Basically, the lawsuit is claiming the tableau of Baphomet with a male and female child standing on either side -- "Baphomet with Children" -- to be their commissioned depiction of the deity, and theirs only, and for Netflix to have used it in their TV show was a violation of their intellectual property. Not only that, the Satanic Temple claims that to use this particular depiction of Baphomet as the centerpiece of a school that houses all the show's evil characters would then, by association, characterize the actual real-life Satanic Temple as an evil organization when their mission, according to the court filing, is "to encourage benevolence and empathy among people rejecting tryannical authority, advocating practical and common-sense justice, and undertaking noble pursuits guided by individual will." So the lawsuit... kind of makes a lot of sense?
Before TST officially sued Sabrina, the Church of Satan -- again, no affiliation with the Satanic Temple -- independently weighed in on the many recent uses of Satanism as "quick and easy villainy" in fiction. According to High Priest Peter H. Gilmore, the devil worshipers you see in pop culture aren't the same thing as Satanists, who are very real, and don't actually dabble in witchcraft or demon summoning that often. (The Sabrina style of witchcraft is a far cry from today's practitioners of neo-paganism -- again, a very real thing.)
"While the demographics suggest that the viewership of [American Horror Story, which also had a Satanism storyline this season] and Sabrina likely won't confuse these mockeries of Satanism with our legally recognized iconoclastic religion, I wouldn't be surprised if less sophisticated viewers might take these as somehow being accurate and thereby feel they need to direct hostility towards actual Satanists who are 'out' to society," he worries. Satan is so hot right now, and yet every show that features the devil is steeped in the outdated "Satanic Panic" of the '80s and '90s, he argues.
Sabrina's witches worship Satan, yes, but the show still clearly has a very campy, over-the-top version of witchcraft that happens to include things like astral projection and festive cannibalism. Casual viewers probably know that a show like Sabrina is not really a factual portrayal of the occult, but maybe it's time for more responsible depictions of Satanic imagery in our media. Sabrina Season 2, take notes.