Trashy Reality TV Shows That Are Actually Good
In 1992, MTV's The Real World started a slow-moving revolution that turned into an all-out blitz when Survivor premiered eight years later: Look at all these regular people starting drama! They are not polite at all! Watching unscripted lives unfold may have felt dirty early on, but no one could stop watching. As cable channels multiplied, the allure of producing cheaper shows that could air on endless loops meant that you didn't have to channel surf long before stumbling on one of them.
Most of these shows are actual trash, leaving you feeling empty and listless on your couch. But a rare few have mastered the art of trashy reality TV, which is no easy feat. "Trashy," in this case, is a term of endearment, a qualifier for shows that capture the raw human emotion that makes compelling viewing, without demanding all your brainpower to decipher plot, motivation, or fan theories. These shows, all of which are currently airing, have elevated trash to an art, and will satisfy you in the best-worst way possible.
The Bachelor/The Bachelorette (ABC)There are a few different ways to watch ABC's The Bachelor/Bachelorette, the reality dating and relationship show that's been inflicting itself on us for more than 16 years. Now that The Bachelor, the male-fronted half of the duo, is in its 23rd season, it's hit its stride, expertly engineering dramas, betrayals, and shocking moments that look really exciting in the weekly commercials and then end up being pretty mundane when you see them in the actual episode. For some deranged individuals, The Bach' is a show about finding love and risking it all and opening up and lots of other vague things the writers found inside a plateful of fortune cookies. For the rest of us, it's a brilliantly designed character study, every episode cajoled and needled and edited into narratives that run the gamut from villain origin stories (usually followed by riveting downfalls) to resurfaced beauty pageant feuds to dramatic backstory reveals to marriage proposals that end up in dismal failure. ABC also knows that the one thing we really want is the crying.
Bar Rescue (Paramount Network)Do you embrace excuses, or do you embrace solutions? It's one of the many binary questions/screamed accusations host and Official Bar Rescuer Jon Taffer asks of flailing bar and restaurant owners, who are invariably the kinds of people who EMBRACE EXCUSES, but over the course of a week learn how to embrace solutions. Taffer is the sort of person whose success is measurable as a series of sales and consumer data points; his renovations basically turn disgusting health hazards into a TGI Fridays-like "homage" to some actual history, like remaking a Louisiana bar based on a "Second Line concept" which symbolizes "fun."
So what makes Bar Rescue such an enjoyable watch? Like all great reality television, it's a fascinating window into the soul of mainstream America. It's the purified id of American consumer capitalism, existing in a world where a seat at the bar is quantifiable as a dollar amount per year, and attracting "desirable" customers (i.e. not poor people) is the ultimate goal. The opening credits remind viewers that Taffer bases his decisions on "bar science," which usually involves scientifically demanding an owner fire an employee and putting a hapless staff through a "stress test" when the bar is overrun with people until Taffer screams another of his catchphrases above the havoc: "SHUT IT DOWN!" Don't worry. Most of the bars find their way out of the muck, but the people are forever changed. It's why Taffer has sincerely said, "It almost could be called People Rescue, you know?"
Catfish: The TV Show (MTV)Everybody’s just looking for love! Many of us are doing online, which has increasingly become the norm -- but some of us are going beyond just swiping right and instead chatting for years on end with relative strangers who live across the country and may or may not be who they say they are. On Catfish, hosts Nev Schulman and Max Joseph intend to finally get those kinds of couples to meet IRL, and debunk whether the particularly hesitant, sketchy one who refuses to video chat is a "catfish," or luring their partner in with a fake profile and lying about their identity. (They usually are. I mean, come on.) The concept originated from a 2010 documentary made by Nev, also called Catfish, when he was caught up in an online relationship in the early days of Facebook. With that experience, he and Max know what they're doing (basically just reverse image and phone number searches), and they tend to get super paternal when their investigation heats up. If you can believe it, the show is still on in 2020, and catfish are still swimming around even in the extremely online social media dating pool, but part of what makes the show so entertaining is how confounding some of these relationships are. Of course, there are some success stories, and most catfish have deep-rooted insecurities, but each episode is its own wild journey. One guy thought he was dating Katy Perry; another was duped by his own cousin! The internet: It's wild.
The Circle (Netflix)The Circle, another imported British original that's become our latest Netflix obsession, feels like the logical culmination of reality shows in 2020. Taking elements of many other reality shows this list -- Big Brother with a dollop of Love Island and a sprinkle of Terrace House -- and incorporating it into a social media-based game, The Circle is also a beast of its own, an experiment in isolation: the players, who are likely living a few doors away from each other in made-for-Instagram apartments, can only interact with other through the show-specific, voice-activated social media app, the titular Circle, and have to rank each other every day based on photos posted, bonds formed in DMs, hunches on who's catfishing and who isn't, and who's likeable enough, but not too likeable, to pad you from being blocked. There's some flirting, but it's mostly people just asking each other how their day is going and forming friendly alliances with each other, with a few occasional challenges made to procure the most likes on posts from other players. It sounds maybe boring -- how could people talking at a screen obsessing over their feeds be entertaining? -- but trust us, you won't regret flipping on The Circle.
Celebrity Big Brother (CBS)Usually by the time celebrities show up on a reality franchise, the ratings have dipped and the premise is doomed. Just look at The Apprentice, Marriage Boot Camp, or the entire run of I’m a Celebrity Get Me Out of Here. That may be why expectations for the first season of Celebrity Big Brother were about as low as the status of the "celebrities" picked to occupy a house for three weeks and vote each other out. However, what we got in the first season of the show was a gem that not only managed to entertain but, with the inclusion of recent White House evictee Omarosa Manigault-Newman, break actual news. The result was one of the best seasons of the show ever, featuring fast-and-furious game play, some deep political discussions, an avoidance of the "showmances" that poison the regular game, and a group of people who know how to deliver a sound bite to camera. Adding celebrities didn’t doom the formula: It elevated it to a brand-new level. Unfortunately, the latest version of the show already seems to be wearing thin, especially with a guy who had a coffee at the Trump White House before regurgitating it all over the media during his 10-day run as Director of Communications already out of the house. The Mooch is dead; long live The Mooch.
Ghost Adventures (Travel Channel)Cable is littered with reality shows where fearless hosts travel to haunted locations, lock themselves inside, and use suspect-looking equipment to scare the crap out of you. Even in the formulaic world of television, these shows rarely deviate from a set pattern: front-load the episode with some exposition and historical background, spend time walking around the area, and then wait for night to fall and freak out about anything that happens. The best of these shows is Ghost Adventures, which has aired for a decade on the Travel Channel, and the reason it's so good can be summed up in two words: Zak Bagans. The hair-gel-loving host is like a cross between Pauly D from Jersey Shore and Fox Mulder from The X-Files. His ability to sell the creepiness of every abandoned hospital, closed hotel, and long-shuttered prison while wearing garish Ed Hardy-esque shirts cannot be undersold. He's like the Guy Fieri of the paranormal.
Jersey Shore (MTV)Jersey Shore was the most important sociological experiment of our time. We got an insiders view to a cage (the shore house) filled with a bunch of animals (the "guidos") and got to dissect all of their odd habits and traditions as they drank, hooked up, and fist-pumped their way from obscurity into superstardom. The show was a way for all of us to vicariously relive the follies of our youth -- messing around with your friends, cheating on a boyfriend, wearing some very ill-advised corsets in the name of fashion -- without any of the hangovers. MTV relaunched the show as Jersey Shore Family Vacation in spring 2018 and, instead of focusing on youth, it became a treatise on growing up and what it means to be "family." Both Snooki and J-Wow are mothers. Pauly D is now the successful DJ Pauly D. The Situation has faced financial ruin. Sammi and Ronnie have officially, for the final time, broken up. Instead of This Is Our Youth, the reboot is more The Big Chill, but with at least one person shouting, "Cabs are here!"
Love Island (ITV2; CBS)Love Island is true organized chaos, a whirlwind of six traditionally hot people made to live in a beautiful villa for a summer, do insane challenges that are often handed down via text message and involve kissing, and have sex under blankets in the same room everyone sleeps in. Yes, the goal of the show is to make a partner out of a stranger, and if you're the last couple standing, you could win a shit ton of money (that is, if you both make the choice to share the earnings in the finale). It first started in the UK in 2015 and spread from there, picking up tons of fans from abroad when it started streaming on Hulu. Now, there are versions in America (that's admittedly still finding its footing and is way less horny than its very R-rated British cousin), Germany, Denmark, Norway, Finland, and Sweden -- that's how much people lap up the concept of people wearing bathing suits drinking out of branded water bottles coupling up and using localized slang (ie. banter, chat, craic, etc. in the UK). There's something about Love Island, whichever its nationality, that is utterly bingeable, a combination of the right personalities, its aesthetic that looks straight out of a PB Teen but designed for Instagram, and the constant exchange of gossip between housemates. Tragically, the original UK host Caroline Flack recently committed suicide, leading to a public outcry for the show to take the mental health of its entire cast more seriously, which, yes -- apparently the stars are often brutally harassed online. Still, the series an important cultural import that ushered in a new wave of reality TV.
The Masked Singer (Fox)Concept: A bunch of people with the ability to sing who are various states of famous compete in an over-the-top competition where the judges have no idea who they are -- because their entire bodies are encased in elaborate costumes complete with what look like the heaviest masks ever worn on TV. That's the premise of Fox's reality singing competition. It's based on South Korea's similarly formatted King of Mask Singer, which has been ongoing since 2015; here in the States, it premiered only last year, but it's already in its third season -- and it's insanely addictive. Is it the weird costumes? The campy performances? The song choices? The mystery of it all? Every week, pairs of the 10 contestants face off, and the loser of each, based on audience and judges' votes, is up for elimination. After they're booted from the show, the contestants take off their masks and reveal their identity -- but we're also given clue packages every episode to guess who might be behind the mask. If guessing who a bunch of people running around looking like Power Rangers villains is your bag, The Masked Singer might just be the costumed singing reality competition show for you.
Naked and Afraid (Discovery Channel)The name is almost too trashy, so straightforward that it risks repelling viewers. Don't let it dissuade you, though it is accurate: A nude man and woman, strangers to each other, must survive in an unforgiving environment for 21 days, armed only with a firestarter and one pre-selected tool each. The brilliance of Naked and Afraid is that it somehow manages to achieve, in most episodes, an arc from misogyny to feminism. It starts with the Primitive Survival Rating, or PSR, which is given to each naked, scared person ahead of their journey. The criteria for this rating is opaque and based on nothing resembling fact, but it's on a scale of 10, and in earlier seasons was broken down into three categories, including "mental," with adjectives like "ingenious" factoring into PSRs that might be, say, 6.3. The men usually receive higher initial PSRs, but they're almost always the the first to crack physically and mentally, while the women are forced to find food, keep the fire going, and provide emotional support... which they do, saving the team from bowing out early. Naked and Afraid has moved away from this model a bit in more recent seasons, which in the big picture is for the best, but it's still one of the most consistently entertaining shows you can binge episode after episode for hours on end.
(Discovery Communications is an investor in Group Nine Media, Thrillist's parent company.)