The stuff that isn't ice cream
The cookie crumbs are there to represent sand, I guess? At least that’s the vibe I’m getting. I mean, it kinda looks like there’s sand in the ice cream. And that’s tropical? Right? But it tastes great, and actually adds a little pleasing texture, so it works.
The caramel is caramel, and if you’ve ever had a banana with caramel, then you know it’s also an absurdly good move.
Finally, the little chocolate peace signs give the whole thing an appropriately Woodstocky vibe, and are also worryingly perfect. I couldn’t find any that were broken, crushed, or malformed. Perhaps the people at B&J’s were worried about the devastatingly potent symbolism of a broken peace sign slowly drowning in ice cream. Also, they were tasty.