Food & Drink

London's 7 best pub pies

Haley Forest Published On 02/11/2014 Published On 02/11/2014

Apart from crisps, scratchings, and any cocktail with more than three olives, pub food pretty much revolves around the noble pie, and rightly so. So while keeping a sort of purist stance -- that is, without running into gastro territory (surely they’re just restaurants with a bar?) -- we’ve figured out the seven best pub pies in the city, and what to drink with them...

The Guinea Grill

The Guinea Grill
Mayfair
What you're getting: Steak & Mushroom Pie
Pair it with: Courage Directors
Sister to the multi-time pie champion, The Windmill, the Guinea's been around since 1423 (!!!). In fact, when it opened, it wasn't technically in London, as the city limits didn't extend out as far as Mayfair yet. Part of the Young's group since 1888, they may be better known for their steaks (hence the name "grill"), but it's their multi-award winning pies that're the real winners here. 

Wikimedia Commons

The Newman Arms
Soho
What you're getting: Lamb & Mint w/ a suet pastry casing
Pair it with: Harvey's Sussex Best Bitter
You'll find this W1 institution on an alleyway corner tucked off Oxford St -- having been built since 1730, they’ve had a few different uses though the years (ironmonger, picture framer, brothel... basically the usual), but wisely settled on tavern in 1860. The fact that they have an actual "pie room" upstairs should serve as a clue as to the quality of their crust, which you can pair with their pretty vast selection of beer. 

The Windmill

The Windmill
Mayfair
The greatest pie: Three-time national champion Steak and Kidney Pie
Pair it with: Young’s Special
Sure, the neighborhood may be home to upper crust (!), but nestled amongst them, these guys take their love of pies to a whole new level. Pie room? Naturally. Pie Club, w/ 6000 members? Sure, why not. Pie-centric YouTube channel, geeking out on recipes?! Man, these guys take this stuff seriously.

Fullers Pubs

The Old Bank of England
City
What you're getting: The cock-a-leekie
Pair it with: Organic Honey Dew
This decadently decorated drinkery is housed in the former Law Courts branch of the Bank of England, but what you really want to know is that it's also smack dab on top of the tunnels between the site of Sweeney Todd's barber shop and Mrs. Lovett's pie shop. The pies they sell, however, are proudly corpse-free and completely delicious, most notably their version of the all-too-rare traditional cock-a-leekie. 

Flickr user Menage a Moi

Ye Olde Cheshire Cheese
City
What you're getting: Steak & Onion Shepard’s Pie
Pair with it: Sam Smith’s Imperial Stout
While there has been a pub on this site since 1538 (stop and think about that for a sec), this particular building has a long and storied history of feeding/watering some of literature's greatest minds (like Mark Twain, Charles Dickens, and W.B. Yeats to name a few). The Cheese is made up of a collection of dark passageways and rooms, inside of which you can find one of the finest pastry-wrapped treats in London.

Wikimedia Commons

The Betsey Trotwood
Clerkenwell
What you're getting: Chicken & Tarragon
Pair it with: Hürlimann Sternbrau
This neighborhood pub has some serious moves going on. With a surprisingly intimate venue space for gigs in the cellar, and a very chilled but charming upstairs bar, The Betsey is a bit of an all-in-one deal. The pies themselves actually come from Borough Market, but even though they're not technically making them themselves, we'll allow it on grounds of deliciousness. 

Flickr user Ewan-M

The Royal Oak
Borough
What you're getting: Vegetable & Stilton 
Pair it with: Wild Hops
Tucked on a little corner off Borough High St sits this teeny traditional Victorian pub. Being run by the brewers over at Harvey’s, you can expect a good selection of first-class brews (including a decent number of seasonal favorites), as well as food to match -- the menu is extremely pie heavy, and the pies themselves are pretty heavy, being about the size of you head. 

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
1. The Windmill 6-8 Mill St, London, W1S 2AZ (Mayfair)

There's plenty to love about this pub, but its best aspect is the pie. The Windmill serves up a variety of the golden brown buggers, the best of which is their steak and kidney pie, which has won numerous national awards.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
2. Newman Arms 23 Rathbone St, London, W1T 1NG (Fitzrovia)

Fitrovia pub Newman Arms is a great place to get a stout, ale, or lager on draught -- but they also dish out crazy-good pies and puddings in their Pie Room, such as a beef & Guinness pot pie or savoury lamb and mint suet pudding.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
3. The Old Bank of England 194 Fleet St, London, EC4A 2LT (The City)

This Fleet St pub is located in the former Law Courts branch of the Bank of England and is famous for its extensive menu featuring a variety of pies that keep people flocking to this beautifully restored establishment.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
4. Ye Olde Cheshire Cheese 145 Fleet St, London, EC4A 2BU (The City)

There has been a pub at this location since 1538 and has served such famous patrons as Mark Twain and Charles Dickens. And the same things that kept them in business then keeps them in business now: a friendly atmosphere, cold brews, and tasty pies.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
5. The Betsey Trotwood 56 Farringdon Rd, London, EC1R 3BL (Clerkenwell)

These guys dish out tasty eats from their small kitchen and serve up plus fresh pies from Borough Market. They also feature an intimate spot for gigs and a charming upstairs bar.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
6. The Royal Oak 44 Tabard St, London, SE1 4JU (Borough)

This little traditional Victorian pub is run by the brewers at Harvey’s, and they serve a good selection of brews, from the standards along with a good mix of seasonal favorites, as well as massive delicious pies.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
7. The Guinea Grill 30 Bruton Pl, London, W1J 6NL (Mayfair)

Founders of the Scotch Beef Club, this unique London pub combines prime meats, tasty pies, and an extensive Scotch list to ensure a bloody good time. An impressive list of draft beers is also available, because without beer, this would be a terrible pub.

Clickbait