The 12 Best Sandwiches in New Orleans (That AREN'T a Po-Boy or a Muffaletta)

New Orleans

The 12 Best Sandwiches in New Orleans (That AREN'T a Po-Boy or a Muffaletta)
The 12 Best Sandwiches in New Orleans (That AREN'T a Po-Boy or a Muffaletta)

Flickr/Alan Teo

When it comes to eating your food between two slices of bread in New Orleans, the po-boy clearly reigns supreme (and really, how could it not?), followed very closely thereafter by the muffaletta. But after that, things really get interesting, as not all great sandwiches in the Big Easy necessarily come on French bread or a muffy loaf. If you’re looking to engage in alternative sandwich excellence, here are some of the best in town right now.

DISTRICT: Donuts.Sliders.Brew.


DISTRICT: Donuts. Sliders. Brew. (address and info)
Lower Garden District
The inventive donut creations at DISTRICT might have people flocking to its Magazine St store -- maple Sriracha with candied thyme (!!!) -- but you’d be remiss to skip out on the perfect little sliders there, as well, which feature house-ground Creekstone Black Angus beef. 

Hooks Cheddar Sandwich

St. James Cheese Company (address and info)
Uptown/Warehouse District
Employing the eponymous Wisconsin cheddar, the Hooks at St. James also sports house-smoked turkey, fresh basil, tomato, mayo, and avocado on fresh ciabatta. It’s delightful. Trust us.


Banh mi

Dong Phuong Oriental Bakery (address and info)
New Orleans East
Although New Orleanians tend to refer to the banh mi as a “Vietnamese po-boy,” it is its own sandwich in its own right. It’s hard to beat the classic out at Dong Phuong bakery. 

Porchetta sandwich

Wayfare (address and info)
Fancy ‘wiches are the hallmark at Wayfare and it’s difficult, if pressed, to choose a favorite. "The Knuckle” is always a crowd pleaser with its combo of rare roast beef and horseradish, but don’t miss the Porchetta: pork loin wrapped in Kurobuta pork belly, caramelized onions, salsa verde, arugula, and fennel aioli on a hoagie. Yes, a hoagie. Not a po-boy.

Scott Gold/Thrillist


Kebab (address and info)
Although Kebab only opened recently and it's serving through the weekends alone, it’s worth a trip over to St. Claude Ave in order to experience its dynamite Dutch/German/Turkish street food, particularly its version of the gyro, made here with Chappapeela Farms pork and dressed up with tzatziki and skhug sauces, pickled onions, and cabbage.

Scott Gold/Thrillist


Cochon Butcher (address and info)
Those in the know realize that the muffaletta at Donald Link’s snack shop is one of the best in the city. Slightly less known, however, is its fantastic classic Cubano. 

The Rachel

Stein’s Market & Deli (address and info)
Lower Garden District
Though not really known for its Jewish delicatessens, New Orleans does indeed have a rich Hebrew heritage, which can be enjoyed at Stein’s (along with a killer beer selection). The Rachel -- a Reuben variant featuring pastrami instead of corned beef -- hits the mark every time.

Liberty Cheesesteaks

The Wiz

Liberty Cheesesteaks (address and info)
It may have taken some decades, but hungry New Orleanians can now find a solid, true-to-Philly cheesesteak, and thank goodness for that. Skip the variants and go with the classic Wiz, just like you’d find in the city of Brotherly Love: loaded with steak, onions, and gooey, bright, yellow Cheez Whiz.

Scott Gold/Thrillist

Croque Monsieur

Mister Gregory's French Casual Cafe (address and info)
French Quarter
This Rampart St sandwich shop bills itself as “Fast French,” and proves it with these delicious “Hot Les Sandwiches,” which employ savory fillings (beef, ham, chicken, andouille, etc.) and thick gobs of blowtorch-melted cheese.

Scott Gold/Thrillist

Pulled pork sandwich

McClure’s Barbecue (address and info)
Neil McClure knows his way around some classic American BBQ, and there’s no doubting that. If you’re headed to his Magazine St spot, you’ll have your eye on the awesome chicken (with white, Big Bob Gibson-style Alabama sauce), but don’t let that keep you away from the spot-on pulled pork, especially when paired with vinegary NC-style sauce.

Scott Gold/Thrillist

Oyster Loaf

Casamento’s (address and info)
Yes, everyone knows -- or should know -- that Casamento’s is the place you want to go to satisfy that raw oyster jones. On top of that should also be added its famous fried oyster “loaf,” which would be a po-boy if it were served on French instead of thick slices of buttery Texas toast.

The Sammich

Fried Lobster sandwich

The Sammich (address and info)
Okay, so this one is, in fact, served on Leidenheimer French bread. But this alone does not make it a po-boy! It seems impossible that a tempura-fried lobster sandwich hasn’t been done everywhere at this point, but The Sammich grabbed that (insanely good) idea and ran with it... with spicy mango cream.

Sign up here for our daily New Orleans email and be the first to get all the food/drink/fun in the Big Easy.

Published on

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
1. DISTRICT: Donuts. Sliders. Brew. 2209 Magazine St, New Orleans, LA 70130 (Garden District)

As the name implies, DISTRICT excels at coffee, sliders, and donuts -- and makes some innovative changes to all of them. In lieu of your average sandwich, expect "croquenuts" (an insanely delicious hybrid of a croque madame and a donut), bold breakfast options like bacon and egg on a miso-praline biscuit, and unconventional donut flavors like Sriracha-maple and candied thyme. While you could sip on a basic brew while you're indulging on such sugary goodies, we suggest you opt for house staples like Vietnamese cold brew and or the "sproca-cola," a winning combination of cola, espresso, and chocolate milk. It's a common destination for hipsters trying to get their morning sugar fix, so try to get there early -- everything here is made fresh daily, so popular bites tend to sell out fast.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
2. St. James Cheese Company 5004 Prytania St, New Orleans, LA 70115 (Uptown)

This Uptown eatery is oh-so-more than just a cheese shop. It also sports fantastic sandos that qualify as some of the best in the city, such as its Hooks Cheddar sandwich that's made with Wisconsin Hooks cheddar, smoked turkey, basil, tomato, mayo, and avocado.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
3. Dong Phuong Oriental Bakery 14207 Chef Menteur Hwy, New Orleans, LA 70129

This eastern New Orleans Vietnamese standby might not amount to much from the outside -- with a mixed brick exterior and fading eggshell awning greeting diners -- but the signature bahn-mis here have drawn accolades from the country over. In addition to functioning as a casual full-service restaurant, the venue comes with a bakery that turns over equally excellent pastries like coconut rolls, egg tarts, and strawberry shortcake.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
4. Wayfare 4510 Freret St, New Orleans, LA 70115 (Uptown)

Wayfare is a proud provider of the great American sandwich. Actually, they make a bunch of them, using house-made jams, mustards, and spreads. And if you want to try one of their specialties, go for the Knuckle sandwich, which features roast beef and other amazingness on a pretzel bun.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
5. Cochon Butcher 930 Tchoupitoulas St, New Orleans, LA 70130 (Central Business District)

Donald Link's love letter to Louisiana, Cochon, is back at it again with this meat-centric offshoot. Build your ultimate, meaty sandwich at this hybrid butcher shop, deli counter, and wine bar in the Warehouse District. Inspired by old-world meat markets, Cochon Butcher specializes in house-cured meats, terrines, and sausages. The lines can get long at lunch, making the simple pleasure of sitting at the bar with a drink and a bite feel like a luxury.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
6. Stein's Market & Deli 2207 Magazine St, New Orleans, LA 70130

This deli & market in NOLA's Lower Garden District offers traditional and specialty sandwiches, including breakfast sandwiches (on Davidovich bagels straight from NYC) all day. Stein's also sells a huge selection of cured meats and salamis, over 50 cheeses from around the world, and a massive selection of domestic & international craft beers.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
7. Liberty Cheesesteaks 5031 Freret St, New Orleans, LA 70115 (Uptown)

Located in Uptown New Orleans, Liberty brings the taste of Philly cheesesteaks to Creole Country with classic sammies loaded with steak, onions, and gooey cheese.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
8. McClure's Barbecue 4800 Magazine St, New Orleans, LA 70115 (Uptown)

One of NOLA's finest BBQ joints, McClure's cooks his meats in a gigantic courtyard smoker and gives you the option of selecting from a variety of sauces, including North Carolina-style, sweet Kansas City sauce, and even white Alabama sauce.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
9. Casamento's 4330 Magazine St, New Orleans, LA 70115

A New Orleans landmark since 1919, Casamento's is the grandaddy of all oyster bars, serving up fried oyster po' boys and equally delicious raw oysters, shucked right in front of you. The space is small and completely tiled, because the owners know oyster juice spillage is inevitable when you're marathon-slurping your meal.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
10. Mister Gregory's French Casual Cafe 806 Rampart St, New Orleans, LA 70116 (French Quarter)

This French Quarter cafe is a prime spot for breakfast and coffee, but don't forget its wide variety of sandwiches, which garner plenty of attention themselves.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
11. Kebab 2315 Saint Claude Ave, New Orleans, LA 70117 (Bywater)

This Bywater eatery immediately found a cult-like following after moving in and for excellent reason: its Dutch/German street food is spot on, especially the dark meat chicken doner, which has no equal in town.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
12. The Sammich 7708 Maple St, New Orleans, LA 70118 (Uptown)

This tasty Uptown used to be a pop-up, but they earned enough acclaim and business to launch a brick and mortar that cooks up sophisticated entrees and throws them between two halves of a French bread loaf. Pro tip: get the En Brouchette, which features a combination of fried oysters with bacon, bleu cheese, and meuniere sauce.