Venue Info

Penny dubs itself as “the only ice cream shop in Santa Cruz making small batches of ice cream completely from scratch in house.” That extra love comes through in classic flavors like Tahitian Vanilla and even more so in special flavors like Earl Grey, Vegan Chocolate Sorbet, and Whiskey Custard. Important: you MUST get the Toasted Marshmallow Fluff topping. It’s as amazing as it sounds.

San Francisco

The Penny Ice Creamery

Amy Copperman/Thrillist

Penny dubs itself as “the only ice cream shop in Santa Cruz making small batches of ice cream completely from scratch in house.” That extra love comes through in classic flavors like Tahitian Vanilla and even more so in special flavors like Earl Grey, Vegan Chocolate Sorbet, and Whiskey Custard. Important: you MUST get the Toasted Marshmallow Fluff topping. It’s as amazing as it sounds.