New York

The meticulously punctual NY bankers behind timepiece blog Hodinkee are now at your beck and call: hit their Find a Watch page, drop your contact info and desired elements (leather strap or metal, chronograph or moonphase, a rare brand, etc), and they'll hit you back with suggestions/purchase info -- usually w/in three days, quicker if you're name's Parker Lewis, and apparently you can lose your Swatch.