Polly Ann has a rotating selection of 500 flavors, 50 of which are offered at a time, and can range from classics (Chocolate Chip is always a good choice) to their best seller, Star Wars: mint ice cream with marshmallows and a blue tint. If you can't decide, spin their flavor wheel and you may even win a free cone!
Time stands still in the best way possible at this 66-year-old Sunset classic, where you can still ask the staff to spin the big wheel to pick your flavor for you. If you prefer to retain freedom of choice, we like the Jasmine Tea, Lychee, and “Bumpy Freeway,” aka Rocky Road. Don’t fall too in love with any of the more obscure flavors because Polly Ann makes 500 flavors in total, “only” 50 of which are available at any given time.
How to order: Walk-ins welcome. You can also get select pints and milkshakes for pickup or delivery online.