Food & Drink

The Best Pimento Cheese Dishes in Charlotte

Published On 11/25/2015 Published On 11/25/2015
Courtesy of Common Market/Max Gilland

Pimento cheese: you can eat it hot, you can eat it cold, but as long as you’re in the South, it’s got to be eaten. Luckily this town has more than enough of this sharply flavored spread to go around. Whether it’s served straight-up on a sandwich, sprinkled atop a hot dog, or spooned into a bowl and scooped up with crackers, here are some of the best ways to get your pimento cheese fix in Charlotte.

Common Market

South End

Common Market is known to put out some damn good sandwiches but the pimento deluxe takes the cake. The award-winning pimento cheese is made with up to nine types of cheeses, from cheddar to pepper Jack and whatever else is around, and then tweaked with some delicious pickled jalapeños. Served on fresh-baked Golden Grains sourdough bread and topped with a generous heaping of bacon strips, this aptly named sandwich is equal parts cheesy and savory with a just-right bacon crunch.

The Diamond

The Diamond

Plaza Midwood

The best part about hot dogs is that you can tailor them to suit your taste buds and in these parts, we like to add a little extra flair by way of melted pimento cheese and chili. The Diamond’s Winky Dinky dog does just that, creating an all-American classic with a heaping helping of Southern charm.

Courtesy of Leroy Fox

Leroy Fox

Cotswold

Pimento cheese is versatile, meaning you can eat it on almost any occasion during anytime of day (including breakfast). Leroy’s serves it accordingly, during brunch, and melts it over a fried chicken and egg croissant that’s topped with mayo and applewood bacon. This sandwich will make you question all of the meals you can make better with pimento.  

Courtesy of Earl's Grocery/Max Gilland

Earl’s Grocery

Elizabeth

Earl’s perfectly prepared house-made pimento cheese is topped with roasted overnight tomatoes, bringing out a smoky flavor that’s so on point. Smeared over Texas toast and grilled to perfection, this sophisticated take on pimento cheese does the classic right.

Soul Gastrolounge

Plaza Midwood

Leave it to Soul to take a classic staple and put a unique spin on it. Its take on nachos: crispy fried chicken skins topped with a creamy pimento cheese fondue and sprinkled with jalapeños for a slight kick.

Courtesy of Nan and Byron's

Nan and Byron’s

South End

Sure, pimento cheese is a great sandwich topper but let us not forget that this stuff can stand alone just fine. Made with red pepper spread and olives, this cold dip serves a bit like tapenade, making it a good starter that’s not quite as gut-filling as some other varieties. It’s served with house-made crostini and pita chips for a good balance of crisp and creamy.

Pinky’s Westside Grill

Wesley Heights

Waffle fries: they’re good with ketchup, honey mustard, and, hell, they’re even good alone. But why do that to yourself when you have the option of Pinky’s Pimp’n Fries. Seasoned waffle fries are served with melted homemade pimento cheese and if you choose, topped with homemade chili and bacon.

Courtesy of Pike's Soda Shop/Max Gilland

Pike’s Old Fashioned Soda Shop

South End

An old-fashioned soda shop is where you’d expect to find a classic like a pimento cheese sandwich, and it definitely doesn’t disappoint. The grilled pimento is just like those ones mom used to make, except better. The homemade recipe is heavy on the sharp cheddar and includes green olive pieces, creating a perfectly tangy, slightly salty bite. Served on buttered, pillowy Texas toast and grilled, you’ll never want to eat a regular old grilled cheese again.

Sign up here for our daily Charlotte email and be the first to get all the food/drink/fun in the Queen City.

Lauren Blake enjoys writing about restaurants and bars just as much as she likes frequenting them. Well, almost as much. Follow her on Twitter and Instagram: @palieblake.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
1. The Common Market 1515 S Tryon St, Charlotte, NC 28203 (South End)

This eclectic market with its sandwich shop, coffee bar, and beer & wine selection is the ultimate neighborhood hub. Most afternoons you’ll find a packed patio with meetings happening over drinks, while evenings often bring live music, and events like beer and wine tastings. There are six beers on tap, but be sure to peruse the shelves as well. The market’s curated selection of intriguing suds from unexpected places like India or the Middle East has made it a favorite for beer aficionados.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
2. Diamond Restaurant 1901 Commonwealth Ave, Charlotte, NC 28205 (Plaza Midwood)

Snag a vinyl-backed booth, put some money in the jukebox, and enjoy the hipster landscape and gritty charm of The Diamond. Daily specials will take you to lunch-lady land with marinated beef tips and comforting casserole-like sides. Breakfast is served all day, and the restaurant is open until 4am on the weekends, so you can keep coming back for those deep-fried pork shanks covered in cinnamon-chipotle sauce, aka the Pig Wings.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
3. Leroy Fox 705 S Sharon Amity Rd, Charlotte, NC 28211 (Cotswold)

One of the few late night spots in the neighborhood, Leroy Fox serves ups its eclectic menu after midnight. Try the hot pretzels, which come with honey mustard and ranch dressing. They are perfect for after dinner snacking.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
4. Earl's Grocery 1609 Elizabeth Ave, Charlotte, NC 28204 (Elizabeth)

This hip grocery is a place to be seen... at lunchtime, at least. Earl's has all sorts of amazing eats like hot bowls of ramen and steak tacos, plus daily features. The real winner, though, is the turkey sandwich. Yes, you heard that right, stacks of deli turkey with smoked Gouda, sun-dried tomato aioli, and avocado stuffed between two slices of lightly grilled wheat bread. It's simple perfection.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
5. Soul Gastrolounge 1500 1/2 Central Ave, Charlotte, NC 28205 (Plaza Midwood)

This second-story small-plate lounge feels like a modern speakeasy. Snag a seat early at its small bar because this spot doesn’t accept reservations and fills up fast with a hip crowd that comes for its killer boozy concoctions. The constantly evolving cocktail menu features inventive (and potent) libations like a Celery Spritz made with gin, Cointreau, house-made celery seltzer, lemon, and olive oil. The vibe here also calls for classics, and drinks like the Manhattan or Sazerac are some of the tastiest in town.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
6. Nan and Byron's 1714 South Blvd, Charlotte, NC 28203 (South End)

Nan & Byron’s is a Charlotte staple for good food that’s creative but doesn’t overthink it. They've also got the incredible G’Night Moon cocktail concocted with moonshine, soda water, sprite, mint, lime and simple syrup that's refreshing and smooth.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
7. Pinky's Westside Grill 1600 W Morehead St, Charlotte, NC 28208 (Freemorewest)

Honey-cilantro slaw, crunchy peanut butter and spicy Sriracha piled together on a burger might sound weird, but once you've had a bite of Pinky's Ding Dong Style Burger in Charlotte's Ashley Park, you'll know you've just got to trust them. And that's only one item on its incredibly diverse menu (it's not every day you see ginger tuna salad and korean pork tacos sharing a menu with reuben hot dogs and greek-style pita sandwiches). No matter what corner of the globe your meal is inspired by, it'll go perfectly with a custom margarita or one of their many quirky house cocktails.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
8. Pike's Old Fashioned Soda Shop 1930 Camden Rd, Charlotte, NC 28203

This old-school diner serves up the best comfort food in all of Charlotte. Their pimento grilled cheese is heavenly.

Clickbait