19. Coconut Oreo Thins
I love coconut milk, coconut water, coconut flakes, and Jason Schwartzman’s solo project Coconut Records. I also love Coco Austin, Ice-T’s wife. With so much real coconut in the average American’s diet these days, it’s tough to get excited about this fairly bland, artificially flavored coconut creme.
18. Lemon Oreo Thins
The lemon flavor creme here is a little too Lemon Pledge-like and not enough Savannah Smiles for me. That said, I’m not kicking this Oreo out of bed. As in, I will literally eat the entirety of this package in bed later tonight.
I have to admit that I didn’t grow up loving Peeps. I hold no warm place in my heart for that bird-shaped monstrosity some people think is good junk food. Give me Cadbury Eggs all day. So I was a little nervous to taste this. But it’s not horrible! I wouldn’t say it tastes exactly like Peeps, and that’s probably why I like it! If I can put myself in the shoes of someone who loves Peeps for a moment (and I believe I can), the texture is part of the Peeps experience. You don’t get that in this cookie, obviously. Instead, there’s a flavor creme that tastes like Peeps that’ve been out in the sun for too long. Buy this for the brand synergy if you want to, but I’d recommend buying actual Peeps if you want that sweet, sweet Peeps flavor.