Big Mario's Pizza Big Mario's New York Style Pizza

Named for a former NYC pizza impresario who's friends with the owners (instead of what you'd better be when you finally find the Tanooki Suit on World 4, Level 5), this 'za-slinging institution makes our Favorite 5 by being Cap Hill's go-to spot for choice pie by the slice, and tongue-in-cheek brew options like PBR and 40s of Olde English.