Nightmare Next Door
American Horror Story's format draws from 30-plus years of true-crime documentary series, and the sensationalized reenactments of the genre are easy to parody. Investigation Discovery is the heir to the the talking-head murder-story throne. With shows like Disappeared, Deadly Woman, Unusual Suspects, Obsession: Dark Desires, and a pillar, Nightmare Next Door, which uncovers the "evil that can lurk just under the surface or in the heart of any tight-knit small-town community," ID's programming indulges the most morbid of curiosities.
Where to watch: Stream all of ID's shows on Hulu