Food & Drink

The Best Tasting Menus in NYC for Under $100

Updated On 09/10/2018 at 06:07PM EST Updated On 09/10/2018 at 06:07PM EST
Empellon
Courtesy of Empellon
Noah Fecks

Sugarfish

Flatiron

Price: $27  
A lot of NYC omakase is aspirational. “I’ll leave it up to you” menus can run hundreds of dollars. Add a sake pairing and BOOM -- you’re a source in a trend piece about why millennials will never own homes. It’s probably best not to ask how they do it, but Sugarfish’s “Trust Me Lite” option includes edamame, tuna sashimi, albacore sushi, salmon sushi, yellowtail sushi, shrimp sushi, and a toro hand roll for $27 at dinner and $23 (minus the yellowtail) at lunch. With rules regarding how to sauce, salt, and eat your fish, you know this place means business.

L&B Spumoni Gardens

Gravesend

Price: $50-$70/person
A restaurant older than your grandparents and perhaps better known for its outdoor pizza and ice cream counter service than fine dining may not be your go-to for a fancy dinner, but hear us out. Inside L&B’s dining room, the Chef’s Table allows for groups as small as two (and as large as 200) to fill up on a custom four-course tasting menu ($50-$70/person, depending on selections) with nonna-approved options including baked clams, “pasta-bilities” like penne alla vodka, daily meat specials, and a dessert platter piled with cannoli, spumoni, and more sugary treats that may make you wish you held back a little on the first, second, and third courses.

Courtesy of Empellon

Empellon

Midtown

Price: $38
The best time to visit fancy taco chef Alex Stupak’s emporium of elevated tacos is during lunchtime on weekdays or Sunday nights, when $38 gets you a three-course prix fixe. Choose from starters, like the sticky rice tamal with spicy duck, a roster of greatest hits tacos (think fish tempura and thick-cut bacon versions) and Insta-friendly desserts that cut through the heat of all that salsa you loaded on the main course.

Pig & Khao

Pig & Khao

Lower East Side

Price: $55
Chef Leah Cohen offers a $55/person, five-course tasting menu at her Southeast Asian restaurant Sunday through Thursday. Expect a range of Thai and Filipino inspired dishes, like papaya salad with crispy taro, spicy slow-cooked meats and crispy Malaysian-style fried chicken. These are generous portions of excellent food without the typical prix fixe pretense.
 

Mission Chinese

Mission Chinese

Chinatown

Price: $45-$99
Deciding what to order at Mission Chinese can feel like Mission: Impossible, so leave the work to the kitchen with a tasting menu option. Twosomes (who love leftovers) can go for the $45/person “quick mission dinner” which includes Chongqing chicken wings, a noodle dish, salt cod fried rice, mapo tofu, and broccoli beef brisket (a vegetarian version of the tasting menu is also served). Larger groups can embark on the banquet-style “suggested” menu for $65/person, which includes a larger range of dishes. Don your stretchy pants for the “feast,” which, at $99/person, adds country-fried lamb breast or a whole fish, and dessert to the equation.

Delaware and Hudson

Williamsburg

Price: $75
Chef Patti Jackson’s Michelin-starred, 38-seat Williamsburg haunt offers one of the best tasting menus in town. The locally sourced, seasonally changing American fare includes shareable apps, a first course (pasta!), a hearty main course (duck, sea bass, or braised beef cheeks), and dessert for less than you’d probably spend at most other Michelin-starred restaurants on just an entree and app.

Babu Ji

Babu Ji

Union Square

Price: $62
Instead of arguing with your tablemates over which curries, koftas, and tandoori chops you’ll share, opt into Babu Ji’s chef’s selection. The colorful restaurant’s capable kitchen will send out round after round of spicy, creamy dishes, best enjoyed with a $24 beer or $34 wine pairings. Plates are presented in a no-filter-friendly rainbow of delights, ending with homemade cardamom, honey, and pistachio kulfi -- a creamy popsicle-like sweet that could easily put Mister Softee out of business.

Sushi on Jones

NoHo

Price: $58
After sushi chef David Bouhadana was ousted from the East Village’s Sushi Dojo for refusing to wear gloves while preparing tastings that New Yorkers would book weeks in advance, he jumped into New York's affordable omakase craze with this al fresco omakase bar. He's since broken off to launch Sushi by Bou, a similar concept, but the original bargain sushi spot remains. And no, bargain doesn’t mean imitation crab -- expect uni, hamachi, scallop, eel, and wagyu at this $58, 12-piece tasting. The only catch is you have to scarf it all down in 30 minutes.

Atoboy

ATOBOY

Flatiron

Price: $42
Expect excellent service in a relaxed environment at this “casual fine-dining restaurant,” where three dishes of your choice plus rice will run you less than a Ulysses S. Grant. It isn’t a tasting menu in the strictest sense, but it’s affordable and lets you mix-and-match 15 varieties of Korean style tapas like yellowtail with white kimchi, jicama, and horseradish; corn with taleggio, bacon, and doenjang; and pork jowl with barley, ssamjang, and cipollini onion.

Courtesy of Contra

Contra

Lower East Side

Price: $78
Years after its 2013 opening, reserving a coveted seat in Contra’s dining room is still harder than scoring Hamilton tickets. The nightly rotating six-course menu of local, seasonal ingredients -- think guinea hen with potato and agretti, lobster with green asparagus and walnut, or black bass with kumquat and olive -- stays in demand as much for its price as its fare. An abbreviated bar menu run s $48, if you can nab one of just eight seats.