Food & Drink

The 13 Most Essential Restaurants in State College, PA

Published On 08/19/2015 Published On 08/19/2015

As much as State College is one of the best college towns in America, it’s often derided for its lack of defining restaurants. And although it’s true that there’s been an influx of chains in recent years, there is still a good number of worthy places for a bite in this town yet! Check out the 13 best restaurants in State College, PA.

Otto's Pub & Brewery

Best burger: Otto’s Pub & Brewery

2235 N Atherton St
Otto’s may be best known for its beers (an on-site distillery is on the way!), but the burgers with locally-sourced ingredients are where it’s at. Try the Cowboy, with barbecue sauce and bacon, The Ottonator (pancetta, grilled onions, and Amish white cheddar), or the Juicy Lucy, a take on the Minneapolis classic.

Faccia Luna Pizzeria

Best pizza: Faccia Luna

1229 S Atherton St
Widely regarded as State College’s premier pizza joint for students, alumni, visitors, and townies alike, its oven is wood-fired and the pepperoni is the curly edged kind. The toppings here are anything but pedestrian.

Flickr/Razlan

Best sandwich: Happy Valley Brewing Company

137 Elmwood St
Start with the short rib nachos, then dig into the intense Shish Kicker -- a grilled chicken sandwich topped with fontina, shishito peppers, and garlic aioli -- paired with a brewed-on-site Tailgater Pale Ale or a Phyrst Phamily Stout.

Dayoung Kim/The Waffle Shop

Best breakfast/brunch: Original Waffle Shop

1610 W College Ave & 1229 N Atherton St
Be prepared for a wait on any weekend, but especially Sundays following Penn State home games. Don’t let the line deter you, though -- there’s a reason for the crowds. The headlining waffles are huge, and the chicken noodle soup will make you wish for a head cold more often.

Saint's Cafe

Best cafe: Saint’s Café

123 W Beaver Ave
A quality cafe is a must in any college town, and this little shop with its outdoor seating is an excellent place to cram for an upcoming exam, or to simply enjoy the nice weather that occasionally decides to visit central Pennsylvania.

Kelly's Steak and Seafood

Best steakhouse with a cow on its roof: Kelly’s Steak & Seafood

316 Boal Ave, Boalsburg
OK, so technically this roadhouse isn’t in State College proper, but it is only four miles down Route 322. The giant rooftop bull gives it the air of a tourist trap, but it’s anything but -- State College residents themselves lauded it as the town’s best steakhouse eight years running.

Allen Street Grill

Best date spot: Allen Street Grill

100 W College Ave
Located on the second floor of the more than 150-year-old Hotel State College, the view here is downright iconic. Prices are reasonable for students, and the vibe is classy (there’s a piano!) without being black-tie. Sit near the giant windows and watch "The Corner” -- where College Ave meets Allen St -- bustle below, then head to the bar for live music every Wednesday through Saturday night.

Margarita's

Best value: Margarita’s Pizzeria

222 W Beaver Ave
Although college kids will invariably tell you the best cheap slice in town is Canyon Pizza, our sleeper hit is several blocks west. Margarita’s, squished between a parking deck and an apartment building, is no-frills but not in a way that feels cheap -- the menu is surprisingly deep (for a pizza place, anyway) and the staff even remembers regulars’ orders.

Bill Pickle's Tap Room

Best place to watch a game: Bill Pickle’s Tap Room

106 S Allen St
Despite the presence of one of America’s most successful university athletic programs, State College doesn’t have an abundance of true sports bars. Enter Pickle’s, with its central location, drink specials, and TVs for watching Pittsburgh and Philadelphia duke it out over bocce ball.  A big portrait of the bar’s namesake hangs on the back wall. Was he a real person? No! Doesn’t matter.

Duffy's Tavern

Best wings: Duffy’s Tavern

113 E Main St, Boalsburg
This roadside pub and patio -- established in 1819 -- serves the standards, but creative options like Wasabi Garlic Ranch, Thai Maple Soy, and Bacon Habanero Ranch are what you’re here for. The name of the latter is rarely spoken aloud for fear of jinxing its presence at Wednesday wing nights. It’s that good.

Local Whiskey

Best late-night food: Local Whiskey

107 E Beaver Ave
It’s located directly above one of the top college bars in America with a kitchen that’s open until at least 2am, so you do the math. The impressive late-night menu from connected Famous Ernie’s Steaks comes complete with cheesesteak egg rolls, a Beaver Burger (not the animal meat -- gross! -- just the street name), and the best Reuben in town. Fries come in two sizes: plate and tray.

The Tavern Restaurant

Best place you’ll probably go to after graduation but should really go to more often: The Tavern

220 E College Ave
An institution since 1948, it’s the go-to post-graduation spot (likely because of all the Penn State ephemera decorating the walls), but that doesn’t mean you shouldn’t visit year-round. The menu changes frequently but is heavy on steaks and seafood, and sides are unlimited.

Herwig's Austrian Bistro

Best place to get yelled at for not finishing your food: Herwig’s Austrian Bistro

132 W College Ave
Reasons to come here: 1) it’s BYOB, 2) the schnitzel. Oh, the schnitzel, and 3) the huge, huge portions that you better finish -- you’ll be scolded otherwise!

Sign up here for our daily Philly email and be the first to get all the food/drink/fun in town.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
1. Otto's Pub & Brewery 2235 N Atherton St, State College, PA 16803

This brewery and bar hybrid offers a wide selection of in-house and local beers and serves American classics like burgers with locally sourced ingredients and mac and cheese.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
2. Faccia Luna 1229 S Atherton St, State College, PA 16801

This local favorite serves casual Italian fare and incredible pizza to students, alumni and visitors alike. Their wood oven cooks pizzas to perfection and the pepperoni is the kind that curls and crisps at the edges.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
3. Happy Valley Brewing Company 137 Elmwood St, State College, PA 16801

This eatery and microbrewery brings together craft beers and quirky comfort food in a converted barn. Be sure to order the short rib nachos!

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
4. Original Waffle Shop 1229 N Atherton St, State College, PA 16803

You likely won't get into this waffle joint without waiting your turn but it's guaranteed to be well worth it. The upbeat eatery offers their famous waffles along with other classic breakfast dishes and lunch fare.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
5. Saint's Cafe 123 W Beaver Ave, State College, PA 16801

This is a quintessential college cafe that caters to studying and chilling needs. Enjoy their outdoor patio while enjoying quality coffee and baked goods.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
6. Kelly's Steak and Seafood 316 Boal Ave, Boalsburg, PA 16827

Four miles out of State College, PA, this joint has been rated by local residents as the best steakhouse 8 years running. Don't let the giant cow on the roof fool you into thinking this is a tourist trap. If you do, you'll be missing out on some quality eats.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
7. Allen Street Grill 100 W College Ave, State College, PA 16801

Enjoy burgers, steak and seafood at this iconic establishment with a homey vibe. It's located on the second floor of the 150-year-old State College Hotel. The piano and delicious cocktails make it feel classy but not too fancy.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
8. Margarita's Pizzeria 222 W Beaver Ave, State College, PA 16801

This place has a surprisingly packed menu and serves up some of the cheapest, most delicious pizza in State College. The staff is incredibly friendly and remembers the orders of regulars.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
9. Bill Pickle's Tap Room 106 S Allen St, State College, PA 16801

This enduring sports bar is lively and packed with TVs to watch your favorite Philly (or Pittsburgh) team. Count on good wings, good beer, and other tasty bar bites.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
10. Duffy's Tavern 113 E Main St, Boalsburg, PA 16827

This Victorian tavern - established in 1819 - serves standard fare with exciting twists like Wasabi Garlic Ranch and Thai Maple Soy wings. There's an upscale dining room and a casual bar so you can choose your experience.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
11. Local Whiskey 107 E Beaver Ave, State College, PA 16801

This cocktail bar serves up over 200 types of whiskey and keeps their kitchen open until 2am, guaranteeing a very delicious late night. Be sure to order the fries, which come in two sizes: plate and tray.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
12. The Tavern Restaurant 220 E College Ave, State College, PA 16801

This colonial-style eatery feels homey in all the right ways. Around since 1948, it's a go-to graduation spot for college students and their families. It's worth stopping by any time of the year though, as their seafood, steak and pasta are always up to par.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
13. Herwig's Austrian Bistro 132 W College Ave, State College, PA 16801

Classic Austrian fare from sauerkraut to sausages & schnitzel is served up at this cozy restaurant with huge portions. The best part? It's BYOB!

Clickbait