If you’re trying to harken back to your screaming for ice cream days, Big Olaf is your spot. Located right on the water, Big Olaf provides benches lining the sidewalk outside, creating the perfect place to enjoy their famous homemade cones and the very generous portions of ice cream that fill them.
The story of cookies that became a cult phenomenon, sold in grocery stores nationwide, started in the town of Southampton at a family farm stand on the outskirts of the small town. The classic crunch of Tate’s cookie translated over years to pies, scones, bread pudding, brownies, and the contemporary Tatewich: two signature chocolate chip cookies stuffed with vanilla ice cream.
Serving all-natural fruit frozen treats, Chloe’s soft serve and smoothies are the perfect, health conscious way to cool off in Water Mill.
This Southampton shop has been satisfying customers’ screams for ice cream and cravings for candy since 1973. Worth every penny, the exotic and traditional fudge, including flavors such as chocolate, chocolate walnut, maple walnut, and chocolate vanilla swirl, comes fresh by the pound for $23.95.