Critics might assert that Half-Baked -- long a Ben & Jerry's staple -- should certainly rank higher on this list. I say there's a handful of flavors (some new!) that do what Half-Baked does, but marginally better. That being said, we still have to pay our respects to the pint and more importantly the name, as it's the first instance of B+J's directly tipping their hat to one of their core audience segments: the stoney-bologna snacker.
17. Pistachio Pistachio
I would have never, ever, under any circumstances, thought a pistachio-flavored ice cream would crack my top 20, let alone escape the confines of Tier V. I was wrong. And this is why we taste test, people.
S'mores are the culinary equivalent of Monopoly. While they are undeniably enjoyable, the set-up, clean up, and overall struggle and strife of making it all happen limits it to special occasions or extreme bouts of boredom. Ben & Jerry's s'mores ice cream takes away the hassle, freezes it, and hands you a spoon. Now, if they could only figure out how to consolidate a game of Monopoly into a pint... without my sister cheating like a rat, of course.