Food & Drink

Top Bartenders Pick Chicago's Most Underrated Bars

Published On 02/09/2016 Published On 02/09/2016
Courtesy of Whitney Morrow

We at Thrillist take pride in championing the underrated, from pizza to tacos to donuts. But we're not the only ones who see value in the underdog. On the topic of underrated Chicago bars -- places where you can have a low-key, but equally enjoyable night out -- who would know better than some of the city's best bartenders themselves? We gave these 12 mixologists a break from trying to locate the damn credit card you left at the bar (again) and asked them to name their favorite under-the-radar spots.

Whitney Morrow of Drumbar

Her pick: Tuman's Tap and Grill (address and info)

Ukrainian Village
Formerly known as the "Alcohol Abuse Center," Tuman's has come a long way since its sketchier, more divey past (or gone way downhill, depending on how you look at it). What hasn't changed is the always friendly, cool yet unpretentious crowd, so, yes, you can still abuse your alcohol as long as you're not a total a dick about it.
Whitney says: "Tuman's has some killer bar food. I hesitate to even call it bar food because the salads and small plates are similar to things you see at elevated dinner spots. It is a neighborhood bar where I can almost always find a seat at the bar, a decently priced shot of whiskey, and a great tap beer selection."

Courtesy of Scotty LoBianco

Scotty LoBianco of Broken Shaker

His pick: Black Bull (address and info)

Wicker Park
If you walk in here not knowing what the hell a porron or copita is, don't worry, you’re not alone. By the time you leave you will, or at least you’ll have the chance to hit upstairs lounge Bordel, one of Chicago’s finest secret bars.
Scotty says: "Black Bull is an authentic Spanish restaurant with a focus on sherry and Spanish wines. The staff treats you like family and the cocktails are constantly evolving, while never straying far from their Spanish roots. I like to enjoy a glass (or entire porron) of cider with a copita of sherry on the side."

Courtesy of Henry Prendergast

Henry Prendergast of Analogue

His pick: Guthries Tavern (address and info)

Lakeview
Can be considered a sanctuary in a jungle of character-less sports pubs and faux country bars.
Henry says: "It has great beers, a super laid-back, old-school Chicago corner-tavern vibe -- without being depressing -- and a great board game selection. It is also free of douchebags and flat-screen TVs, even though it is steps from Wrigley Field, which is quite the achievement. As an added bonus, the bar is right down the street from my beloved Red Hot Ranch, which also has the most underrated, and best burger in town.”
 

Peter Vestinos of Sparrow/The Betty

His pick: Ten Cat Tavern (address and info)

Lakeview
Driving on Ashland is stressful enough. Drinking doesn't have to be. At least it's not at Ten Cat, where you can escape the whizzing cars and surrounding bro culture by chilling in the dark with a few friends listening to BB King by the fireplace (or outdoor patio in summer). You might even run into the Tamale Guy. Or one of them, at least.
Peter says: "I am sure you have driven past it a dozen times and never realized there was a bar there. Nothing fancy, but it has this great laid-back, New Orleans corner bar-like feel to the space. The best pool tables in the city and a great jukebox. Don’t look for any craft beer or spirits here."

Courtesy of Micah Melton

Micah Melton of The Aviary/The Office

His pick: Galway Bay (address and info)

Lincoln Park
Sandwiched in between typically uninspired Lincoln Park offerings like Yak-Zies and Duffy’s, Galway Bay is a true diamond in the rough. If you consider dive bars diamonds (which you totally should). Post up in front of the wall of old-school NES games (Donkey Kong, anyone?) and get comfy. You could be here a while.
Micah says: "Cheap beer, popcorn, darts, pool, Buck Hunter, Nintendo, Super Nintendo, and Nintendo 64s with tons of games."

Courtesy of Eric Henry

Eric Henry of The Whistler

His pick: Smallbar (address and info)

Avondale
Seeing as it's one of the finest beer bars in all of Chicago, we’re certainly no strangers to the appeal so many fans of the original Smallbar speak of. With its former Wicker Park location now Pub Royale and one of the best new restaurants of 2015, you still can’t go wrong even if you stumble into the wrong bar.
Eric says: "Even as the Logan Square bar and restaurant scene has exploded around them, Smallbar hasn't changed what they do: curate an outstanding locally focused draft list, offer a wide range of spirits, serve solid bar food, and keep a friendly, unassuming staff."

Courtesy of Doug Phillips

Doug Phillips of Slippery Slope/The Heavy Feather

His pick: Logan Arcade (address and info)

Logan Square
If you’re a gaming nerd into Killer Queen, this is the only place to publicly play it in Chicago. If you don’t know what the hell that is, not to worry. There are plenty of other noteworthy distractions here, like a signed edition of Star Trek: The Next Generation -- the pinball game, not the VHS cassette series (although that would also be sweet).
Doug says: "It reminds me of arcades of my childhood that happen to have a bar there for the adult in me. Seriously, it has three rooms filled with arcades you haven't thought about in 20 years! This is my favorite winter bar. I don't feel bad sitting in the dark playing video games and eating pizza while throwing one back."
 

Sean McNeilly of Sink | Swim

His pick: Bob Inn (address and info)

Logan Square
You bob in, you bob out. That's the way it's done at Bob Inn. That's the way it's always been done. 
Sean says: "Great place to get a low-key drink and a pool table that's almost always open."

Courtesy of Galdones Photography

Julia Momose of GreenRiver

Her pick: The Drinkingbird (address and info)

Lincoln Park
Sometimes location is everything, and Drinkingbird nails it not just due to its proximity to one of Chicago's finest pizza joints, but also next to one of the only other places in the neighborhood you can muster up the energy to visit in winter: Regal Webster Place 11. Stop in before and/or after the movie and if you’re foolish enough not to grab Pequod’s on the way home, Drinkingbird's burger makes an excellent alternative.
Julia says: "This bar is just a little bit out of the way, but well worth the trip. Located next to Pequod's Pizza, or Clybourn and Webster, The Drinkingbird has a fantastic balance between neighborhood spot and cocktail bar. You can trust the bartenders here. They know how to make a delicious balanced cocktail, or whatever it is that you fancy."

Courtesy of Derek Richmond

Cristiana DeLucca of Maple & Ash

Her pick: Clark Street Ale House (address and info)

River North
Known (to some, but not many) as one of the few places in Chicago to serve cask ale made with a hand pump (in addition to 100 bottled beers and over 300 whiskeys), this oasis for beer nerds isn't just a place to escape the hordes of tourists jockeying for parking in front of Blue Chicago. It's also one of Chicago’s most dog-friendly bars... especially if your dog is into cask ale.
Cristiana says: "There's a big neon sign out front that says, 'Stop and Drink,' so one day I did and I've been hooked ever since. They have extensive beer and whiskey lists, a great staff, and a 4am liquor license, so they're beloved by industry folks but I don't know if that many people actually know that it's there!"
 

His pick: Brindille (address and info)

River North
If you’ve opted for exotic frog legs, 200+ Old World wines, and magnum pours of Champagne in River North over another Public House bro-down, congratulations: you've made a wise decision.
Steve says: "It is a bar that offers an elegant and comfortable experience. The theme from its inception is 'refined Parisian.' It complements the extraordinary French fare with sophisticated wines and cocktails that are designed specifically to complement the dining experience. The absinthe program is another aspect that has remained a hidden gem in the city."

Courtesy of Liz Pearce

Liz Pearce of The Drifter

Her pick: Five Star Bar (address and info)

West Town
Although this place was once "so hot right now" back in the days when you could pair a trip to the bar with a visit to the always bumping Sonotheque (now Beauty Bar), Five Star's reputation may have cooled a bit but that's just how the regulars like it. Any bar with a "Hunter S. Thompson for Sheriff" poster on its wall is more than OK in our book.
Liz says: "Great beer list, cheap whiskey, awesome snacks, and the sassiest staff in town."

Sign up here for our daily Chicago email and be the first to get all the food/drink/fun in town.

Jay Gentile is a Thrillist contributor and proud owner of his very own "Thompson for Sheriff" poster. Inquire about visiting hours: @innerviewmag.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
1. Tuman's Tap & Grill 2159 W Chicago Ave, Chicago, IL 60622 (Ukrainian Village)

Tuman's Tap & Grill features a seasonally rotating American menu with signature selections, 28 draft crafts, and seasonal outdoor seating.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
2. Black Bull Tapas 1721 W Division St, Chicago, IL 60622 (Wicker Park)

The former Angels & Mariachis space has received a Spanish-style makeover, with tiles imported from Grenada, and metal cage chandeliers overlooking the reclaimed stablewood bar where they're serving up sangria in glass-blown pitchers, and cocktails like the rum/green chartreuse/raspberry Expatriate. As for grub, bites include salt-cod-stuffed piquillo peppers, mussel croquettes, and huevos rotos, aka, thick-cut fries that are covered in fried eggs 'n chorizo.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
3. Guthrie's Tavern 1300 W Addison St, Chicago, IL 60613 (Lakeview)

A Great Lakes draft and a side of Scrabble. That's what this tavern specializes in: beer, wine and board games. In the summer, a seat out on the back patio will allow you to enjoy the breeze while waiting for the next round of Apples-to-Apples while winter time may find you staring at the ceiling art in search of your next play for Scrabble.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
4. Ten Cat Tavern 3931 N Ashland Ave, Chicago, IL 60613 (Lakeview)

Fact: There are not, in fact, 10 cats that frequent this bar. However, dogs are welcome so you will find some of them.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
5. Galway Bay 500 W Diversey Pkwy, Chicago, IL 60614-1610 (Lincoln Park)

Named after a large island on the west coast of Ireland, Galway Bay is an authentic dive through and through. Like any great Irish bar, the beer's free following, the crowd is local and friendly, and the vibe is casual, sometimes verging on raucous. And the best part? Galway Bar has couches. You're welcome.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
6. SmallBar 2956 N Albany Ave, Chicago, IL 60618 (Logan Square)

Sandwiched in the middle of a residential block, Small Bar has somehow stood the tests of time as a hip neighborhood bar. As the name would suggest this isn't the place to come looking for 50 taps, but even the most cynical beer nerd will inevitably find something that makes him or her say, "Oh damn, I really want to try that." Slip through the kitchen and into the laid-back patio, order a burger and you'll feel like you're in a friend’s backyard.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
7. Logan Arcade 2410 W Fullerton Ave, Chicago, IL 60647 (Logan Square)

Located in the original Logan Hardware building, this arcade/bar houses a collection of vintage pinball, video games, and serves up 20 quality draft beers and a large selection of other alcoholic beverages.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
8. Bob Inn 2609 W Fullerton Ave, Chicago, IL 60647 (Logan Square)

Duck into this Logan Square bar that's been a neighborhood fave since it opened in 1945. The family owned and operated spot is a dive to the max; they offer cheap brews, strong cocktails, and generous pours in a low-key, locals-only environment. Also be sure to check out the pool tables in the back of the bar.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
9. Brindille 65 W Illinois St, Chicago, IL 60654 (River North)

Brindille is a French restaurant (by acclaimed chef Carrie Nahabedian) that's dishing out frog legs, old-world wines, and absinthe in River North.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
10. The Drinkingbird 2201 N Clybourn, Chicago, IL 60614 (Lincoln Park)

A '60s-inspired cocktail lounge sporting retro neon signage behind the bar, and a turquoise-hooded pool table near the remote control fireplace, the D-bird's backing up cocktails like the Royal Bermuda Yacht Club (Flor de Cana/Velvet Falernum/Cointreau) and the gin/maraschino/chartreuse Last Word with edibles exemplified by pork rillettes w/ house-baked challah and bourbon butter, which Louis XIV liked to put on everything.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
11. Clark Street Ale House 742 N Clark St, Chicago, IL 60610 (River North)

The fun and relaxed atmosphere inside this bar continues outside to their 1,000 square foot beer garden patio. They offer 24 microbrews on tap and over a hundred bottled beers, and feature a Caske Ale that they serve using a hang pump to give a more hop-y flavor and less carbonation.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
12. Five Star Bar 1424 W Chicago Ave, Chicago, IL 60642 (West Town)

This West Town spot features a rock n' roll-style vibe and a 75ft, L-shaped bar doling out a number of creative cocktails, beers, and a Bloody Mary that you should write home about.

Clickbait