Food & Drink

We endure five days of fad diets, slowly go insane

Fad Diets
All photos by Andy Kryza

Here at Thrillist, we're committed to a certain (low) standard of healthfulness, and are willing to try anything to achieve it. And we're seemingly faced with a different fad diet each day, something promising to give us washboard abs and healthy hearts through some tinkering with what we put in our body. But which is the best?

To answer that question, we played Fad Diet Roulette: Over the course of five days, we strictly followed one diet daily. Then we lost our minds.

Paleo diet

Starting weight: 206 (on the dot)

DAY 1: THE PALEO DIET

WHAT IT IS
Basically, you eat food made only of stuff that cavemen had access to. That means meat, fish, veggies, fruit, and nuts. And no fun stuff like grains (bread, rice), dairy, refined salt, sugar, or processed oils.

FEELING AT THE START OF DAY 1
Bright-eyed and bushy-tailed.

DIET LOG
I start the day in a bad place: a coffee shop. No self-respecting Cro-Mag would eat a croissant, even if it was covered in Brontosaurus guts. So I get a dressing-free side salad and some OJ. Obviously, I'm still hungry. Luckily, I live in Portland, so of course there's a Paleo cart called the Cultured Caveman. Scored some tasty Paleo chicken tenders coated in coconut flour, plus a cup of bone broth served in a coffee cup. It's caveman Starbucks.

For a diet based around a caveman, things seem a little too foofy, so I decide to start a fire in my backyard and roast an unseasoned steak using a stick. I keep dropping it in the fire, and when it's done it's half well-done and half raw. It tastes like victory.

FEELING AT THE END OF DAY 1
Primal.

Oktoberfest Diet

DAY 2: THE OKTOBERFEST DIET

WHAT IT IS
Invented by a national treasure known as Evo Terra (not his real name!), the diet dictates that you subsist solely on a diet of sausage and beer for one month, averaging six beers and four sausages daily. He claims to have lost 14lbs and a huge portion of his cholesterol each year.

FEELING AT THE BEGINNING OF DAY 2
Girlishly excited.

DIET LOG
Breakfast in bed is four sausage links and a blueberry lager that I realize is 8% only after the fact. Breakfast is AWESOME. But it turns out that sausage with no bread, onions, or cheese isn't very filling.

I have two beer brats and a porter around 3p, and quickly realize that I'm not allowed to eat any more sausage for the day. Ugh, I'm starving. I head out to a karaoke bar, where I down an IPA and a huge mug of Dos Equis. I stumble through "Semi-Charmed Life". In goes more IPA, out comes Backstreet Boys lyrics, and before I know it I'm in a cab home.

FEELING AT THE END OF DAY 2
Huh? Starving. Also, you're pretty.

Juice cleanse

DAY 3: JUICE CLEANSE

WHAT IT IS
A steady, daylong diet of nothing but organic, fresh squeezed juices formulated to act as Liquid-Plumr in your intestinal tract.

FEELING AT THE BEGINNING OF DAY 3
Miserable, tired, and hungry.

DIET LOG
My fingers still smell like sausage and beer, but this bright-green bottle marked "Prana" smells like a freshly mown lawn… probably because it's made of romaine, collard greens, cucumbers, cilantro, and lemon. It tastes like chores. So does the next one, made of kale, spinach, parsley, and celery. Also, I can't get off the couch. I feel terrible and need Domino's.

Drink three is a nice change of pace, since it's apple, beet, and carrot. It looks like stage blood, but tastes sweet. But my stomach isn't happy, and I soon find my college basketball game interrupted by a howling deep inside of me. The good news is the green stuff has definitely gone through my system. The bad news is that this will happen 11 more times over the next eight hours -- representing the entire color spectrum -- and the cayenne that dominated the carrot/red pepper/broccoli juice really makes its presence known.

Luckily, the last juice is almond, cacao, vanilla bean, nutmeg, and sea salt. It tastes like chocolate milk, and lulls me to sleep like a baby (a baby who desperately needs to switch to Cottonelle).

FEELING AT THE END OF DAY 3
Vacant and dead-eyed.

8-Hour Diet

DAY 4: THE 8-HOUR DIET

WHAT IT IS
You can eat whatever the hell you want, so long as you do it within a span of eight hours.

FEELING AT THE BEGINNING OF DAY 4
Dizzy, but surprisingly sprightly.

DIET LOG
It's kind of a blur, but here is what I desperately shoved into my mouth, beginning at 11a: A slice of pizza, some Pringles, an IPA, half an order of breadsticks, a Jell-O shot, a PBR, some Pringles, a slice of pizza, more Pringles, peanuts, a slice of pizza, one fried chicken thigh, some tater tots, one finger of Scotch, a cheeseburger, a root beer float, one mini carrot, and half a cookie. The worst was at 630p, when I realized I only had a half-hour to eat, and panic-gorged at the finish line. Now I don't feel very well.

FEELING AT THE END OF DAY 4
Fat, sweaty, and crampy.

Raw foods

DAY 5: RAW FOOD DIET

WHAT IT IS
Vegetables. Stupid, uncooked vegetables. And uncooked nuts. And water. And also, stupid vegetables.

FEELING AT THE BEGINNING OF DAY 5
Wonky, with a slightly malfunctioning brain.

DIET LOG
Looking in the fridge, I realize that I have zero raw veggies. After high-fiving myself in the mirror, I head out and get some clementines, carrots, cucumbers, lettuce, bananas, lettuce, and apples, then spend the day grazing. "So this is what cows eat all day", I think to myself as I eye my forearm and imagine eating it. Then I kind of doze off with my eyes open, also like a cow. I don't really like this at all. I feel cleaner, but less happy. Is this why vegans write such sad music? (We're looking at you, Fiona.)

I feel terrible. I look terrible. I need a steak.

FEELING AT THE END OF DAY 5
Lethargic, tired, herbivorian. I'd be lying if I said I wasn't waiting for it to turn midnight so I could eat something else, but I fell asleep at 9p.

Fad diets

FINAL WEIGHT
202.4lbs (-3.6lbs)

BEST DIET
The 8-Hour Diet rules because you can eat what you want, but I actually gained back 2lbs that day. I vote juice cleanse, which was oddly invigorating and, um, cleansing.

BIGGEST SURPRISE
The Oktoberfest Diet is actually the most punishing thing, and that makes me sad.

THE TAKEAWAY
It's a terrible idea to switch between diets... like, there's yo-yo dieting, and there's this. But hey! Bikini bod, here I come.

Andy Kryza is Thrillist's national eat/drink senior editor, and has proudly lived vegetable-free since 2001. Follow his adventures/slow decline via Twitter at @apkryza.