Rocket Fuel

Fire Island Rocket Fuel Drink Recipe
Matthew Kelly/Supercall

The Piña Colada just wasn’t boozy enough for the folks on Fire Island, NY, so bartenders came up with Rocket Fuel, the coconut cocktail’s bigger, boozier cousin. While this tropical drink is best enjoyed on the car-free, clothing-optional island, it’s nearly as good served cold and frosty at home. One glass of the boozed-up beverage turns a simple afternoon spent ankle-deep in a kiddie pool into a dream vacation. The cocktail gets its potent kick from a hit of nutty amaretto, which joins the tried-and-true combo of pineapple juice, rum and coconut, as well as a “fuel injection” of 151-proof rum, which goes straight into the straw, ensuring that first sip sends you sky high.

Rocket Fuel



  • 2.5 oz dark rum
  • 2.5 oz Amaretto
  • 1 oz coconut cream
  • 6 oz pineapple juice
  • Splash of Milk
  • crushed ice
  • 1.5 oz 151
  • Brandied Cherry


Step one

Pour dark rum, amaretto, cream of coconut, pineapple juice and milk into a blender with crushed ice.

Step two

Blend until smooth (add more ice if necessary), and pour into a Hurricane glass.

Step three

Carefully pour the 151 into a straw using a speed pourer (count out about four “Mississippis”), and garnish the drink with a cherry.

Contributed by Supercall