These Bartender Recipes Will Help You Mix Rum Highballs Like a Pro
New York and LA. Two cities on opposite coasts, locked in an eternal struggle to look cooler than the other. And we all know the only way to settle matters is at the bar.
We asked a handful of bartenders from each coast about the highball, that simple and refreshing cocktail anyone can make -- even if they don’t have bartender expertise. But just in case, we got some recipes from the people who do so you make one perfectly to impress your friends… and make the ones across the country jealous.
If you want to impress in NYC, be resolute. This town doesn’t have time for your hemming and hawing. It’s all about movement and action. That echoes the observations from your local watering hole.
“I have a theory that people who drink highballs don’t vary from that at all,” says Kenneth McCoy, creative director of Public House Collective (a hospitality firm whose bars include Tribeca's Ward III and The Rum House in the Theater District). “They drink their highball and that’s it. They don’t even ask for a menu.”
To help you mix it up while respecting the highball’s straightforward charm, McCoy shares a recipe he’s been “playing around with,” a beer and rum cocktail that he calls...
Mowing the Lawn
½ ounce Giffard Banane Du Bresil liqueur
Bottle of Miller High Life
Grapefruit as garnish
2. Zest a grapefruit twist over the drink.
3. Top off with beer.
In a city that never stops moving, this is a drink that buys you a little extra time to yourself. “You will have extra beer to add to the cocktail as you drink it,” McCoy notes. “The idea is it’s a thirst quencher and you are diluting it as you drink it, therefore you can have more than one.” Sounds perfect for summer.
McCoy’s colleague Nicholas Jackson -- a bartender at The Rum House -- agrees, saying the “Highball also makes me think of classic no-fuss drinkers. It’s the type of thing someone orders to get things started. Someone who knows what they want and enjoys the simplicity of the drink. They want the focus to be on the spirit, but the experience to be extended with the mixer.”
Zach Zoschke, bartender at LA’s Prank says similar. “In my opinion people don’t order highballs enough. When a guest orders one, I immediately assume they are a no-nonsense, to-the-point drinker: they want a drink with minimal additives, presented to maximize the flavor of the base spirit. Not unlike those early old-fashioned drinkers, before it became something of a fad to order one. Two ingredients, ice-cold, and refreshing.” Turns out what’s true in the east holds up in the west. Must be a big city thing.
But of course, there needs to be some of that famous LA-idback attitude on the West Coast version of this cocktail. For that, turn to Aaron Melendrez of Va’ La Hospitality.
“The term highball can be interpreted a little more loosely these days,” he says. “It is such a simple cocktail family on paper but it’s the attention to each detail which makes it so special. The perfect spirit, the lively effervescence, and the garnish that accents and compliments the flavor profile. Hold all the excess sugar! The ice you select and the temperature of your glass can transform a decent highball into a memorable one.”
Melendrez’s view of the drink may be chill, but no less ambitious. If you fancy yourself a mixologist, break out your soda siphon and get ready to do some home carbonation. Starting the night before make some Moroccan mint tea, whose sweetness will balance the herbal flavors.
Moroccan Mint Tea
1 tablespoon sugar
30 mint leaves
5 cups boiling water
2. Stir and let steep for 15 minutes.
3. Strain with tea strainer or fine strainer.
4. Refrigerate overnight. The colder the better to help with carbonation.
Aaron Melendrez’s Highball Recipe
½ ounce Brugal Añejo rum
¼ ounce Clement Mahina coco liqueur
1 teaspoon fresh lime juice
1 pull of Bittermens ‘Elemakule tiki bitters
4 ounces Moroccan mint tea (recipe above)
Small bundle of mint for garnish
Lime wheel for garnish
Ice balls for minimal melting
2. Add tea to iSi soda stream and double carbonate.
3. Shake well, let sit for a few minutes.
4. Mix all ingredients except tea and garnishes.
5. Add ice cube and stir for five seconds.
6. Top with 4 ounces carbonated Moroccan mint tea from an iSi soda siphon.
7. Give one quick stir.
8. Garnish with a lively mint bundle and a lime wheel.
Ingredients aren’t the only thing that make a highball memorable. For Ariel Suarez of Chelsea’s Bathtub Gin, the cocktail transports him from NYC back to his youth.
“I remember growing up in the Dominican Republic, where the rum highball is very popular, because it’s a local product and also very affordable for the population,” he says. “Rum for me means culture, [an] iconic product in the island, and also love for the crafted spirit.”
There’s no question the drink can be a tour of the world. For a transcontinental take, turn to Alli Torres, bartender at Refinery and lead bar consultant at midtown’s Jams, where the heart of NYC dishes up California cuisine. Her recipe uses local ingredients (very local in the case of the honey) to create a surf-friendly tiki drink.
“We source our spirits thoughtfully in addition to the seasonal ingredients we shake into them,” says Torres. That’s how you get to sip on a drink using NYC rooftop honey infused with the restaurant’s favorite local hot sauce, Shaquanda. While you may not have access to your own apiary, you can order NYC honey to keep true to the recipe below.
“The most sustainable taste of New York is what we want you to enjoy,” Torres says. “This summer we’re paying homage to our beautiful city, and what it’s like to sip a stroll down the city streets,” Torres says. “Mixing Brugal two ways, we made a hot and spicy highball for that late afternoon cocktail quench.”
Alli Torres’s Highball Recipe
¾ ounce orgeat
½ ounce lime juice
Dash of NYC rooftop honey infused with Shaquanda local hot sauce
Brugal 1888 to taste
(Optional) garnish with honeycomb, pineapple leaf, and an orange peel
2. Pour into glass.
3. Top with pineapple soda almost to the brim.
4. Float Brugal 1888 atop to seal the sweetness in.
5. Repeat if necessary, which Torres highly recommends.
As you can see, the highball might have a simple form, but like these fashionable cities, it dons thousands of outfits to look good and see where the evening takes you. As Karla Flores, bar director at Wolf & Crane, says, the highball is “an amazingly refreshing drink” that’s suitable anytime. And perhaps its universality (and flexibility) is what makes it so great. It’s for everybody from NY to LA, not just the aficionados.
"Some highballs may get a bad rap among the cocktail nerds,” Jackson says. “But highballs are important and essential to the art of making drinks. Plus we all end up ordering them at some point of our life -- or the night."