Food & Drink

Where to break your New Year's resolutions in New Orleans

Published On 01/02/2014 Published On 01/02/2014

New Orleans has never really been known for its temperance, prudence, and and overall decorum. In fact, it’s pretty much the opposite, and to tell you the truth, the city takes pride in being America’s fat, loud, drunk -- but ooooohhhh, so much fun! -- older uncle. Leave the temperance to Salt Lake City (even if they still have the Jazz as their basketball team, for some inexplicable reason), NOLA will keep its debauchery (and actual jazz) intact, thank you, sir. Which makes it a perfect place to break all the resolutions you just made. Here’s where:

Scott Gold

1. R&O’s Restaurant
What you’re having: a full roast beef po-boy, dressed
In a town filled with po-boys, there is only one that reigns supreme when it comes to roast beef, and it is R&O. A full foot of seeded Leidenheimer French bread piled high with long-simmered, tender roast beef drowning in gravy, it’s a must to order it “dressed” -- i.e. with lettuce, tomatoes, pickles, and plenty of “mynez.” Be sure the napkin dispenser is full. Also, the Lipitor dispenser.

Flickr user TAZphotos

2. Acme Oyster House
French Quarter, Metairie, MSY Airport
What you’re having: Louisiana oysters on the half-shell. ALL OF THEM.
Maybe you decided to take it easy on the living creatures this year (fresh oysters, it turns out, are alive when you eat them, though they generally have little to say about it). If that’s the case, belly up to the bar at Acme and order some oysters. How many? That’s the thing... they just keep shoveling them in front of you until you’ve had your fill. You literally have to tell them “when” and throw in the towel. Add some hot sausage jambalaya, gravy-cheese fries and plenty of cold Abita beer to the experience, and it’s adios resolution/last notch on your belt!

Flickr user Carnaval King 08

3. Central Grocery
French Quarter
What you’re having: a whole muffaletta
And in the red corner, weighing in at three cured meats (Genoa salami, mortadella, Ham), a pound of provolone, olive salad dripping with olive oil, all served on an Italian roll the size of a damn tractor tire, ladies and gentlemen, the undisputed heavyweight champion of New Orleans sandwiches, it’s the Central Grocery whole muffaletta!!! To paraphrase Louis C.K.: even if you’re not a man, if you kill this sandwich on your own, YOU ARE A MAN. Fair warning though, it might actually kill you.

Scott Gold

4. Toups’ Meatery
What you’re having: the house “meat board” followed by a double-cut pork chop
Oh, so you thought you were going to be a vegetarian for a spell this year? Not once you walk in the door at Toups’, you’re not. Start with their “meat board”, filled with a Noah's Ark of cholesterol, from Cajun fried cracklins to foie gras, fried boudin balls, deviled eggs, cured ham, fried jalapeño poppers, candied duck rillons, sausages, meatballs, and more. Top that off with a double-cut pork chop the size of a man’s head, and you’ll be on PETA’s kill-list for sure.

Tropical Isle

5. Tropical Isle
Bourbon St
What you’re having: the hand grenade
Wave bye-bye to that nice, clean liver, my friend, because at Tropical Isle it’s all about the “re-tox”. Touted as “New Orleans’ most powerful drink,” the hand grenade is most likely a mixture of grain alcohol, sugar, and something that turns it a horrifying shade of radioactive chartreuse (and it’s guaranteed NOT to be actual Chartreuse).

Flickr user y6y6y6

6. Joey K’s
Garden District
What you’re having: all-you-can-eat fried catfish
While Joey K’s has some of the best red beans in town, not to mention killer daily specials like a giant lamb shank covered in rich gravy (Tuesdays, FYI), if you’re looking to pack an artery, the best thing to do is partake in what is essentially a fried catfish orgy that would make ancient Roman emperor Vitelius blush.

Bourbon House

7. Bourbon House
French Quarter
What you’re having: bourbon (duh) and seafood
Oh, bourbon. America’s official spirit. Bourbon is so delicious and wonderful, New Orleans decided to name a very famous street after it (shut up, ancient French dynasty!), and on that street, you'll find Bourbon House, which sports a list of over 80 different bottles of American whiskey from Baker’s all the way to Vintage rye. Top that off with a variety of baked oysters (Rockefeller, Bienville, and Fonseca), Crab Fingers Bordelaise, and NOLA-style BBQ shrimp swimming in butter sauce to complete the experience, and possibly your life.

Ted's Frostop

8. Ted’s Frostop
Uptown and Metairie
What you’re having: a double “Lot-o Burger” with chili and cheese, waffle fries, and a gigantic ice cream sundae
When you’re getting ready to drop that resolution to “not eat until you get gout”, and your plan is to do so with a hamburger, why go out of your way for a hoity-toity gourmet burger with things like pickled shiitakes on it? For an honest-to-god heart-stopper of a beef puck, it’s difficult to beat the Double Lot-o at Frostop, most notably because they actually add rich creamery butter to the meat. Plus, their waffle fries are off the chain, and the place has enough ice cream to kill a mule. 

BONUS: Ted’s Frostop (see above)
What you’re having (if you’re not having the Lot-o Burger, waffle fries, and a float): the “Player’s Breakfast” -- four scrambled eggs, four sausages/strips of bacon, two pancakes, extra cheesy grits, and your choice of drink
Why is Frostop on this list twice? BECAUSE PLAYER’S BREAKFAST.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
1. R & O's 216 Metairie Hammond Hwy, Metairie, LA 70005

R & O's plates a variety of Creole/Cajun dishes, but they're best known for their po' boys and other tasty sammies.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
2. Acme Oyster House 724 Iberville St, New Orleans, LA 70130 (French Quarter)

This iconic oyster spot may have a number of locations, but despite its chain status, it still serves some of the tastiest seafood in New Orleans, not to mention some interesting cocktails that include an oyster-topped Bloody Mary and oyster shooters w/ vodka.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
3. Central Grocery 923 Decatur St, New Orleans, LA 70116 (French Quarter)

There’s no disputing that this small Italian grocery with a deli counter, which dates back to 1906, invented the muffaletta, and still has its flag firmly planted in that fertile territory. Truth be told, the CG muff, served cold and not always overstuffed with meats and cheeses, has been surpassed in recent years by other eateries. But if you’ve never been there, do yourself a favor and wait in line for the original, if only for the experience. Also, don’t forget that Central Grocery is also a grocery, with tons of canned, fresh, and dried Italian goodies for your sweet nonna.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
4. Toups' Meatery 845 N. Carrollton, New Orleans, LA 70119 (Mid City)

Helmed by James Beard Award-winning chef Isaac Toups, this Mid-City spot serves a carnivore-centric menu with bold Cajun flavor. Large entrees like the grilled Georgia quail with farm-fresh seasonal vegetables and saba satiate and surprise; light bites range from addictive cracklins and deviled eggs with smoked trout roe. Minimalist metal chairs and refurbished wood surfaces give Toups a cabin-like feel that enhances the relaxed, convivial vibe.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
5. Tropical Isle 721 Bourbon St, New Orleans, LA 70116 (French Quarter)

Tropical Isle is an essential part of New Orleans, for better or worse. The Bourbon St bar is known for the Hand Grenade, a gigantic drink that tastes vaguely of melon but mostly of alcohol. The crowd is a mix of what you'd expect from a bar known for its bad decision-inducing cocktails: college kids and out-of-towners, but that tourist trap-meets-frat party vibe is all part of the experience.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
6. Joey K's 3001 Magazine St, New Orleans, LA 70115

Located at the heart of Magazine St, Joey K's is a local favorite for homestyle NOLA specialties like jambalaya, po-boys, catfish, and red beans & rice.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
7. Bourbon House 144 Bourbon St, New Orleans, LA 70130 (French Quarter)

Bourbon House is a prime exemplar of what NOLA's all about, cuisine wise-- it serves up fresh seasonal, seafood dishes, has a great oyster bar on hand, and is home to more kinds of bourbon than you ever knew existed. This place is legit. The New Orleans Bourbon Society was created there, and continues to meet to discuss bourbon, drink bourbon, and even eat bourbon-themed meals.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
8. Ted's Frostop 3100 Calhoun St, New Orleans, LA 70125 (Uptown)

This retro diner has been serving burgers, milkshakes, po' boys, and breakfast specials since the 50s. Everything about Ted's is a total throwback, from the window-serve and picnic tables to the prices (example: all you can eat pancakes for less than $10 is a steal). The classic move is to get the Loto Burger dressed with mayonnaise, mustard, and the usual fixins, and a root beer float. Trust us: the fried and griddled goods from Ted's is better than what you'll get at any generic fast-food joint.