Food & Drink

The 11 Best Under-the-Radar Beer Bars in New York City

Zach Mack Published On 02/25/2015 Published On 02/25/2015
Courtesy of Pamela Masters Photography/Threes Brewing

Last year, we told you about the best beer bars in NYC. This year, we're gonna tell you about the best beer bars in NYC that no one is telling you about (including us!) -- 11 under-the-radar gems that weren't on our list or any of the most recent "Best Beer Bar" lists from Time Out, Gothamist, First We Feast, the Village Voice, or Tasting Table.

Swift Hibernian Lounge

NoHo
Craft beer drinkers and Irish pubs go together about as well as mayo and French fries (seriously England, just stop), except when it comes to Swift Hibernian Lounge, where you'll surprisingly find an impressive selection of craft brews (from Pretty Things all the way down to Cantillon) on draft, from cask, and in bottle. Even though it's only steps off the Bowery, the devoted beer drinkers who frequent the Swift have been doing so relatively quietly for years. Oh, and the quality pub eats certainly don’t hurt matters, either.
 

Covenhoven

Crown Heights
Hardcore beer geeks probably already know and love Covenhoven for its awesome themed bottle nights, subway proximity, trivia throwdowns, and appearances by local beer makers, but this spot has remained a best-kept secret for casual beer drinkers who live outside of Crown Heights. Cellar manager James Case runs a great program, pouring a balanced splay of the best local breweries and nerdy favorites, all with friendly, educated service and a sweet back garden.

Courtesy of Pamela Masters Photography/Threes Brewing

Threes Brewing

Gowanus
Aside from the fantastic in-house brews (with a focus on saisons), Threes offers up some of the most unique beers in the game, including Off Color and the occasional Hill Farmstead keg. Add to this the rotating pop-up restaurant space that’s already hosted the likes of Roberta’s and soon Mile End, coffee from the in-house branch of Ninth Street Espresso, and the events space that’s set to blow up -- you’ve got yourself a cultural and culinary and beer...inary one-stop shop just a block from the Gowanus Canal.
 

Queens Kickshaw

Astoria
Most of the press on the Queens Kickshaw lands on its killer grilled cheeses or fantastic coffee, and totally deservedly. But beer is far from a second thought here: four rotating draft lines pour the likes of Element Brewing and Thirsty Dog, plus there's an expansive offering of bottles (including Oude Gueuze Tilquin and To Øl) that really makes this place on-the-radar-bound.

Flickr/Charles Hope

Burp Castle

East Village
Burp Castle sometimes gets lost in the noise of its popular neighbors, Jimmy’s No. 43 and Standings, but that may be partly because of the strict decorum policy: bartenders here have been known to shush anyone who is talking too loudly. This church-like adherence to good behavior may be what makes it such a great place to enjoy the monk-made trappist beers that make up a large part of an impressive drinks list, which leans heavily toward Belgian producers, but also includes some English and German favorites. One drink in silence here and you’ll understand the long-lasting devotion locals have to this place.
 

Beer Street

Williamsburg
Even though Beer Street has been open for a few years, it wasn’t until Cory Bonfiglio of Proletariat fame recently came on board as an owner that the menu got so good. Hard to find bottles and rare kegs are the name of the game here, with Cory showcasing his trademark love for locally produced brews such as Other Half and esoteric foreign imports like White Hag from Ireland. And just like Proletariat, it’s price gouge-free despite its obscure offerings.

Flickr/Ice Cream Man

Brouwerij Lane

Greenpoint
It may feel like all of the hype about drinking beer in Greenpoint has been sucked up by Tørst, but Brouwerij Lane has been at if for years, having barely preceded the wave of craft beer bars in the city. Today, thanks in part to the expertise of owner Ed Raven, it stills stands out for its support of great local beers like Gun Hill, hard-to-find German imports like Riegele, and a killer selection of bottles that number in the hundreds and can (read: should definitely) be purchased to go.
 

St. Gambrinus

Boerum Hill
There are very few places that manage to pull off a great draft program, a solid bottle selection, and even less that can also host the occasional yoga class for customers, but St. Gambrinus manages to do it ALL. Its relatively young position in an exploding neighborhood probably means the under-the-radar thing is only temporary, so make sure to savor it (and the not-too-full beer and yoga classes) while you still can.

Flickr/Axel Taferner

Owl Farm

Park Slope
We can’t think of any reason why this bar hasn’t been as hyped as its sister spots (it has the same owners as Mission Dolores and Bar Great Harry), besides the fact that it’s located in beer-bar-heavy Park Slope. Its expansive rotating list includes everyone from Almanac Beer to Mikkeller, many of which get tapped as part of the impressive event schedule. If you’re in the market for a new extracurricular activity (or another excuse to drink beer <-- THIS ONE), consider joining the local pinball league, which makes use of the bar’s three machines for official league play.

Drop Off Service

East Village
Most New Yorkers think Drop Off Service is the kind of bar you would only head to for a rowdy happy hour. Lately, though, it has quietly become one of the best places to get a great beer in the East Village. The rotating taps pour local favorites like Grimm and Braven, and remain well priced even outside of happy hour deals. It also boasts later hours than most beer-focused bars, which makes it the perfect place to drink great beer well into the wee hours.
 

East Village Tavern

East Village
It wasn’t too long ago that things were looking pretty grim for East Village Tavern. After being awarded a Good Beer Seal and becoming a low-key locals bar, it changed ownership just weeks before being wiped out by Superstorm Sandy’s floodwaters. For months, it veered close to shuttering, but has rebounded with great beers on draft and not a single ounce of pretense in the joint. The lines are clean, the prices are low, and it’s a true New York City second wind story if there ever was one.

Sign up here for our daily NYC email and be the first to get all the food/drink/fun New York has to offer.

Zach Mack is Thrillist's contributing beer writer, the owner of Alphabet City Beer Co. in NYC, and absolutely nothing else. Follow him: @zmack.

 

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
1. Swift Hibernian Lounge 34 E 4th St, New York, NY 10003 (Noho)

If you're looking for an impressive selection of craft brews on draft, Irish whiskey, and single malt scotch, head to this dimly lit neighborhood bar in Noho. The draft and bottled beers are perfect for pairing with traditional pub food, like shepherd’s pie, chicken & sausage pot pie, and a reuben. Swift's dark and cozy interior will have you staying well into the evening.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
2. Covenhoven 730 Classon Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238 (Crown Heights)

Hardcore beer geeks probably already know and love Covenhoven for its awesome themed bottle nights, subway proximity, trivia throwdowns, and appearances by local beer makers, but these guys -- and their sweet back garden -- have remained a best-kept secret for casual beer drinkers who live outside of Crown Heights.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
3. Threes Brewing 333 Douglass St, Brooklyn, NY 11217 (Gowanus)

Threes Brewing is a state-of-the-art brewing facility in Gowanus boasting a restaurant -- helmed by the guys from The Meat Hook -- and a Ninth Street Espresso outpost. Greg Doroski and his team consistently top critics' picks lists with some of the best beers in New York State state, focusing on farmhouse styles. Beers like Hereyago and Superf*ckingyawn show a great balance between a malty backbone, blended hop character, and finishing bitterness.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
4. The Queens Kickshaw 4017 Broadway, Astoria, NY 11103 (Queens)

This Astoria cafe primarily focuses on vegetarian eats, but carnivores will love it just the same. Best for lunch or brunch, standout comfort food menu items include a variety of grilled cheeses, avocado toast, and quiche. Just as popular as the food options are The Queen's coffee and beer offerings, so you can easily pop in for a drink to go.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
5. Burp Castle 41 E 7th St, New York, NY 10003 (East Village)

This East Village local-favorite has a strict decorum policy: bartenders here have been known to shush anyone who is talking too loudly. The church-like adherence to good behavior may be what makes it such a great place to enjoy the monk-made Trappist beers that make up a large part of an impressive drinks list, which leans heavily toward Belgian producers, but also includes some English and German favorites.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
6. Beer Street 413 Graham Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211 (Williamsburg)

Hard to find bottles and rare kegs are the name of the game here, not to mention locally produced brews such as Other Half and esoteric foreign imports like White Hag from Ireland.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
7. Brouwerij Lane 78 Greenpoint Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222 (Greenpoint)

A woodsy boutique with a fresh cedar-burning antique stove, Brouwerij Lane peddles 400+ hard-to-find beer brands, all brought together by a 20+ year Brooklyn Brewery vet. It's a reliable place to buy interesting bottles for enjoying at home, but also an inviting space to attend educational beer events or enjoy the occasional night of live music.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
8. St. Gambrinus Beer Shoppe 533 Atlantic Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217

There are very few places that manage to pull off a great draft program, a solid bottle selection, and even less that can also host the occasional yoga class for customers, but St. Gambrinus manages to do it ALL.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
9. Owl Farm 297 9th St, Brooklyn, NY 11215 (Park Slope)

We can’t think of any reason why this bar hasn’t been as hyped as its sister spots (it has the same owners as Mission Dolores and Bar Great Harry) besides the fact that it’s located in beer bar-heavy Park Slope. Its expansive rotating list includes everyone from Almanac Beer to Mikkeller, many of which get tapped as part of the impressive event schedule. If you’re in the market for a new extracurricular activity (or another excuse to drink beer <-- THIS ONE), consider joining the local pinball league, which makes use of the bar’s three machines for official league play.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
10. Drop Off Service 211 Avenue A, New York, NY 10009 (East Village)

Drop Off Service has delicious meat pies, awesome beers on tap, and they let dogs inside. So basically, it's the ultimate adult playground.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
11. East Village Tavern 158 Avenue C, New York, NY 10009 (East Village)

Come for the beer (a rotating selection of 17 American craft taps), but stay for the burger at this unassuming Alphabet City bar. As one Yelper put it, "Holy. Craft. Beer. Heaven."

Clickbait