Food & Drink

5 essential Hamptons lobster rolls West of Montauk

Published On 06/05/2014 Published On 06/05/2014
Hamptons LR
Liz Melnitzky

With Montauk being the seafood capital of... quite possibly the universe, it's no shock that you'll find many a mean lobster roll that way -- but that doesn't mean the rest of the Hamptons isn't bringing some serious crustacean game to the table. When you have a craving that only fresh lobster, a hint of mayo, and a soft, buttery bun can fill, you can't go wrong with these go-to rolls.

Liz Melnitzky

Best Overall Taste
Clam Bar at Napeague, Napeague
Nothing tops the feeling of enjoying the sun en route to Montauk outside Clam Bar on the Napeague Stretch... except for the taste of their lobster roll. Clam Bar’s seafood is delivered fresh from the local fishermen each morning, and despite being named after a slightly smaller and easier-to-crack sea critter, lobster is king here. The Clam Bar’s generously appointed roll is not overpowered by extras, just perfectly complemented with a light amount of mayonnaise and celery to give the meat a bit of a crunch, plus a soft, simply toasted bun. 

Liz Melnitzky

The Most Unique
Lunch Lobster Roll RestaurantAmagansett
On the side of the highway on the Napeague Stretch you’ll find such a fantastic lobster roll joint that they get away with a stunningly simple moniker: Lobster Roll Restaurant. Founded 49 years ago, and more commonly known as Lunch, LRR is credited with creating what we now know to be our beloved cold lobster salad. Uniquely, Lunch offers two types of lobster rolls, and when you order they’ll ask if you’d like your sandwich cold or hot. The traditional cold lobster salad roll option is mayonnaise-based with a celery crunch and served on a buttery toasted bun. As it tends to cool down further out East, don’t shy away from their specialty -- the hot lobster roll -- a butter-based sandwich with only whole pieces of steamed lobster to pile onto a toasted bun served on the side. Both dishes are served with crispy, golden-brown French fries, homemade coleslaw, and an orange.

Silver's Restaurant

The Fanciest
Silver’s RestaurantSouthampton 
Walking around bustling Southampton, you can forget that the ocean is even nearby -- but eat at Silver’s and you’ll quickly be reminded. The furthest out from the freshest fish in the Montauk Area, Silver’s is an underdog, proving that it can hold its own against the local beach cafĂ©s further out East and stepping up to the task with lobster from Braun Seafood Co. in Cutchogue. True to its character, Silver’s lobster roll is served on a French baguette, as opposed to the usual hot dog bun, which gives the sandwich a crisp and neat feel. The sandwich is prepared with very light mayonnaise, and a little bit of celery and a single slice of lettuce for crunch, making room for the huge, succulent, fresh chunks of lobster.

Liz Melnitzky

Best Bang For Your Buck
The Seafood ShopWainscott
In the small but central town of Wainscott, The Seafood Shop operates as a fresh fish market and kitchen, providing meats and produce to fire up on the grill at home and a tasty selection of prepared meals -- but the best deal in the house is their lobster roll. With their lobster salad running at $60.00 a pound, the $15.00 lobster roll is a steal. A generous portion of lobster, hints of celery and red onion, and a bit of garlicky seasoning all sit on a perfectly toasted bun, and it's no surprise that people line up to grab these on their way to the beach.

The Dock House on Long Wharf, Sag Harbor

The Most Authentic
The Dock House on Long WharfSag Harbor
Nestled in the bay at the very end of Sag Harbor, amongst docks filled with million-dollar yachts and state-of-the-art sail and speed boats, is one of the Hamptons' most quintessential lobster rolls. Served on toasted hot dog buns, these rolls are in the no-frills business, letting the fresh quality of the meat speak for itself. This low-key establishment is right on the water in a historic whaling community, offering not only the real deal when it comes to the taste of the lobster roll, but an authentic atmosphere as well. The staff is friendly and keeps the line moving quickly, which is an added plus on a hot day, not that this tasty treat wouldn’t be worth the wait.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
1. The Clam Bar 2025 Montauk Hwy, Amagansett, NY 11930 (Amagansett)

All the food comes from local fishing boats and baymen, which means everything is super-fresh. Despite the name, the lobster rolls are one of the best items on the menu.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
2. Lunch Lobster Roll Restaurant 1980 Montauk Hwy, Amagansett, NY 11930 (Amagansett)

Better known as Lunch, the Lobster Roll Restaurant is a beach shack serving lunch (and dinner). The famous lobster salad is made with 100% pure cold water lobster meat and is a must-try.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
3. Silver's 15 Main St, Southampton, NY 11968 (Southampton)

Silver's slings brunch, lunch, and dinner in Southampton, with bites like lobster salad, blue claw crabmeat cakes, and a Scottish smoked salmon sandwich.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
4. The Seafood Shop 356 Montauk Hwy, Wainscott, NY (Wainscott)

It's The Seafood Shop's goal to serve the "freshest and finest" seafood out there. The best deal in the house is their fresh lobster roll.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
5. The Dock House 1 Long Wharf, Sag Harbor, NY 11963 (Sag Harbor)

Located on a 300ft long wharf in Sag Harbor, TDH's your spot for fresh seafood -- from lobster rolls, to clam chowder, to scallop platters -- oceanside views, and bustling marina activity.