Allied: Fantasy Team Name Nightmarification Because your current name is just too full of hope

Keep My Thrillist organized with checklists

Add to Checklist

My Note

Add Note

Once a player turns your fantasy season into a nightmare like the one poor Jon's having up there, you should absolutely change your overly optimistic team name to something appropriately miserable. Here're some prime examples of that excruciating-but-kinda-fun process, using some all-time great fantasy killers.

The Victory Guarantor: Chris Johnson
Fantasy Name: CJ2KO
Rationale: 2000+ rushing yards and 16 TDs will knock everybody out.
Nightmare Name: Chrisappointing
Rationale: 1364 rushing yards and 12 TDs will only knock some people out. 1047/4 only knocks out Peter McNeeley.

The Surefire Comeback: Larry Johnson
Fantasy Name: Yards Per Larry
Rationale: LJ is too good not to come back strong.
Nightmare Name: Three Yards Per Larry
Rationale: LJ was not too good not to come back strong.

The Devastating Injury: Jamaal Charles
Fantasy Name: Jamaal Night Long
Rationale: Jamaal Charles' explosive numbers will have you singing “Tam bo li de say de moi ya/Hey Jambo Jumbo/Way to parti o we goin'/Oh, jambali/Tam bo li de say de moi ya/Yeah, Jambo, jumbo!”
Nightmare Name: JamACL Charles
Rationale: It's not his fault, but it's still incredibly painful. For you. And your fantasy team.

The Looked Amazing in Limited Appearances Guy: Kevin Kolb
Fantasy Name: Kolb as Ice, narrowly beating out Kevin Sent
Rationale: “He's the first QB in NFL history to throw for 300+ in his first two starts, and now he's throwing to a little guy I like to call THE BEST RECEIVER IN THE NFL. Also, Foreigner is totally underrated.”
Nightmare Name: Kevin and Hell, narrowly beating out How Can Kevin Kolb Suck This Bad?
Rationale: You now hate Foreigner.

The Biggest Bust Ever, Including Probably Man-Bra Size: JaMarcus Russell
Fantasy Name: Do The Russell!
Rationale: Anyone who can throw a ball 70 yards off his knees is clearly the real (Van) McCoy
Nightmare Name: Russell and Blow
Rationale: If the Raiders/fantasy owners had done their homework, they would've discovered Terrence Howard was actually a better pro QB prospect. So was Anthony Anderson, for that matter.

The Second Year Bust: Steve Slaton
Fantasy Name: A.C. Slaton
Rationale: His freakish athleticism makes everyone else on the field look like Screech.
Nightmare Name: Moats from the Underground
Rationale: Because the most promising all-around back in the league fumbled 800 times and got beaten out by Ryan Moats. And because you want everyone to think you read Dostoevsky, which is a weird lie to tell a bunch of guys in a fantasy football league.

The Actually Over-the-Hill Gang: 2011 Pittsburgh Steelers Defense
Fantasy Name: Order of the Smith Lords
Rationale: Sure Aaron Smith gets hurt all the time but he's the heart and soul of a defense that was the fantasy world's best in 2010.
Nightmare Name: Step PUP 2: The Streets
Rationale: Aaron Smith got hurt again. So did everybody else who sacked quarterbacks, intercepted passes, or recovered fumbles -- basically this D was like a Step Up sequel Channing Tatum barely appeared in.

The Madden Cursed: Peyton Hillis
Fantasy Name: The Hillises Have Eyes
Rationale: The 2nd coming of John Riggins will tear apart defenses like a savage hill mutant, which he might actually be, since he's from Conway, Arkansas.
Nightmare Name: What You Talkin' 'Bout, Hillis?
Rationale: The dude just flat-out disappeared, like Different Strokes' Todd Bridges did during the years he was shooting drug dealers and stabbing guys with kitchen knives.

The Perpetual Disappointment: DeAngelo Williams
Fantasy Name: DeAngeLo-Mein
Rationale: After a season riddled with injury, this talented player is as hungry as a guy who had Chinese food four hours ago.
Nightmare Name: It Puts the DeAngelotion in the Basket
Rationale: DeAngelo Williams will throw your fantasy season in the bottom of a well.

The I'm-Gonna-Out-Guess-Everyone Guy: Chastin West
Fantasy Name: Chastin West Coast Offense
Rationale: “Blaine Gabbert has to throw to somebody, and this kid's 5 inches taller than Mike Thomas."
Nightmare Name: Chastiny Belt
Rationale: Apparently Blaine Gabbert doesn't have to throw to anybody, because Chastin West is not scoring.

Keep My Thrillist organized with checklists

Add to Checklist

My Note

Add Note

Fantasy Team Name Nightmarification

Published: July 26, 2012 at 4:00am EDT

Other Stories You Will Like

Tell your friends what they should be doing.