Food & Drink

The Thrillist Awards: Pittsburgh's Best New Food & Drink of 2015

Published On 12/17/2015 Published On 12/17/2015
COURTESY OF GRAPPERIA (Edited)

Pittsburgh’s food renaissance has continued through 2015 with stand-out restaurants and bars from both established chefs and welcome newcomers. Key innovations from the past year include new recipes for artisan dough, a coffee shop/art gallery hybrid, and a cocktail menu made of vintage office supplies. Several spots have emerged from vacant or unused buildings (take that, urban sprawl!), a testament to the city’s rebirth and growth. We’ve honed in on 11 best-of Pittsburgh categories to highlight new additions to the city.

Adam Milliron/Morcilla

Best new restaurant (overall)

Morcilla

Address and Info

Lawrenceville

Despite opening in the last few weeks of 2015, this highly anticipated Spanish tapas restaurant from James Beard Award-nominated chef Justin Severino (Cure) has wowed diners with its ample selection of cured meats. Aside from the signature charcuterie, the menu offers pintxos (snacks), seafood tapas, sandwiches, family-style dishes, and a twisted churro dessert with mugs of hazelnut chocolate and cinnamon cream.

Spirit

Best new bar (overall)

Spirit

Address and Info

Lawrenceville

With its expansive disco ball-adorned dance floor, cheap PBRs, and an in-house pizza shop, this Moose Lodge-turned-bar has quickly won hearts in Lawrenceville. Themed events are hosted regularly from Divas Night to punk shows to the popular “In Bed By Ten” dance party series (for all you dancy party dads out there). 

Courtesy of Voodoo Brewery

Best new brewery

Voodoo Brewery

Address and Info

Homestead

There’s something for every beer drinker at Voodoo Brewery’s new location, from the hoppy “Good Vibes” to the malty “Big Brown Ale.” The spray-painted murals and chalk drawings on the ceiling of this former municipal building are part of the aesthetic charm. Voodoo is just outside the city limits, but it’s so close and so good that it’s worth the trip across the Homestead Grays Bridge. 

Adam Milliron/Biergarten

Best new beer bar 

Biergarten

Address and Info

Downtown

On the roof of the freshly minted Hotel Monaco, Biergarten’s outdoor space was quickly touted as a summertime favorite. The patio’s long picnic tables were full all season (when it was sunny, anyway). The Belgian and German beers are the main attraction, of course, but it’s hard to ignore the waitstaff walking around with hot pretzels big enough to share with the whole table and people cheering (maturely) over oversized patio games.

Courtesy of Alyssa Florentine

Best new cocktail bar 

Butcher and the Rye

Address and Info

Downtown

Butcher and the Rye’s cocktail program achieved all-star status long ago, but this year’s fall/winter menu outdid itself. The 38-cocktail menu is alphabetized and presented in a Bates address book, a sleek vintage relic that appears as if plucked from Don Draper’s desk. A few standouts from the menu: "Conqueror’s Ruin" with a surprise garam masala syrup; "Joy of Landing," which is the legit version of an apple martini; and "European Songs," a mix of gin and Champagne, chilled with lemon sorbet ice cubes.

Maria Palermo/Grapperia

Best new drink

Grapperia’s “LaVanda”

Address and Info

Lawrenceville

Until this year, grappa was tough to find in Pittsburgh, even as an aperitif in Italian restaurants. But Grapperia made the stiff, grape-based liquor more accessible by mixing it into cocktails. The best is a not-too-sweet, not-too-potent drink called "LaVanda," a mix of lavender-infused grappa, green pepper honey, and lemon juice.

Bread and Salt

Best new pizza 

Bread and Salt

Address and Info

Bloomfield

The pizza at Bread and Salt is unlike any other in the city. Not only is it the best new pizza in 2015, it might just be the best in Pittsburgh -- period. This Roman-style (raised dough in long, rectangular shapes) gourmet pizza is sold by the pound, measured out based on each customer’s order and snipped into slices with a large pair of scissors. No matter the toppings: from the more traditional to the unusual, it’s the airy dough that makes this slice so otherworldly.

Smoq Pitt

Best new barbecue joint 

Smoq Pitt

Address and Info

Brookline

At Smoq Pitt, meats are smoked for more than 20 hours, sealing in an authentic smoky flavor and guaranteeing tenderness. The Sam & Erna sandwich, a mix of pulled pork and brisket, became a classic this year. The punchy sauces are made in-house from meat stock, but the meats don’t need the dressing to be delicious; they stand on their own. 

Kira Hoeg/4121 Main

Best new first date spot 

4121 Main

Address and Info

Bloomfield

Equal parts floral shop, coffee bar, and art gallery, this bright, relaxed new spot in Bloomfield embraces the right vibe for a first date. The high-quality coffee is sourced from Heart Roasters in Portland, OR, and the ambiance is made for talking, not hiding behind laptop screens. But if the first date doesn’t go well, there are plenty of opportunities for #latteart Instagrams to break the awkward silence. 

Courtesy of Alyssa Florentine

Best new taco

Täkō

Address and Info

Downtown

Täkō somehow achieves a surf shack vibe in the heart of the city’s Cultural District. The namesake is the Täkō taco -- for you sushi people, you’ll recognize this as grilled octopus. If that’s a little too adventurous for your palate, there are plenty of other margarita-friendly options, like Korean-style Waygu short rib, roasted mushroom, and grilled chicken. Definitely try the Yellow Jacket, a tequila and liquer drink made with lemon and charred yellow pepper. 

Adam Milliron/The Commoner

Best new brunch 

The Commoner

Address and Info

Downtown

There’s so much to love on The Commoner’s menu. Let’s start with the expansive DIY Bloody Mary bar with options for vodka, plus all the fixings -- pickled veggies, hot sauces, hard-boiled eggs, mini grilled cheese sandwiches, sausages, olives, and celery. Then, there’s the pub toast: a dense Irish soda bread French toast topped with chantilly cream and whiskey barrel-aged maple syrup. Talk about a decadent brunch.

Sign up here for our daily Pittsburgh email and be the first to get all the food/drink/fun in the Steel City.
 
Rossilynne Culgan is a Pittsburgh native who hopes her future home will look like the interior of 4121 Main, preferably including a Spirit Duette espresso machine. Follow her #HouseGoals: @rossilynne.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
1. Morcilla 3519 Butler St, Pittsburgh, PA (Lower Lawrenceville)

This Spanish small plates spot in Lawrenceville is seafood centric-- try the oysters with pickled grapes and mustard seed. Also great? The wide selection of affordable new world wines. The space is standing-room only, which is fine for snacking on pintos, or Basque-style tapas. There is a 2oz pour option for the wines, allowing you to sample a couple varieties before ordering a full glass.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
2. Spirit 242 51st St, Pittsburgh, PA 15201 (Central Lawrenceville)

Crispy, thin-crust, square-cut pizza meets Pennsylvania booze -- it's a love story to end all others. That's what happens every night at Spirit, a spot on the upper West corner of Allegheny Arsenal that tricks everyday passerby with its outer abandoned warehouse look. Those in the know, however, regularly flock here for the simple Slice Island pies and glass after glass after glass of craft beer, wine, and cocktails alongside some live indie music in '70s-prom kind of dance hall or out on the back patio.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
3. Voodoo Homestead 205 E 9th Ave, Homestead, PA

There’s something that feels so forbidden about drinking in a former police station and firehouse. VooDoo Brewery’s taproom features a great selection of craft beer, from lagers to IPAs with names like HooBoo IPA, Cowbell Oatmeal Stout, and the Voodoo Love Child Belgian Ale. There are long farm tables and small round high tops for for all sized groups. Grab a boardgames from the stack and stay a while (throwback to the Pre-App Stone Age).

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
4. Biergarten 620 William Penn Pl, Pittsburgh, PA 15219

Biergarten at the Hotel Monaco features an exhaustive list of European beer, like bottled German favorites the Spaten Optimator doppelbock, the Weihenstephaner hefeweizen, and the Spaten marzen, and Belgian Trappist ales and sours. German-inspired bar bites range from house-made currywurst and sauerbraten to giant pretzels and a full array of pickles. And if you think the highlight of the evening will be trying to pronounce all of this German after a few drinks, try your hand at any of Biergarten’s pub games, like Jenga, garden chess, and super-sized Connect Four, and see how long you can last.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
5. Grapperia 3801 Butler St Rear, Pittsburgh, PA 15201 (Central Lawrenceville)

Grapperia in Lawrenceville is extremely true to its name, as it focuses on grappa. Grappa is an Italian brandy made from the skin of grapes used in winemaking -- and it packs a punch. This Italian bar centers around the liqueur and also offers other Italian beverages, including amari, limoncello, and grappa cocktails like the LaVanda -- lavender-infused grappa, green pepper honey, and lemon juice.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
6. Bread and Salt 330 Pearl At, Pittsburgh, PA 15224 (Bloomfield)

Bread and Salt Bakery is already amassing long lines at its Bloomfield shop. Long, rectangular pizzas -- some are classic tomato-and-mozzarella rendition, others are tasty experiments with leeks and herbs -- sit on display in the bakery’s entryway. Customers can point to their choice and measure out how much they’d like. Yes, pizza is sold by the pound, and with the pizza’s airy dough and fresh ingredients, it’d be easy to gain several pounds here.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
7. SMOQ PITT BBQ 600 Brookline Blvd, Pittsburgh, PA 15226 (Brookline)

SMOQ PITT has some truly incredible barbecue. Owner and pitmaster Mitch Liebovich has been perfecting his brisket since childhood. He applies a sugar rub to the brisket, which is then cooked in a giant smoker over logs for 20 hours. The mac and cheese with gouda, monterey jack and sharp cheddar is also incredible.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
8. 4121 Main 4121 Main St, Pittsburgh, PA 15224

Nestled in a small 1920s house in the center of Pittsburgh, 4121 Main is an actual Pinterest board come to life. Part art gallery, part florist and part coffee shop, this rustic-chic space is host to craft coffee drinks, which they've sourced from Heart Coffee Roasters (all the way from Portland) and brewed with artful machines imported from Holland. All about aesthetic, this place for the visual folk, who'll enjoy the specifically curated art selections and floral arrangements dotting the walls and shelves.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
9. täkō 214 6th St, Pittsburgh, PA 15222

As the sign says out front, this Downtown street-fusion spot offers tacos, sandwiches, ceviche, cold beer and tequila. The täkō tacos really are deserving of the house name, featuring octopus, but the others are equally as delicious ranging from grilled pork shoulder to mushrooms to wagyu short rib. Don't forget about their drinks, which include inventive margaritas and the Neville Island Tea, which is a Pittsburgh take on the Long Island Iced Tea.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
10. The Commoner 458 Strawberry Way, Pittsburgh, PA 15219 (Central Business District)

Located in Downtown Pittsburgh, The Commoner is anything but common and it's one of the coolest joints in town. The menu offers tavern-style tastes, with meat as the main attraction, and be sure to nab dessert -- the Sticky Toffee Pudding, a warm date cake with ice cream, will be the best thing you may ever have in your mouth.

Clickbait