This teeny tiny venue on the Upper West Side caused quite the stir when it swung open its doors in 2017—and years later still attracts lines. Mama’s Too specializes in a thick, square-cut style that makes the perfect vehicle for whipped ricotta, crispy pepperoni cups, and other topping options, but some of the varieties are also available to order in a traditional round style if you want a true slice.
The dish: Pizza
Nearest polling place: West Side High School, 140 W 102nd Street
New Yorkers eat pizza while walking down the street and even sitting on the subway, so why not take it with you to the polls? At Mama’s Too, a popular uptown joint that opened in 2017, a simple slice of cheese or pepperoni would do well because you can fold it (as all good New Yorkers should) for easy eating while you’re in line. But the shop is also known for dense square slices of pepperoni and sandwich specials that are sure to fill you up before your vote.
How to order: Pick up online