The Upside Down

What the Post-Credits Scene in 'Stranger Things' Means for Season 4

stranger things hopper
Netflix

This story contains spoilers about the end of Stranger Things 3. Beware! 

Stranger Things has faked its audiences out before. At the end of season one, the mysterious, super-powered girl known as Eleven (Millie Bobby Brown) disappears in the dust of the Demogorgon. The only sign of her left: the Eggo waffles Hopper leaves in a snow-covered box in hopes of her return. Of course, no one really thought Eleven was gone for good, and sure enough, she was back when the show returned for its second installment.

The end of Stranger Things' third batch of episodes leaves viewers in a similar spot. Is David Harbour's Sheriff Hopper, adoptive father to El, killed in the explosion that put an end to the Russian Upside Down experiments that created more problems for Hawkins? Or does he somehow manage to survive? For a while, it certainly seems like the former, but then a sneaky post-credits scene comes along and redefines what we thought we saw.

Hopper's evolution from gruff law enforcement official with a tortured past to offbeat father figure takes a turn this year. The caring dad -- who many also found to be "daddy" -- is fully flustered with the prospect of raising a hormonal teenager. He's angry that Mike (Finn Wolfhard) and Eleven are having makeout sessions in his home, and essentially breaks them up. Meanwhile, he himself is pissed that Joyce (Winona Ryder) seems to be uninterested in smooching up on him. That's all to say he spends a lot of time yelling at women who have already had a lifetime's worth of trauma, all because he doesn't like who they are or aren't kissing. It's not a good look. 

Toward the end of the season, though, creators The Duffer Brothers transform Hopper into an action star who has no problem with brutal violence -- whether that means pummeling a shady mayor or mowing down some Russian guards with a machine gun. So, by the time his tragic end arrives, he's not quite the sympathetic hero he used to be. (At least to my mind. You're mileage may vary.) 

hopper
RIP? | Netflix

Just as Hopper and Joyce are about to simultaneously turn the keys that will kill the machine that Russian spies have been using to let the body-snatching mind flayers into small town Indiana, the Terminator-like lackey who has been tracking our protagonists appears. He and Hopper do battle, putting them on the platform right next to what is set to go kablooey. By the time Hopper kills his foe, it's too late for him to reach safety, Joyce must switch the device off. When she does the room is obliterated, and when she looks back for Hopper, he's gone. 

The conclusion of the season finds the Byers, now with El as part of their family, in mourning as they prepare to finally get the hell out of Hawkins. As they pack, Joyce finds a note from Hopper, the emotional speech he was going to make to El. It's a touching coda to his story, and yet something doesn't feel as final as maybe it should be. 

Cue the mid-credits sequence. In a Russian facility of sorts a guard calls for a prisoner. "Not the American," he says, and, lo, a random poor soul is fed to a Demogorgon. The surprise of the sequence is the reappearance of the season one bad guy, but the "American" comment is more of a clue as to what's to come. Who is "the American?"

The most likely answer? Hopper. Because, come to think of it, we never actually saw him turn to goo, the way some soldiers did. Maybe he got sucked into the Upside Down when the gate closed and the Russians fished him out of it? Or maybe someone grabbed him in the process of escape? Compare Hopper's death to that of Billy (Dacre Montgomery), who gets impaled in multiple ways by the Mind Flayer: One is pretty clearcut, the other is, well, not. 

Harbour could very well return, especially given that Stranger Things often takes its time between seasons. A fourth season has been teased and is essentially a given even, though it hasn't been officially announced by Netflix. Harbour's currently in the middle of filming Marvel's Black Widow movie, but otherwise, his slate is free. (Alas, it seems like a Hellboy sequel is unlikely.) 

Still, there's something a little disappointing about Hopper's likely return. It undercuts the effective moments of sorrow that made up the end of the season. How are characters supposed to grow if their tragedy is just one big fake-out to appeal to fans? 

Sign up here for our daily Thrillist email, get Streamail for more entertainment, and subscribe here for our YouTube channel to get your fix of the best in food/drink/fun.

Esther Zuckerman is a senior entertainment writer at Thrillist. Follow her on Twitter @ezwrites.