“Get me as much pizza as I realistically want to eat while you sit there and watch me put down a whole pie, while still thinking I’m the most amazing person in the world.” - Gabbi, 26
“I want that homemade pizza you implied you'd be making all the time approximately 85 dates ago." - Sophie, 28
“I want a 12-pack of tacos. Seriously. And if he throws in a gallon of iced tea, we can negotiate some… extracurriculars. All of the other crap is lost on me… all I want is tacos, iced tea, and some cuddling.” - Paula, 26
Alcohol, but it doesn't need to carry a big price tag
A pricey bottle of red might channel visions of equally red hearts and classic V-Day celebrations, but the women we talked to really weren't that picky.
“I’d really like a bottle of Yellow Tail, and an It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia marathon.” - Nessa, 25
“Alcohol. I’m so, so single.” - Mel, 25
While we all like to think we fundamentally understand our partners better than anyone on this planet, the women we talked to were shockingly frank about the most practical gift. Hey, you tell your mom all the time just to give you cash instead of the Criterion Blu-Rays of Doctor Zhivago, and you still love her, right?