Food & Drink

The best restaurants in central Ontario... that aren't in Toronto

Published On 05/28/2014 Published On 05/28/2014

Despite the evidence presented by Rob Ford’s pants tailor, Toronto does not have ALL the great restaurants in Central Ontario -- in fact there are a ton of amazing eateries just a (really big) stone's throw away from our hallowed metropolis. Here's where to eat when you're out of town...

The Craftsman Restaurant

The Craftsman Restaurant
Bancroft
This place has been around since 1955, and the key to that longevity is found, believe it or not, in the great food. They’ve got special features every night, such as Cajun-style blackened catfish, maple stuffed roast pork, and grilled rainbow trout, to name a few -- plus there's a traditional roast beef dinner every Sunday, which sounds just about right for a town of 4,000 people.

Memphis Fire Barbeque Company

Memphis Fire Barbeque Company
Winona
Breakfast, lunch, and dinner are all on the menu here and the Sneaky Cheeseburger has developed a loyal fan following. You get a patty made from fresh ground beef from local farms, dressed with ranch, lettuce, tomatoes, dill, and caramelized onions and topped with a smoked cheddar spread... and while you can get a single, you need to get the triple.

Frijoles Fresh Mex Burritos

Frijoles Fresh Mex Burritos
Niagara Falls
You’ll find all the classic Mex eats here -- tacos, burritos, quesadillas -- without any of the unnecessary frills, but what you want  is the burrito, served with homemade guac, pico de gallo salsa, toms, sweet corn, fresh cheese, romaine, crisp cabbage, jalapeños, plus chicken, beef, and pork. And the kicker? There are eight of the house-made sauces to go with it.

Era 67 Restaurant & Lounge

Era 67 Restaurant & Lounge
Orilla
The steaks here are cut in-house daily and easily stack up against anything any big city has to offer, especially their 14oz AAA Angus Reserve Alberta Beef Ribeye monster. Feel like something different? Try some hand-made pasta stuffed with Era 67 homemade wild mushroom duxelle and a chardonnay reduction, shallots, fresh thyme, Woolwich goat’s cheese and Balderson aged cheddar tossed with a roasted garlic cream sauce and topped with wilted baby arugula and duo of grape tomatoes in maple marinara. Yep.

That Little Place By The Lights

That Little Place By The Lights
Huntsville
A fairly sizable family runs this amazingly named Italian eatery, where everything actually does taste homemade. Try the linguine puttanesca (black & green olives, capers, garlic, hot peppers, and anchovies in tomato sauce), or their meat-loaded Mamma Anna’s pizza, w/ Italian sausage, salami, ham, and bacon.

Il Buco Ristorante
Barrie
This gem has been serving up Old World Italian eats for more than six years, and pairing them with wines from their extensive and pretty impressive list -- favorites include the already-boozy penne al la vodka, w/ bacon & Reggiano cheese.

Big Chris BBQ Smokehouse

Big Chris BBQ Smokehouse
Barrie
Sure, there are plenty of places that'll furnish your arteries with a full rack of smoked baby back pork ribs or, even an equivalent Dirty Burger with pulled pork -- but there's only one place that'll give you the Ultimate Dirty Burger Challenge. It comes with SIX 8oz patties, each topped with bacon and cheese, plus 2lbs of pulled pork, and some poutine for good measure. The current record holder finished it in 50 minutes and 59 seconds. Can you do better?

Lion City Restaurant
Mississauga
An institution in Mississauga for almost 20 years, Lion City serves authentic Sing-Malay food, cooked up by chef and owner Lilian Ow. Try the beef rendang curry and the rojak, a green mango, pineapple, and cucumber salad that’s tossed with dried jellyfish, peanuts, and fermented shrimp paste. It’ll push you outside of your comfort zone and it’s so, so worth it.

Hot Belly Mama's

Hot Belly Mama's
Peterborough
The music, food, and arts of New orleans... in Peterborough. Hot Belly Mama's is a local standby and for good reason, the food is fantastic and the atmosphere is cordial and relaxed. We recommend the Jamaican honey mustard chicken, which comes roasted in-house made honey mustard marinade, accented with curry, allspice, and Red Fife Wheat Ale, all served w/ fresh mango chutney.

Soulyve Caribbean Kitchen

Soulyve Caribbean Kitchen
Orangeville
Proudly known as Orangeville's premier Caribbean restaurant (!), you’re going to want to try their trademark dish, the Reggae Wrap (for $10 you get your choice of jerk chicken, jerk pork, sweet BBQ chicken, vegetable, or cornmeal catfish), or some of the traditional dishes, like goat curry, beef patties, and jerk chicken.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
1. The Craftsman Restaurant 27965 Hwy 28 South at Paudash, Bancroft, K0L 1C0

This Bancroft eatery has been around since 1955 and they've never lost their traditional old-school charm, with a pleasant dining room complete with a fireplace and special menu items every night like Cajun-style blackened catfish, maple-stuffed roast pork, and grilled rainbow trout.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
2. Memphis Fire Barbeque Company 1091 King's Highway #8, Winona, L8E 1L6

Breakfast, lunch and dinner are all on the menu here and the Sneaky Cheeseburger has developed a loyal fan following, unsurprisingly, considering it consists of fresh ground beef from local farms, dressed with ranch, lettuce, tomatoes, dill, and caramelized onions, and it's topped with a smoked cheddar spread.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
3. Frijoles Fresh Mex Burritos 3465 Portage Rd, Niagara Falls, L2J 2K5

You’ll find classic Mexican eats at this tasty Niagara Falls spot, including tacos, burritos, and quesadillas -- and without any of the unnecessary frills. Just. Good. Mexican. Food.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
4. Era 67 Restaurant & Lounge 64 Mississaga St W, Orillia, L3V 3A8

This Orilla haunt is all about high-quality, fresh, local food. Executive Chef Ian Thompson insists on it, so that dishes like the 14oz AAA Angus Reserve Alberta Beef Ribeye, and the Wild Mushroom Duxelle Goats Cheese and Aged Cheddar Ravioli are as fresh as possible.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
5. That Little Place By The Lights 76 Main St, Huntsville, P1H 2B8

This tiny Italian Huntsville establishment is family-run and everything they serve is and tastes homemade. Pro tip: try the Linguine Puttanesca with black and green olives, capers, garlic, hot peppers, and anchovies in tomato sauce.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
6. ll Buco Ristorante 31 Dunlop St E, Barrie, L4M 1A3

This Barrie gem serves up Old World Italian fare, like their highly lauded Veal Contadina, which is veal scaloppini sautéed in a roasted garlic jus with zucchini, mushrooms, and red peppers. And don't forget to sample some wine from their extensive list.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
7. Big Chris BBQ Smokehouse 110 Anne St S, Barrie, L4N 2E3

This is the perfect place to go to watch some sports, drink some beer and eat artery-choking deliciousness in a laid-back setting. And when we say artery-choking, we're referring to the Ultimate Dirty Burger Challenge, which comes with SIX 8oz patties, each topped with bacon and cheese, and there’s also two 2lbs of pulled pork piled in there, and some poutine for good measure.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
8. Lion City Restaurant 1177 Central Parkway W, Mississauga, L5C 4P3

This Mississauga institution serves authentic Sing-Malay food, cooked up by chef and owner Lilian Ow. Try the beef rendang curry and the rojak, a green mango, pineapple, and cucumber salad that’s tossed with dried jellyfish, peanuts, and fermented shrimp paste. It’ll push you outside your comfort zone and it’s so, so worth it.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
9. Hot Belly Mama's 380 George St N, Peterborough, K9H 3R3

This Peterborough resto brings all the fun (music, flavors, and style) of New Orleans to Ontario with its pleasant and relaxed atmosphere and extensive menu.

Previous Venue Next Venue Venue Description
10. Soulyve Caribbean Kitchen 19 Mill St, Orangeville, L9W 2M3

You can dine in or eat out at this Orangeville Caribbean spot, which doles out classic dishes like jerk chicken, jerk pork, sweet BBQ chicken, or cornmeal catfish. You won't be disappointed.

Clickbait