First, we scored the six different major ice cream brands: Breyers, Häagen-Dazs, Edy's, Baskin-Robbins, Friendly's, and ol' Ben & Jerry's. To separate the dough, we plopped the whole carton into a strainer, hit it with a faucet of hot water to wash away the ice cream, and picked out the nuggets like little chunks of gold before removing the excess water. Because food waste is bad, we also made a donation to a local food bank. Then, we baked! This is how they stacked up.