You Should Be Negotiating Rent on Your NYC Apartment. Here's How.

Negotiate Rent
Jason Hoffman/Thrillist
Jason Hoffman/Thrillist

As you may have noticed, it’s not exactly cheap to rent an apartment in New York City. As of March 2017, the average rent for a one-bedroom apartment was $2,711 a month. But factors like an influx of new developments and a continued demand for cheaper housing are causing prices to drop -- if only a little -- meaning potential renters may have more power over lease stipulations, broker fees, and concessions than they thought.

In February, Curbed reported that concessions (like comped building fees or a free month’s rent) had hit an all-time high, with more than 30% of leases including an allowance of some type. Brooklyn, in particular, saw the number of concessions in a lease agreement triple from last year.

That means there’s no reason you should be settling for the asking price on a rental without haggling a bit. Figuring out how to negotiate can be tricky, so we asked NYC real-estate experts how to find money-saving incentives and lower rent on your next apartment lease.

First things first: Current renters have the most negotiating power

According to TripleMint’s director of agent development, Brian McFadden, current renters have the best chance of getting a break in rent on the apartments they currently live in. Because you already have a reputation with your landlord or management company -- and because your departure could mean a costly vacancy -- you’re in the best position to negotiate your yearly increase.

Look for apartments in the winter

“This is typically a slow season, especially around the holidays,” explains Jason Tonge, a sales partner at Prime Real Estate Group. Renting in the summer brings way more competition and higher prices, so try to get yourself on a winter-rental schedule, if possible. “There will be fewer places on the market; however, there are also fewer people looking to move... so landlords show a little wiggle room to well-qualified tenants.”

Try renting from independent landlords or small management companies

“The size of the management company or landlord determines how much negotiating power you will have,” McFadden says. A private owner would much rather accept a lower monthly rent than absorb months of lost rent from a vacant apartment.

Take advantage of unfavorable building conditions

“Certain [aspects] of the building or the apartment may be an invitation to a negotiation,” explains TripleMint agent Olgierd Minkiewicz. “Anything from garbage and recycling bins outside the bedroom window, a poorly maintained staircase, old appliances, crooked floors, or not-so-perfect water pressure in the bathroom” are windows of opportunity for potential renters to negotiate a lower monthly price.

Offer cash up-front

Renters with cash can sometimes sweeten the deal for a landlord by offering to pay a few months in advance or by putting down an additional security deposit in exchange for a lower monthly rent.

Set realistic expectations

Be careful (and realistic) when you’re negotiating your rent -- making a too-low offer can sometimes hurt a renter’s application. “There is always room for negotiation, but trying to get $400 off a $2,100 studio on the Upper West Side will most likely not be taken seriously.” Minkiewicz says.

If you can’t get your rent lowered, search for other incentives

Landlords may not always be able to offer lower rent, but they’re often willing to incentivize renters with other perks. “Consider lowering your cost by requesting concessions from your landlord instead of actually changing your rent,” McFadden suggests. A landlord or management company may offer rent-free months, or comp standard add-ons like parking and gym access. He or she may also agree to pay the broker fee. 

Sign up here for our daily NYC email and be the first to get all the food/drink/fun New York has to offer.

Melanie Taryn Lieberman has lived in apartments all across Boston, Brooklyn, and Jersey City. She’s successfully negotiated move-in dates and new, stainless steel appliances.