Food & Drink

The Most Criminally Underrated Restaurants in Philly

Published On 09/16/2015 Published On 09/16/2015

In a city with as many great restaurants as Philly, it’s easy to... get fat. Just kidding! It’s easy to overlook hidden gems that don’t get the recognition they deserve, that’s why we’ve rounded up some sweet spots that’re turning out eats just as good -- or even better -- than some of their often overhyped counterparts. These are the 11 most criminally underrated restaurants in Philadelphia...

Abyssinia

Abyssinia

University City
What you’re getting: Doro vot

Straddling the line of University City, Abyssinia is sometimes seen as just a destination for college students, and as a result, the unassuming place where portions are big and the prices are small, is the ideal spot for a quiet, gratuitously sized meal. Pro tip, though: don’t go if you’re in a rush. Much like eating Ethiopian food in itself, dining at Abyssinia is an engaged process that may be a bit time consuming.

Tres Jalapeños

Tres Jalapeños

Bella Vista
What you’re getting: Al pastor tacos

This Tex-Mex spot in the heart of Bella Vista has all the staples you look for in your traditional Tex-Mex spot without any overly trendy distractions taking away from the food. An ardent observer of Margarita Monday, Taco Tuesday, and Fajita Wednesday (hey, it can be a thing), the restaurant offers plenty of deals that make the authentic fare go down all the more easily. The spot was formerly BYOB but now boasts a tequila-slinging bar, which may have been the restaurant's missing piece, keeping it from getting the recognition it deserves.

Lucky’s Last Chance

Lucky’s Last Chance

Manayunk
What you’re getting: Bacon, egg & cheese burger

Lucky's is one of dozens of bars lining Main Street in the 'Yunk, meaning it falls prey to the neighborhood's influx of bar-hopping Villanova and St. Joe's students, but it's way more than a watering hole for coeds trying to "get lucky." The menu is full of creative burger, hot dog, and French fry options that pair perfectly with one of the more extensive beer and drink menus that Manayunk has to offer. Oh, and extra points for a friendly service staff that is always helpful and upbeat despite said frequent influx of college students.

Seafood Unlimited

Seafood Unlimited

Rittenhouse
What you’re getting: Garlic-herb mussels

The name of this Fitler Square restaurant is actually pretty accurate, so it’s good news that it offers daily deals that’ll help you get through some of the sweetest seafood options. Eventually. This means all-you-can-eat mussel Mondays, impromptu lobster dinners at a discount, and seasonal specialties that include things like soft-shell crab alongside $3 Yuenglings. Bonus: if you're looking for a fresh brunch spot, this place does not disappoint, whether you opt for crabmeat Benedict or shrimp & grits with a side of endless bellinis.
 

Giorgio on Pine

Washington Square West
What you’re getting: Spinach, prosciutto, and mozzarella-stuffed chicken breast

With so many Italian restaurants in Philly, this unassuming BYOB can be easily overlooked -- but it shouldn’t be. The savory pastas (like the braised beef gnocchi), and some sweet pizza options are some of the most perfect comfort foods you’ll find on this side of the park, and the place gets extra points for somehow making a gluten-free Italian menu that is actually not-terrible, meaning Giorgio leaves no diner behind when it comes to pasta.

Positano Coast

Positano Coast

Old City
What you’re getting: Zucchini crab cake

Somehow in all the good food Old City has to offer, the killer menu (and roof deck!) at Positano is sometimes left out. The Mediterranean-inspired menu includes specialties like Italian sashimi, tuna tartare, and verde risotto, as well as plenty of staple meat and seafood dishes alongside more innovative plates. The food menu is matched with a wine list chock-full of hand-selected picks from smaller niche vineyards with an emphasis on Italian wines. The second-floor deck is... um, decked out to feel like wherever you went on your Mediterranean vacation, making your meal a sweet escape.

Miles Table

Miles Table

Graduate Hospital
What you’re getting: Miles burger

This unexpectedly refreshing eatery is just a stone’s throw from Bob & Barbara’s and some other favorite South St haunts, but the menu is a far cry from $2 PBRs and Jim Beam. The casual spot has something for everyone, whether you’re hungry for a good breakfast sandwich, or opt for one of the burger/not-breakfast sandwich options. Miles Table also has a surprisingly great taco selection, and yes, they taste just as great when discounted on Tuesdays.

Vientiane Cafe

Vientiane Cafe

Spruce Hill
What you’re getting: Thai catfish

It turns out that some of the best Thai food in the city is hiding out in West Philly. The family-run business turns out authentic Thai cuisine from a business that started directly out of the chef’s house some 13 years ago, gaining a local following just from word of mouth. The BYOB resto works to make the traditional cuisine adaptable for people with diet restrictions, like vegan or gluten-free eaters, and is perfectly suited for a big group dinner or just a quick bite.
 

Modo Mio

Fishtown
What you’re getting: Bistecca Rossini

Despite Modo Mio’s proximity to the Girard MFL stop, its location is a bit off the beaten path from the main drag of Fishtown, plus the BYO’s cash-only policy can be an annoyance for diners, but it’s worth the trip to the ATM. Even if you find yourself annoyed by overcrowding or too much noise heard from the next table, take a deep breath and find peace in the authentic Italian fare, whether you opt for the tagliatelle pasta (chicken liver, mushrooms, black truffle) or seared filet mignon.

Verdad

Verdad

Bryn Mawr
What you’re getting: Strawberry habanero guacamole

Considering all the great Spanish tapas the city has to offer, it may seem strange to venture out to the ‘burbs in search of more, but Verdad will make your mouth water during the entire train ride. In addition to booze flights that help you sample the Main Line spot’s extensive tequila menu, margaritas served el fuego, and authentic paella that could easily feed your entire table, Verdad is the perfect pick for post-work happy hour or a first date. Happy hour also comes around twice at Verdad -- in addition to serving discounted drinks from 5-7pm during the week, you can usually score deals from 10pm-12am some weeknights as well.

Llama Tooth

Llama Tooth

Callowhill
What you’re getting: Buffalo blue chicken mac 'n' cheese

Despite a truly wonderful beer menu and a small but satisfying selection of comfort foods (think mac 'n’ cheese and burgers), there always seem to be far more empty chairs than occupied ones in Llama’s expansive outdoor area. Just across the street from Union Transfer, it’s the perfect spot for pre-concert dinner/drinks, or the place to be if you just want the ambiance of dining beside a Philadelphia mural under the twinkle of golden string lights. The friendly waitstaff is exceedingly patient when it comes to helping you decide which beer to try, and the servers’ extensive knowledge of each brew comes in handy as you maneuver through the menu.

Sign up here for our daily Philly email and be the first to get all the food/drink/fun in town.

Marielle Mondon is a Philly-born editor and writer. Follow @MarielleMondon on Twitter and Instagram.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
1. Abyssinia 229 S 45th St, Philadelphia, PA 19104

This Ethiopian restaurant serves large plates for a small price in a quiet atmosphere with simple surroundings. There's an upstairs bar in addition to the main dining room.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
2. Tres Jalapeños 901 S 8th St, Philadelphia, PA 19147

This formerly BYOB restaurant serves standard Tex-Mex fare with vegan options and has no shortage of gimmicky deals like Margarita Monday and Taco Tuesday. The introduction of a liquor bar has turned this underrated place into a real Philly gem.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
3. Lucky's Last Chance 4421 Main St, Philadelphia, PA 19127 (Manayunk)

Lucky's brought pub-height two-tops into the former Yunkers while covering the walls with a rose-vine mosaic and sweet vintage beer posters, serving serious burgers prepped with local ingredients and a tidy roster of craft brews.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
4. Seafood Unlimited 270 S 20th St, Philadelphia, PA 19103

This fish restaurant offers a daily rotating menu of fresh seafood. Mondays are for all-you-can-eat mussels, reasonably-priced lobster dinners are impromptu and seasonally-inspired dishes are always being debuted. The spot is also great for brunch with items like shrimp & grits and crabmeat Benedict.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
5. Giorgio on Pine 1328 Pine St, Philadelphia, PA 19107

This rustic Italian trattoria in Washington Square West supplies a variety of gluten-free eats among other Italian classics, like a prosciutto platter, veal melanzane, and gnocchi tossed in house made, 12-hour braised beef ragout. Giorgio on Pine is also BYOB, so guests can enjoy the traditional cuisine with their favorite bottle of wine.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
6. Positano Coast 212 Walnut St, Philadelphia, PA 19106

This airy mediterranean restaurant has a roof deck and serves small plates with a seafood focus. There's tuna tartare, Italian sashimi and other inventive plates alongside more traditional staples. The wine list is hand-curated with an emphasis on Italian grapes.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
7. Miles Table 1620 South St, Philadelphia, PA 19146 (South Street)

Head to Miles Table for fresh brunch staples and a few wild-card dishes. It’s one of few trusted places in Philly for a decent bagel, so try the Nova Bagel (smoked salmon, cheese, lettuce, tomato, and onion) with a side of Red Pepper Home Fries.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
8. Vientiane Cafe 4728 Baltimore Ave, Philadelphia, PA 19143

This Laotian-Thai BYOB cafe is compact but can still accommodate group dinners. Expect authentic food from this family-run joint that is more than willing to accommodate dietary restrictions like vegetarianism and gluten intolerance.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
9. Modo Mio 161 W Girard Ave, Philadelphia, PA 19123 (Nolibs)

Modo Mio is serving up some great Italian food in NoLibs and is a great place to bring a bunch of friends to enjoy a good meal and good times.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
10. Verdad Restaurant & Tequila Bar 818 W Lancaster Ave, Bryn Mawr, PA 19010

Euro-Latin tapas and creative cocktails shine in this stylish eatery in the 'burbs. Get adventurous with a tequila flight to sample their extensive liquor menu or catch one of their two happy hour windows: one in the early evening and one later on in the night.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
11. Llama Tooth 1033 Spring Garden St, Philadelphia, PA 19123 (Spring Garden)

You can’t get more Philly than drinking microbrews next to a mural. This Spring Garden spot is a great asset to the rising neighborhood and has some great brews to try.

Clickbait