Food & Drink

The Best Bloody Marys in Louisville

Published On 09/28/2015 Published On 09/28/2015
Courtesy of Chris Witzke
Courtesy of Garage Bar

Garage Bar

Who knew Bloody Marys and Kentucky country ham were the perfect pair? We can thank Garage Bar for this act of brilliance, its original Butchertown Bloody a clever twist on the typical vodka + tomato juice + olive we’ve come to know and love. Locally distilled brandy courtesy of Copper and Kings replaces the clear booze in this scenario and is shaken with a spicy house-made tomato base, the aforementioned Kentucky country ham a proverbial cherry on top.

Courtesy of Megan Hook from The Outlook Inn

Outlook Inn

Since its creation in 1974, the Bloody Mary at the Outlook Inn has set the bar for what it means to be a good -- nay, great -- Bloody Mary in this city. The secret? Well, the bar won’t share all of the details, but it doe attribute a great deal of its flavor to the fact that every single Bloody Mary is handmade, on the spot. The mix is never batched, not even during the insanity of the Derby or the debauchery that is the Highlands St. Paddy’s Day Parade. We have our suspicions that the copious amount of vodka included in the recipe doesn’t hurt its popularity either...

Courtesy of Emilie Pfeiffer of The Bristol

The Bristol

If you need one reason to go Downtown for brunch here it is: the Bristol’s Bloody Mary bar. Only offered at its Main St digs, the Bloody Mary bar is served every Saturday and Sunday until 3pm and comes with all of the traditional trappings, allowing you to spice, pickle, and veg up your Bloody to whatever level your heart desires.

Courtesy of Chris Witzke


When Chef Anthony Lamas puts his mind to something there is no doubt it is going to be amazing. Such is the case with Seviche’s Chef’s Bloody Mary, crafted with the signature Bloody Mary mix Chef Lamas created in conjunction with American Beverage Marketers. Add a colorful and spicy rim of Tajín Clásico seasoning to the glass and stuff it to the brim with veggies pickled in-house and you’ll be settling in for seconds in no time, a fresh order of the tuna old-fashioned seviche coming right up.

Courtesy of Ashley Towning

Against the Grain

Voted Louisville’s best Bloody Mary at the Finlandia Bloody Mary contest, which takes place every year during the Derby Festival, Against the Grain takes authenticity to the max, putting an original touch on every element of its Bloody, including the vodka. Macerated with fresh herbs and vegetables, the vodka is blended with house-made tomato mix and served with a variety of toppings, each pickled, smoked, cured, and offered up on Sundays, buffet style. 

Courtesy of Selena’s


The Creole flair of Selena’s Bloody Mary is what sets it apart, an added kick expressed thanks to the Absolut Peppar vodka used to craft this reasonably priced hangover must. A touch of Cajun seasoning in the mix adds that certain something to this hair-of-the-dog drink that is oh so necessary on a Saturday morning after a late night at the bars.

Courtesy of Blue Dog Bakery & Cafe

Blue Dog Bakery

With one of the best brunch menus in the city, it should come as no surprise that Blue Dog makes a damn good Bloody Mary. An ideal match for its poached egg and bacon pizza with arugula, Blue Dog uses Tito’s vodka to spike its tomato juice and garnishes each cocktail with pickled green beans, lime, and a Tomolive. What do we love most about the Bloody Mary at Blue Dog? The shot of Stillwater Classique that comes along with it.

Village Anchor

We’ve got to hand it to the Village Anchor -- it's created a Bloody Mary for nearly every day of the week, with five original creations gracing the brunch menu. If you like to keep it classic, the Proud Mary is for you, or go for the Bloody Bourbon if you’re looking for something completely different. The BLT Mary is a crowd favorite, with bacon making an appearance in three forms: infused in the vodka, bacon salt added to the rim, and a slice of bacon for garnish.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
1. Garage Bar 700 E Market St, Louisville, KY 40202

Especially in the warmer months, this renovated garage in the trendy NuLu area is a must-visit. Glowing ping pong tables, Astroturf-covered places to perch, and a consistently ultra-hip crowd make this bar the go-to destination for sticky, hot nights in The ‘Ville. Garage Bar uses local veggies and cured meats to top its pizzas, which bake in a blistering wood-fired brick oven. Be sure to order a tasting platter from the ham bar (yes, it has a bar dedicated to ham) to pair with your pie. It’s got a pretty extensive beer list, too.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
2. Outlook Inn 916 Baxter Ave, Louisville, KY 40204

It may be a bit of a dive, but “Louisville’s oldest tavern” has one fine Bloody Mary, as well as a number of other adult beverages on offer.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
3. Bristol Bar and Grille 1321 Bardstown Rd, Louisville, KY 40204

For decades, this friendly Louisville staple has been feeding the Highlands with a buffet-style brunch featuring Southern classics like chicken & waffles and cheesy grits, as well as its famous green chile wontons at lunch and dinner: fried wonton skins filled with cheese and chiles, and topped with house-made guacamole. Other favorites at this casual sit-down include Bristol's hot brown, blackened chicken linguine, and the simple yet perfected burger on a toasted English muffin -- all of which you can and should pair with its global wine flights.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
4. Seviche Restaurant 1538 Bardstown Rd, Louisville, KY 40205

The distinct latin menu at this restaurant changes seasonally, but the high-quality is maintained thanks to James Beard: Southeast finalist chef Anthony Lamas. His famous "avocado" dessert is made with avocado ice cream, dulce de leche chocolate, a bourbon pit, and coffee pine nut soil.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
5. Against The Grain Brewery 401 E Main St, Louisville, KY 40202

Damn good beer and damn good barbeque are the hallmarks of downtown Louisville staple Against the Grain, located right at the famous Louisville Slugger field. Since opening their doors, the creative brewing team at Against the Grain have created over 100 unique beers that are so good they've evolved from local brewery to national beer distributor. With a full range of beer types, from light session ales to hop-full IPAs and smoky stouts, Against the Grain has a beer for every drinker. And if you don't drink, then chow down on their house-smoked barbeque, with favorites like brisket and pulled pork sitting alongside vegetarian options, like a signature chickpea sloppy joe, more adventuresome than just another salad.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
6. Selena's 10609 Lagrange Road, Louisville, KY 40223

Selena's at Willow Lake Tavern flawlessly merges the cuisines of Sicily and New Orleans with Creole classics like crawfish/shrimp étouffée alongside an assortment of Italian favorites. Guests can also enjoy daily happy hour specials, Sunday Brunch, and outdoor seating.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
7. Blue Dog Bakery & Cafe 2868 Frankfort Ave, Louisville, KY 40206

Most restaurants in Louisville are serving Blue Dog bread, and this is the original spot. But why go somewhere else when they have their own cafe in house? Stop in for brunch or lunch, it won't disappoint.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
8. The Village Anchor Pub & Roost 11507 Park Rd, Anchorage, KY 40223

Village Anchor Pub & Roost is well worth the drive out to historic Anchorage, where this handsome bistro is serving Southern comfort favorites, plus an extensive selection of craft beer and bourbon. The best seats in the house are around the lavish, banquette-lined bar and, particularly on chillier nights, on the covered terrace that sports a double-sided fireplace. The menu focuses on Southern classics, including a hot brown, shrimp & grits, fried chicken, and pork shoulder with cornbread, and truly shines at brunch, when you can indulge in the Village's fan-favorite red velvet pancakes topped with sweet Kahlua cream cheese, plus several twists on a Bloody Mary.