Food & Drink

The 19 Most Popular K-Cups, Ranked By a Coffee Expert

This barista would even pay money for one of these at a coffee shop.

keurig k-cups
Ted McGrath/Thrillist

K-Cups are practically inescapable these days. They've invaded every lazy human's kitchen counter and half of the aisle space at all suburban Bed Bath & Beyond locations. Hell, even staunch environmentalists desperate for caffeine have compromised their morals and used a K-Cup at some point.

And nearly every brand is making a single-serving coffee pod these days. Starbucks? Check. Dunkin' Donuts? You betcha. Even Cinnabon, the maker of mall food court cinnamon rolls, makes K-Cups. But with hundreds of coffee K-Cups out there -- and at least a few dozen in your office pantry -- which one's really worth the (minimal) time?

We asked Josh Taves, a 12-year coffee industry vet (who has spent time working as a barista as well as training them) and the director of business development for Denver’s Novo Coffee -- one of the finest coffee shops in the country -- for help. He did a blind tasting of 19 of the most popular K-Cups like a true (and highly caffeinated) hero. In the end, few proved to be worth drinking, though a couple did impress our judge. Here are the results:

Tully's French Roast Extra Bold
Tully's French Roast Extra Bold | Keurig

19. Tully's French Roast Extra Bold

"It tastes like 90% dark chocolate or baker's chocolate. Most dark chocolate is only 65 -70%, so this is much more bitter. The coffee also tastes old, and a little fishy."

Diedrich French Roast Blend
Diedrich French Roast Blend | Keurig

18. Diedrich French Roast Blend

"Unfortunately, this was not an enjoyable experience. It tastes chemically, tarry, and pungent."

Folgers classic roast keurig cup
Folgers classic roast | Keurig

17. Folgers Classic Roast Coffee

“It tastes like wet cardboard, which is a sign of old, raw product. Not old, roasted product -- it’s pre-roast. Old, green coffee is harvested and sat too long before it was roasted.”

Barista Prima Coffeehouse Italian Roast
Barista Prima Coffeehouse Italian Roast | Keurig

16. Barista Prima Coffeehouse Italian Roast

"It tastes a little like curry or móle. It's very gamey and overwhelmingly roasted in flavor."

Laughing Man Colombia Huila keurig cup
Laughing Man Colombia Huila | Keurig

15. Laughing Man Colombia Huila

"This one has some peanut and cashew flavors to it. While it has a medium body [and doesn't taste too heavy], it does taste old."

Keurig cup Starbucks caramel
Starbucks Caramel | Keurig

14. Starbucks Caramel

"It tastes like sugar-free flavoring."

Keurig Cup Green Mountain Dark Magic
Green Mountain Dark Magic | Keurig

13. Green Mountain Dark Magic

“It’s a little thin -- it’s a little dusty tasting. There’s dark chocolate and shoe leather. And a little bit of raisin sweetness, but also some leguminous vegetable notes mixed with some roastiness. It’s all right. It’s drinkable, but not enjoyable. For a K-Cup, it’s fine.”

Gloria Jean's Butter Toffee keurig cup
Gloria Jean's Butter Toffee coffee | Keurig

12. Gloria Jean's Butter Toffee

"This one tastes like caramel without milk, I don't mind it. The coffee also has some vegetal flavors like that of sugar snap peas."

Keurig cup Caribou blend coffee
Caribou Blend Coffee | Keurig

11. Caribou Coffee Caribou Blend

"This tastes like hotel coffee. It's less offensive than some other ones I tried, but only because it's so weak. It's like brown water."

Keurig Cup Newman's Own Special Blend
Newman's Own Special Blend | Keurig

10. Newman's Own Organics Special Blend Extra Bold

"It tastes like a low-quality coffee, as there's not a lot going on flavor-wise. Even though there is a little bit of cinnamon sweetness in the finish, overall it's weak and old when you drink it."

Green Mountain Coffee Hazelnut Keurig Cup
Green Mountain Coffee Hazelnut | Green Mountain Coffee Hazelnut

9. Green Mountain Coffee Hazelnut

"This doesn't taste like coffee at all. Instead it tastes like a hazelnut milkshake. If you put hazelnut syrup in water and heated it up, this is what you'd get. It's not bad, but it's also not coffee."

keurig k-cup
Cole Saladino/Thrillist

8. Cinnabon Classic Cinnamon Roll

"It tastes like a cinnamon roll! There's still a little bit of coffee flavor, however, unlike the [aforementioned] hazelnut coffee. But still, it's mostly flavoring."

Keurig Cup Starbucks Sumatra
Starbucks Sumatra | Keurig

7. Starbucks Sumatra Coffee

“This tastes like an old dark roast. The darker the roast the more it’ll taste old faster. It’s fine [overall], it’s probably on par with most things you get at the grocery store and make in your home coffeepot.”

The Original Donut Shop Coffee Keurig K Cups
The Original Donut Shop Coffee | Keurig

6. The Original Donut Shop Coffee

"It has a nice body to it and it’s nutty and chocolatey."

Keurig K Cup Folgers Black Silk
Folgers Black Silk | Keurig

5. Folgers Black Silk

“This is alright -- it tastes like a dark roast. It’s a little chocolatey and a little nutty. It’s also weak. There’s a little bit of sweetness to it. If I had to guess, it’s a poorly roasted Colombian coffee. It’s not bad, especially as it cools off. It gets a little sweeter. There’s a little more coffee flavor and a little less roast flavor.”

Starbucks Pike Place Roast k cups
Starbucks Pike Place Roast | Keurig

4. Starbucks Pike Place Roast

"There were very few negatives to this coffee. It started with good flavors and it didn't taste old."

Eight O'Clock The Original k cups
Eight O'Clock The Original | Keurig

3. Eight O'Clock The Original

"I'm getting some sweetness and caramel. Compared to the other K-Cup coffees I've tried, this has a heavier body, which is a good thing."

Green Mountain Coffee Breakfast Blend k cup
Green Mountain Coffee Breakfast Blend | Keurig

2. Green Mountain Coffee Breakfast Blend

"It's very clean in flavor. It lacks bitterness and astringency in the finish, which is nice. I wouldn't be upset drinking a cup of this, but I would be upset paying for it."

Keurig Dunkin' Donuts K Cups
Dunkin' Donuts Original Blend | Keurig

1. Dunkin' Donuts Original Blend

"It's not bad! It has some moderate sweetness and it has some acidity that pops. I can see an importer sending us this coffee [to try to get us to sell it], and us saying, 'It's OK, but no.'"

Sign up here for our daily Thrillist email and subscribe here for our YouTube channel to get your fix of the best in food/drink/fun.

Lee Breslouer is a senior writer for Thrillist, and needs some coffee. Follow him to caffeine @LeeBreslouer.
Our Newsletter
By Signing Up, I Agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.