Food & Drink

The best dessert places in the Hamptons

Published On 08/14/2014 Published On 08/14/2014

I scream, you scream, the Hamptons scream for ice cream. While Summer vacations have become shorter (non-existent) since childhood, our cravings for pies, cookies, and ice cream sundaes in freshly baked waffle cones have weirdly only intensified. Call it the munchies if you must, but the little kid in us is still screaming for ice cream and Thrillist has the five best dessert places in the Hamptons to satisfy your sweet tooth.

Facebook/Big Olaf

Big Olaf

Sag Harbor
If you’re trying to harken back to your screaming for ice cream days, Big Olaf is your spot. Located right on the water, Big Olaf provides benches lining the sidewalk outside, creating the perfect place to enjoy their famous homemade cones and the very generous portions of ice cream that fill them. Yes, there tends to be quite a line. Yes, the smell of waffle cones baking throughout the day will make you wait in it anyway. Just remember to bring cash.

Facebook/Chloe's Soft Serve Fruit Co.

Chloe's Soft Serve Fruit Co.

Water Mill
Don’t let the Soccer Mom seal of approval scare you off of these all-natural fruit frozen treats. Chloe’s offers sweet and savory flavors such as the Crunchy Salty sundae made with Banana & Dark Chocolate Soft Serve Fruit, banana, pretzels, warm natural peanut butter, and melted chocolate; and the Smores Sundae with Dark Chocolate Soft Serve Fruit, banana, marshmallows, warm natural peanut butter, and whip cream. There's still plenty of indulgence here.

Facebook/Tate's Bake Shop

Tate’s Bake Shop

Southampton
The classic crunch of Tate’s cookies eventually grew into a nationwide phenomenon, but this is where it all started. They've expanded their game to pies, scones, bread pudding, and brownies, but you're getting the Tatewich: two signature chocolate chip cookies stuffed with vanilla ice cream, with some bonus chocolate for good measure. Good luck limiting yourself to one of these.

Facebook/Southampton Fudge Company

The Fudge Company

Southampton
The Fudge Company in Southampton does not fudge around with their fudge, nor their candy and ice cream. The shop has been satisfying customers’ sweet cravings since 1973. Worth every penny, the exotic and traditional fudge (try the maple walnut) comes priced at $23.95/lb. You'll also find classics like salt water taffy and other traditional candy shop fare here.

Flickr/Neil Conway

Candy Kitchen

Bridgehampton
A classic luncheonette and soda fountain shop, Candy Kitchen offers a variety of both homemade ice cream and milkshakes, and also Page-Six clientele. Located in a Bridgehampton town on Montauk Hwy, the ice cream parlor is decked out in memorabilia and tokens of an old-fashioned diner from the 1950s. Their ice cream, however, is timeless with a wide range of classic and innovative flavors. Candy Kitchen also offers tubs of soft and rich ice cream to take home for make-your-own sundae stations and late-night eating. Once again, be warned: bring your cash.

This list -- and all the rest -- look even sexier in our iPhone app. Get it now!

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
1. Big Olaf 8 Wharf St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963 (Sag Harbor)

If you’re trying to harken back to your screaming for ice cream days, Big Olaf is your spot. Located right on the water, Big Olaf provides benches lining the sidewalk outside, creating the perfect place to enjoy their famous homemade cones and the very generous portions of ice cream that fill them.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
2. Tate's Bake Shop 43 N Sea Rd, Southampton, NY 11968 (Southampton)

The story of cookies that became a cult phenomenon, sold in grocery stores nationwide, started in the town of Southampton at a family farm stand on the outskirts of the small town. The classic crunch of Tate’s cookie translated over years to pies, scones, bread pudding, brownies, and the contemporary Tatewich: two signature chocolate chip cookies stuffed with vanilla ice cream.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
3. Chloe's Soft Serve Fruit Co. 869 Montauk Hwy, Watermill, NY 11976

Serving all-natural fruit frozen treats, Chloe’s soft serve and smoothies are the perfect, health conscious way to cool off in Water Mill.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
4. The Fudge Company 67 Main St, Southampton, NY 11968 (Southampton)

This Southampton shop has been satisfying customers’ screams for ice cream and cravings for candy since 1973. Worth every penny, the exotic and traditional fudge, including flavors such as chocolate, chocolate walnut, maple walnut, and chocolate vanilla swirl, comes fresh by the pound for $23.95.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
5. Candy Kitchen 2391 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton, NY 11932 (Bridgehampton)

Looks and feels like an old-school ice cream shoppe and candy store; serves that plus more substantial diner eats to hungry visitors all Summer long.

Clickbait