Pitch & Fork An "everyman tavern" with eats the everyman can't make

Keep My Thrillist organized with checklists

Add to Checklist

My Note

Add Note

Perhaps not wanting to attract any angry villagers, the team behind Pitch & Fork (Jacques & 1534) decided the UES was the best location for their American tavern, a dimly lit casual hang with black vinyl banquettes, a heavy walnut presence (benches, bar, moldings...), and a backyard garden that's covered, so you know it's not Savage.

Blending in influences from the owner's French roots, the 'merican fare kicks off with smoked salt & pepper St. Louis Ribs, crispy fried rabbit legs, and pig foot "trotter tots", so it would behoove you to eat them.

Seconds stay heart-threateningly hearty, from a bacon/Irish cheddar burger on brioche, to chicken pot pie w/ spaetzle, while massive "Grand Courses" for 2-3 include porchetta w/ whole grain mustard jus, and a gargantuan roasted rib eye with onions and creamed black kale, though if it's such a super food, shouldn't it not be getting creamed?

The bev program is no afterthought: carefully curated suds like Breckenridge's Agave Wheat sit beside Manhattans made with blueberry-infused bourbon and Baked Apple bitters, which is apparently no longer just a nickname for all those angry villagers.

Keep My Thrillist organized with checklists

Add to Checklist

My Note

Add Note

Pitch & Fork

Published: June 26, 2012 at 4:00am EDT

1606 First Ave

New York, NY 10028

212.288.1003

Other Stories You Will Like

Be the first to know about the newest restaurants, bars, & events in your hood.

Hot Right Now

Nearby

More Eat

More on Thrillist

Tell your friends what they should be doing.