Food & Drink

The 12 Best Seafood Restaurants in NYC

Published On 06/23/2015 Published On 06/23/2015
Doug Lyle Thompson

With the profusion of killer oysters, fat lobster rolls, and all-you-can-eat crab, you'd be silly to not to dive into these, the 12 best seafood restaurants in the city. NYC is a coastal city -- it's time to act like it!

Courtesy of Vicky Wasik

Freshest catch: Greenpoint Fish & Lobster Co.

You know the fish is fresh when you can spy it all glistening in the cases up front. Fifth-generation fishmonger (fifth-monger? Nope.) Vincent Milburn and co-owner Adam Geringer-Dunn oversee this white-tiled restaurant/market, and expertly turn local catches into craveable comfort food -- think fried oyster breakfast tacos and Thai-style mussels.

Courtesy of Daniel Krieger

Best sushi: Sushi Nakazawa

West Village
NYC has no shortage of sushi masters, but none are able to balance the seriousness of the craft with a sense of humor quite like Daisuke Nakazawa. But it isn’t just the Jiro Dreams of Sushi star's antics behind the bar (like wriggling live shrimp in front of diners) that propelled this relative newcomer to the top -- the omakase, featuring buttery fish and his signature tamago, is truly exquisite.

Best crabs: Clemente’s Maryland Crab House

Sheepshead Bay
The king crustaceans show up in multiple dishes at this South Brooklyn cash-only spot, but what you're really here for is for the all-you-can-eat feast -- freshly boiled crabs seasoned in one of two ways: Maryland style with Old Bay or with garlic, in a nod to the neighborhood’s Italian roots. Fine print: the buffet option is only available on Monday and Tuesday.

Courtesy of Cull & Pistol

Best happy hour: Cull and Pistol

Do happy hour right by 1) actually leaving work early enough for happy hour, and 2) consuming $1 oysters and $6 Bloody Marys at this bar on weekdays from 4-6pm. And although this white-tile-lined Chelsea Market hideaway is excellent, don't feel beholden to it -- there are 64 other damn-fine oyster happy hours in this city to choose from.

Courtesy of Barchetta

Best crudo: Barchetta

The rotating crudos are minimal, as fish whisperer Dave Pasternack lets everything speak for itself. The $25 tasting, which includes samples of six fish, is one of the best seafood deals around.

Courtesy of Doug Lyle Thompson

Best water view: Grand Banks

Throw back cocktails and oysters on the deck of the Sherman Zwicker, a historic fishing vessel docked off Tribeca’s Pier 25. Unless you have super-rich friends with sailboats or you commute from Staten Island, this seasonal floating bar is the closest you'll get to boating all sweltering summer long.

Courtesy of Ted Axelrod

Best Italian seafood: Marea

Midtown West
Pasta man Michael White's Marea (that’s Italian for “tide!”) masterfully combines regional Italian cuisine with seriously fresh fish. Try the prized pasta with the wine-braised octopus fusilli or tagliolini with Manila clams, and revel in the fact that it's one of the most affordable ways to eat at a Michelin-starred restaurant.

Courtesy of Luke’s Lobster

Best lobster roll: Luke’s Lobster

East Village, FiDi, UWS, UES, Brooklyn Bridge Park, Midtown East, Park Slope
The freshest in town, this lobster roll bursts with top-secret, spice-enhanced claw and knuckle meat in every bite. Maine native Luke Hold and partner Ben Conniff's nautically themed shack is expanding at an alarming rate for good reason.

Courtesy of Maison Premiere

Best seafood tower: Maison Premiere

If there’s anything more impressive than the cocktails at this NOLA-inspired drinkery, it’s "La Grande" Plateau, an impressive, three-tiered seafood tower that teeters with scallops, caviar-topped lobster, multiple types of clams and, as a finishing garnish, sea urchin served in its spiky shell. It's $150, so make sure the person you're dining with is worth it.

Courtesy of Ryan Smith

Best whole-fish dinner: John Dory Oyster Bar

Forget roast chicken for two or a massive prime rib -- the star of April Bloomfield’s large-format Ace Hotel seafood spot is a whole tempura-fried red snapper. Sides like a papaya salad, green curry eggplant, and coconut rice complete the belly-busting spread.

Best oysters: The Mermaid Inn

East Village
The oyster game at this institution is so superb that they created an app -- the appropriately named Oysterpedia -- that helps you order bivalves like a pro.

Courtesy of Littleneck

Cheapest without being terrible: Littleneck

With most items ringing up at under $20 (including the lobster roll), diners certainly get the most bang for their buck at Aaron Lefkove and Andy Curtin’s Brooklyn joint. Be true to the name and get the clams -- steamed, in chowder or, best yet, battered and deep fried for the whole belly Ipswich roll.

Sign up here for our daily NYC email and be the first to get all the food/drink/fun New York has to offer.

Patty Lee is a reporter and editor who has written for Zagat, Time Out New York, New York Daily News, and Cooking Channel. At all other times: an eater of desserts, aspiring world traveler, and proud Brooklynite. Follow her on Twitter and Instagram.



Learn More