Lickety Split Ice Cream

New York
Lickety Split Ice Cream

295 City Island Avenue

City Island, NY 10464

Housed in what looks like an old cottage, this ice cream shop has a 1950s vibe and a solid amount of outdoor seating for those hot days when ice cream is almost necessary. They serve sorbet, hard ice cream, gelato and frozen yogurt, offering a few homemade flavors in addition to known ice cream brands. The servers are notoriously over-generous with portion sizes, so be sure to stock up on napkins.