Next time somebody tells you to take a long walk off the short Shelter Island Pier, just stop halfway and thank them for the fantastic advice, because you'll be at the brand new Fathom Bistro Bait & Tackle, a sea-themed craft beer hideaway with gluttonous eats that may just take you exactly one fathom (or 6ft) under
Similar to a Kardashian's bedroom, one wall's covered with famous seamen (Cousteau, Verne, Zissou) and the whole place is decked out in nautical memorabilia including a series of plaques from submarines once stationed at SD's Ballast Point Sub Station, located just beyond the window.
The owner earned his beer chops managing Hamilton's and co-owning Small Bar/Eleven, so you know the rotating selection of 15 craft drafts will be stocked with legit offerings from locals like Monkey Paw & Societe, alongside celebrated, hard-to-get mainstays like Pliny.
The relatively minimalist menu is comprised mostly of hand-helds like this pulled pork sandwich with house kimchi made “in-your-face” with a triple-dose of fresh garlic/ginger
They'll also be grilling up skin-on, Vienna Beef dogs like the bacon-wrapped World Famous Fathom EXPLODO loaded with pepper jack, mustard, and more of that house-made kimchee
Aside from the Viennas, they'll be stuffing all of their sausages in-house, like this chicken basil with sun-dried tomato number totally obscured by their Polish kapusta (braised cabbage) made with bacon fat, cinnamon, allspice, and apple cider vinegar.
'Friends' Is Celebrating Its 25th Anniversary With This Immersive Pop-Up Exhibit