Food & Drink

The Best Pizza Slices in San Francisco

Published On 02/24/2016 Published On 02/24/2016

Pizza is an almost universally beloved food. Whether you’re a carnivore or a vegetarian, everyone makes a bee-line for the closest pie house -- especially come last call. But San Francisco has sometimes gotten a bad rap for its selection of slices.

But when it comes to pizza (and everything else, too) we’re not trying to be New York. Sure, we have a few New York-style pizza-by-the-slice joints, but we also boast some pizzerias that are specific to the City by the Bay. We’re talkin’ slices made at bread shops (and everyone knows SF has the best bread in the nation), square slices, sauceless slices, and more. While this list isn’t for the pizza traditionalist, if you’re open to slices in all shapes and sizes, we’ve got the scoop on the best pizzerias San Francisco has to offer.

Eloise Porter/Thrillist

Arinell

The Mission

It’s the gold standard for traditional, New York-style pizza, and has earned a seal of approval from just about everyone. This thin and crispy slice is just what the doctor ordered, day or night (no, it’s not just drunk food, although this spot does stay open late). Arinell’s also has those pillowy Sicilian-slices for those into a square pie. You’re gonna get only the classic toppings here, and we’re just fine with that. Mmm, pepperoni.

Courtesy of Pi Bar

Pi Bar

The Mission

Come in for the “π r²” deal every day from 3:14-6:28pm, where a slice of cheese pie and beer of the day is only $7.22 (get it?). These thin-crust slices are San Francisco’s version of New York-style, meaning you can get slices topped with locally sourced meats and vegetables. Plus, they have a great selection of local craft brews like Russian River and Allagash.

Courtesy of Tony's

Tony’s Slice House

North Beach & SoMa

Tony’s is on literally every pizza “best of” list, and for good reason: Tony Gemignani is a pizza god. His menu is comprised of ten different styles of pizza (we didn’t even know there were that many). As far as his slice house next door (and in the SoMa), you’ll get to pick from New York slices, Grandma-style, and Sicilian, so you can make every pizza-lover happy.

The Mill

The Mill

NoPa

Ah, San Francisco bread... it’s the stuff dreams are made of. So it’s no wonder that Josey Baker’s lusted-after bread recipe lends itself perfectly to spectacular pizza dough. Every Monday night from 6-9pm, The Mill throws a BYOB pizza party, where you’ll get a chewy, salty sourdough crust topped with everything from fava green pesto to kimchi. Don’t forget to bring a six-pack.

Arizmendi

Arizmendi

The Mission (& other locations)

Arizmendi is a worker-owned co-op specializing in pastries, breads, and gourmet pizza. Every day, you’ll get a different thin-crust sourdough pizza, with seasonal, organic vegetable toppings like Kalamata olives, arugula, feta cheese, marinated artichoke hearts, and more. These slices are quintessentially San Francisco, with unusual, fresh toppings on dough with substance and character.

The Cheese Board Collective

The Cheese Board Collective

Berkeley

The only rule at Cheese Board Collective, the oldest food collective in Northern California, is that all pies must use two kinds of cheeses. We are big fans of this rule. Aside from that, pies vary daily from out-of-the-ordinary flavors. Check out a couple of these super complex combinations: roasted potato, yam, caramelized onion, French brie, truffled Moliterno Pecorino cheese, and chives; baby swiss chard, dino kale, leek, mozzarella, Comté cheese, garlic olive oil, orange and lemon zest, and parsley. They’re a mouthful -- and not for the timid palate.

Golden Boy Pizza

Golden Boy

North Beach

These thick-crust, square-slice, Sicilian-style pies have been a San Francisco favorite since 1978. They’re perfect after a night spent traipsing around North Beach, and are a sure-fire hangover remedy. The Golden Boy favorite? Clam and garlic. Just trust us...

Courtesy of Presidio Pizza Company

Presidio Pizza Company

Lower Pac Heights

The Brooklyn-born owner and chef of Presidio Pizza Company, Frank Bumbalo, serves up three kinds of pies at his joint -- thin-crust New York-style, Sicilian-style thick focaccia, and Grandma-style, which is both square and thin. This is the kind of place you could sit down with family or a date and munch classic pies covered in interesting toppings. We like Frankie's, which comes with sausage, rapini, garlic, onions, cherry peppers, and Grande mozzarella.

Patxis

Patxi's (lunch special) 

Hayes Valley (& other locations)

Deep-dish fans will be thrilled to know that Patxi's offers their massive pies by the slice. They do deep dish right, and slice seekers can come in seven days a week from 11am-4pm for the lunch special -- a slice of deep dish or thin-crust with salad and a soda will set you back $9.99 (and trust us, one slice of deep dish is plenty mid-day). Slices change daily, but include meat and veggie toppings. 

Flickr/torbakhopper

Oz Pizza

The Castro

Oz is your go-to, late-night pit stop. This Castro haunt attracts endless crowds come last call, and for good reason. They offer wacky flavor combinations like mac ‘n' cheese pizza with bacon, hot dogs with jalapeño and pickles, or chicken wings with ranch and onion rings. While this kind of insanity usually means you’ve really gotta tie one on before heading into Oz; don’t worry, they have regular toppings, too. Pro tip: grab a piece of chocolate-covered bacon for dessert.

Zachary’s Chicago Pizza

Zachary’s Chicago Pizza

Oakland & Berkeley

Although Zachary’s specializes in stuffed pizza (that’s two layers), you can stop by every weekday for their equally delicious thin slices. These buttery-crust pies are dusted with cornmeal, which adds some crunch and texture. You’ll get a slice, a side Caesar salad, and a soda for $9.25 from 11am to 4pm. Just make sure you order a stuffed pizza to go for dinner (trust us, it’s brilliant). 

The Pizza Shop

Pizza Shop

The Mission

A New York-style slice in the Mission that rivals Arinell’s? Yeah, we said it. The Pizza Shop sticks to classic combos like mushroom olive, tomato garlic, and pepperoni mushroom. These thin, greasy slices are the perfect midnight snack and will satisfy even the snobbiest pizza fiends. Salty, cheesy, and perfectly dotted with toppings, is one of our favorite go-tos.

Za Pizza

Za Pizza

Russian Hill

This small neighborhood joint churns out reliable slices that are thin and crispy, with a bubbly crust covered in gooey cheese. There’s a rotating board of slice options, with fresh California toppings like artichoke hearts, spinach, and mushrooms, as well as sweet Italian sausage. The walls are covered with customers’ drawings, and you’re welcome to generate a piece of artwork while you wait (or snack on your ‘za).

Goat Hill Pizza

Goat Hill Pizza

Potrero Hill (& other locations)

We’re in San Francisco, so of course we’re excited about another sourdough crust spot. This one is thin, crispy, studded with cornmeal, and has been feeding the neighborhood since 1975. This is a slice we could eat day or night, with plentiful, fresh toppings like whole garlic cloves, sausage and linguiça, bright green pesto, and massive black olives.

Escape From New York

Escape From New York

Haight (& other locations)

Located all over our fair 7x7, Escape From New York is the perfect antidote for a wild night out or simply a quick midday stop for a reliable slice of pie. They’re known for the potato, pesto, and garlic -- a thin slice bursting with flavor. All the locations stay open late, so this is a perfect pre- or post-drinking pitstop.

Courtesy of Pizzeria Avellino

Pizzeria Avellino

Marina/Presidio

Pizzeria Avellino comes from an Arinell’s veteran, so you know you’ll get that extra thin, NY-style slice here. You won’t see any of those fancy California toppings at this joint, so come for classics like cheese, sausage, and mushrooms. 

Sign up here for our daily San Francisco email and be the first to get all the food/drink/fun SF has to offer.

Eloise Porter is a Thrillist contributor and equal-opportunity pizza lover (except for vegan pies). She expects some seriously angry comments about how SF doesn’t have good slices, so do your worst.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
1. Arinell Pizza 509 Valencia St, San Francisco, CA 94110 (The Mission)

This late-night Mission 'za slinger earns a spot on Thrillist's Favorite 5 solely because they filmed an adult movie there in August. No, seriously.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
2. Pi Bar 1432 Valencia St, San Francisco, CA 94110 (The Mission)

This Mission bar and restaurant wins for its craft brews and awesome pizza. Available by the slice or pie, the thin-crust pizzas are topped with meat and veggie add-ons of your choice. The Death by Mushroom pizza, covered with a mushroom sauce that's made with Moonlight Death & Taxes beer, is a signature, as are the house-made rainbow cookies. Of course, a meal at Pi Bar isn't complete without a beer from the daily beer board.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
3. Slice House by Tony Gemignani 680 2nd St, San Francisco, CA 94107 (Soma)

Tony Gemignani (gold medal winner of the Food Network's Pizza Champions Challenge!) brings Italian-style pizza to his 2nd Street pizzeria, featuring two roomy floors in which to experience his creations by the slice (as the name would suggest) or by the whole pie. The famed Cal Italia is an award-winning treat featuring sweet fig preserves, prosciutto, and a balsamic reduction.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
4. The Mill 736 Divisadero St, San Francisco, CA 94117 (Alamo Square)

Baking incredible fresh bread daily (made with flour from from their German mill) this partnership between the Barrel guys and Josey Baker Bread is a constant go-to for a bite, coffee, and some quiet contemplation. As you'd expect from a place that has a serious way with dough, the BYOB Monday pizza nights and Wednesday grilled cheese and soup nights are not to be missed.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
5. Arizmendi Bakery 1331 9th Ave, San Francisco, CA 94122 (Inner Sunset)

This pizzeria/bakery (?) has delicious 'za, baked treats, and a general attitude towards carb-loaded goodness.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
6. Cheese Board Pizza 1504 Shattuck Ave, Berkeley, CA 94709 (Berkeley)

The culinary offshoot of the worker-owned Cheese Board Collective, this three-in-one pizzeria, bakery, and cheese counter has been melting Berkeley tastebuds since 1985. There's only type of veggie pizza (never meat) and one type of salad per day, and each is available until they sell out. The Cheese Board is well-known to have some of the best pizza around, so there's usually a wait (especially at peak lunch and dinner hours), but live music from local artists keeps you entertained. If you don't like the element of surprise, the website lists the pizzas for the week ahead, but truth be told, they're all insanely good.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
7. Golden Boy Pizza 542 Green St, San Francisco, CA 94133 (North Beach)

Golden Boy Pizza has been slinging grab-and-go slices since 1978. Their claim to fame is the Garlic Clam Pizza, and most fully loaded slices can be had for the price of $4.25. For those who like thicker dough and corner crusts, Golden Boy offers Sicilian slices. If you feel like sticking around to enjoy your pizza there, you'll find beer and wine on tap to pare with it.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
8. Presidio Pizza Company 1862 Divisadero St, San Francisco, CA 94115 (The Presidio)

A sporty yet family-friendly pizza restaurant that balances their grown up, reclaimed-wood style with an obvious sense of humor about their pies. Send the kids to Pizza Camp, enjoy a Nutella dessert pie, or overload on toppings. It isn't serious, it's just seriously good.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
9. Patxi's Chicago Pizza 4042 24th St, San Francisco, CA 94114 (Noe Valley)

Noe Valley deep-dish-ery Patxi's is piloting a new run of thin-crust specials, including the Picante (w/ Zoe’s spicy salami, red pepper cured hot coppa, and chopped pepperoncini) and the Tre Porcellini, which combines all natural pepperoni, garlic-fennel sausage, and EVEN MORE Zoe’s spicy salami.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
10. Oz Pizza 508 Castro Street, San Francisco, CA 94114 (The Castro)

A late-nite Casto pizza joint slinging prideful pies, full-bodied brews, and chocolate bacon strips. Their varieties include a boneless wing, onion ring, and cool ranch topped monster known as the Lord of the Wings, and a hot dog, bacon, pickle, and jalapeno style they call "Puppy Chulo."

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
11. Zachary's Chicago Pizza 1853 Solano Ave, Berkeley, CA 94707 (Berkeley)

This Italian joint is serving up deep dish pizza like no other Bay area purveyor. Grab a slice, or four, and enjoy it overlooking the Berkeley hills.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
12. The Pizza Shop 3104 24th St, San Francisco, CA 94110 (The Mission)

Located in the Mission, these guys serve up steaming hot 'za in pie or slice form.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
13. Za Pizza 1919 Hyde St, San Francisco, CA 94109 (Russian Hill)

It's thin crust, but it doesn't skimp on the toppings. Flavor where flavor is due, this spot piles them on unapologetically. The walls are covered in fan art, which should be taken as a rightful indication of how beloved their pies are.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
14. Goat Hill Pizza 300 Connecticut St, San Francisco, CA 94107 (Potrero Hill)

Sourdough crust, yo. Since 1975. You want to go on Monday because that's "Neighborhood Night" -- aka all-you-can-eat pizza night. For $12.95 you can go to town on pizza and salad from 4-10pm. Even better? This isn't some crappy buffet where the pizza is stale and cold. Servers bring the latest pies out of the oven to walk around the restaurant, so you can grab a slice while it's still piping hot. The slices are slimmer than usual, which means you get to try more kinds. It's totally genius.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
15. Escape From New York Pizza 1737 Haight St, San Francisco, CA 94117 (Upper Haight)

Escape from New York in the Haight is the perfect cure to any bad hangover, or fun night out. Their thin crusts are delicious, as are their juicy tomato sauces that coat said crust.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
16. Pizzeria Avellino 2769 Lombard St, San Francisco, CA 94123 (The Marina)

In the old Curbside space, Avellino's tiny and plenty nice (black two tops, spherical hanging lamps, etc), and serves both NY style pizza by the slice/pie, and whole 'zas of rustic Napoletana with pesto/tomato sauce done up with topping combos ranging from classic pairings to more experimental combos.

Clickbait