SO WHICH PEANUT BUTTER CUP WINS?
“Reese’s. It’s good, though, no doubt. It’s just not the same as getting the real deal.”
“Team Reese’s. If it was an organic peanut butter cup or something like that, or this, I would go for this.”
Butterfinger. Now let me say, though, that I don't think they’re comparable. They’re different candies, and I prefer the Butterfinger. It’s certainly not a replacement for a Reese’s, or a better version of Reese’s. It’s a matter of taste, and this wins.”
Devon, Director of Communications Who Wasn't Even Part of the Test, And Walked In And Just Started Eating Stuff:
“WOOOOOOOW. Wow. Wow guys. Wow. This Butterfinger one is life-changing. This is my new favorite candy. I want this over Reese’s, 100%.”
“I’ve gotta be a purist here and say Reese’s all the way."
While it put up a mighty strong showing for such a young buck, the Butterfinger got nudged out by the reigning champ, 3 votes to 2. But aside from that, I'll just tell you two things right now: they're both monumentally delicious, and do whatever you can to keep Devon away from your snacks.
Ben Robinson is Thrillist's Editorial Director, and is eagerly expecting a Fudgie the Whale cake on his birthday, and also just general other days. Follow him @BenjoRobinson.