9. Double Stuf (Golden cookie)
Exactly like the Double Stuf Oreo with chocolate cookies, but not as good. Still pretty good! If Mega Stuf is too much creme and normal Oreo is the right amount of creme, Double Stuf is a little more than the right amount of creme. That makes sense, right?
8. Double Stuf (chocolate cookie)
The Double Stuf Oreo is a uniquely American product. Nabisco went all McDonald's on the Oreo and Super-Sized the creme. It's an original product -- I didn't know I needed more creme in my Oreo until this came along. The only knock is that Eli Manning was once paid to endorse this product, and as a lifelong Eagles fan, I cannot in good conscience enjoy this. I mean, it's good and everything, but I don't like it.
7. Key Lime Pie
I opened many Oreo boxes to do this story, and I've not yet remarked on how the Oreo cookies smell. Probably because there's not much of a scent. But the second you crack open these limited-edition suckers, the smell hits you. And it smells unmistakably like Key lime pie, or lime Powerade (of which I'm a huge fan). The taste is pretty dead on -- I'm not getting a ton of action from the graham-flavored cookie, but the Key lime is very much there. There are even whipped cream notes in the back end. Nabisco must've done some serious cookie-science to create these flavors.