SO WHICH PEANUT BUTTER CUP WINS?
Ken: “Reese’s. It’s good, though, no doubt. It’s just not the same as getting the real deal.”
Jenna: “Team Reese’s. If it was an organic peanut butter cup or something like that, or this, I would go for this.”
Andrew: "Butterfinger. Now let me say, though, that I don't think they’re comparable. They’re different candies, and I prefer the Butterfinger. It’s certainly not a replacement for a Reese’s, or a better version of Reese’s. It’s a matter of taste, and this wins.”
Devon, Director of Communications Who Wasn't Even Part of the Test, And Walked In And Just Started Eating Stuff: “WOOOOOOOW. Wow. Wow guys. Wow. This Butterfinger one is life-changing. This is my new favorite candy. I want this over Reese’s, 100%.”
Ted: “I’ve gotta be a purist here and say Reese’s all the way."
While it put up a mighty strong showing for such a young buck, the Butterfinger got nudged out by the reigning champ, 3 votes to 2. But aside from that, I'll just tell you two things right now: they're both monumentally delicious, and do whatever you can to keep Devon away from your snacks.
Ben Robinson is Thrillist's Editorial Director, and is eagerly expecting a Fudgie the Whale cake on his birthday, and also just general other days. Follow him @BenjoRobinson.