also ridiculous: bread pudding brulee, Heaven/Hell cake, cheesecake, Key lime pie, Brooklyn Blackout cake, salted caramel ice cream, and fresh-whipped Hudson Valley cream all shoved into a fishbowl and called the Earthquake, although the 6'7'', 468lb wrestler surely would've called it "ARRGHGRHRGH".


To take the edge off after taking down 35 consecutive Warheads and an Earthquake, the cocktail program's chock-full of bacon-infused bourbon and spiked milkshakes, which should get you feeling good enough to also get after a Maine lobster roll w/ lemon aioli, or the roasted salsa verde/ fried duck egg/ Muenster Fog City Burger, although the only thing rolling into or out of this place will be you, Oompa Loompas or not.

Keep My Thrillist organized with checklists

Add to Checklist

My Note

Add Note

Sugar & Plumm

Published: August 21, 2012 at 4:00am EDT

377 Amsterdam Ave

New York, NY 10024

212.787.8778

Other Stories You Will Like

Be the first to know about the newest restaurants, bars, & events in your hood.

Hot Right Now

Nearby

More Eat

More on Thrillist

Tell your friends what they should be doing.