With massive portions, a lively staff, and a no-frills attitude, this corner classic has everything one looks for when seeking out Italian dining. Established in 1990, Club Lucky sits inside a former Polish dance hall where the 1940s-era flair and contagious carefree energy still lingers. The neighborhood favorite showcasing Sicilian traditions via handmade stuffed pastas, grilled pork chops, and a divine Chicken Marsala, served smothered in mushrooms over fresh pappardelle. A darn good martini will help you wash it all down, and don’t skip the notorious profiteroles, if you know what’s good for you.
How to book: Reserve via Resy or order take-out and delivery online.
This quintessentially old-school Italian hang offers a unique take on the traditional Cosmo, instead slinging a concoction they call the Flirtini made with the addition of blood orange, mango, and passion fruit-infused liqueur. Known for their martinis, Club Lucky is also a go-to supper club-styled joint where the pasta is always on point.