Mount Gay Black Barrel - $30
From a gang of time-tested rum runners, this stuff is good, alone or in a seasonal (or off-seasonal) Dark and Stormy. It's a small batch, handcrafted blend, matured in a process called finishing, then aged in deeply charred Bourbon oak barrels. What's this mean? Delicious, full-bodied rum with notes of anise, candied fruit, caramel, vanilla, and coffee beans.