5681 Route 28
Phoenicia, NY 12464
The Phoenicia Diner in Phoenicia, New York has been around since 1962. It was originally located on Island, but in the 80s they picked up the whole damn building and moved it to Phoenicia, finally refurbishing it in 2012. The exterior looks like the cover of a hipster magazine, meaning it's so retro you can easily go #nofilter on the Instagram. The food takes it way beyond the typical diner fare, with locally smoked fish and house-cured corned beef hash, so slide up on a stool and stay a while for the killer Bloody Marys and breakfast served all day.