Gray Brothers Cafeteria

Indianapolis

American Restaurant

$$$$

Situated in the far south-side town of Mooresville, this huge roadside edifice has been doling out comfort food since 1944. Gray Brothers is a giant cafeteria (seating capacity is 400-plus) serving traditional American fare that’s anything but cafeteria-like: It's much-lauded buffet offers a massive list of goodies, including peerless fried chicken, homemade chicken & beef noodles, and succulent roast pork. Dessert options span basically every pie variety known to man -- from sugar cream to the establishment’s signature strawberry. You'll want to prepare for a mean food coma. No, seriously, bring a designated driver to get your sleepy self home.