Nine One Five
Finding top-notch seafood in Key West isn't always easy, but this fine dining spot in an old Victorian house on Duval does it better than anyone on the island. The lobster ravioli is a wise choice and uses a light tomato sauce, leaving room for you to try the humongous tentacle that comes with the grilled octopus. The meats are done to perfection, too, including a Kobe beef Bolognese pappardelle, chipotle pork tacos, and a Florida grass-fed burger. With food this impeccable, you'll forget you're eating just steps from bars with refillable plastic cups and Jimmy Buffett blasting.